So you're arguing over a couple of million? I bet we were bringing him back in any case. We'd all love stars at every position, but we have so many holes to fill. Personally I think if need be we go with a pass rush of Micah, Tank, Armstrong, Golston, high draft pick or serviceable FA.
For me the greater concern is an O-line that has Steele as the only RT, no LG (unless you think McGovern standing there as a speed dump counts), and no cover for Tyron WHEN he gets injured......oh and we also could do with re-signing Kearse and improve the WR Corp.