Bart Scott: "Dak Prescott hasn't even reached Alex Smith's level"

[TexasHillbilly]

Dak has won games when the team scored 6 points

Dak has won games when he has thrown for 0 Tds and multiple Interceptions

Dak has lost games when he had good passer ratings

Dak has won games when he had poor passer ratings

Using wins to evaluate a QB is about the dumbest thing someone can do

Couldn't you say this about several qb's if not all of them?

85% of all men over 60 have hemorrhoids. I just pulled that one out of my "you know what", kinda like you just did.

 

[MWH1967]

Bart Scott, just another ex player, talking head through his butt with Dallas Cowboys envy.

I wish I could give more than one like. Not saying he's totally wrong but, he's not right. Our QB has flaws just not to this extent.

 

[G2]

At you think ima waste anymore time arguing with a Dak Stanley

Steady Dezzie

 

[JoeKing]

Bart Scott was already an idiot, plus he's proven himself to be a hater of the Cowboys and even less of a fan of Dak. Why should we pay attention to a single word he has to say about anything?

 

[WillieBeamen]

Couldn't you say this about several qb's if not all of them?

85% of all men over 60 have hemorrhoids. I just pulled that one out of my "you know what", kinda like you just did.

What a stupid post


Refute anything I said. Tell me how smart it is to evaluate a QB based of his record.

Because the coach everyone on here hates has the same record over that span....

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

At you think ima waste anymore time arguing with a Dak Stanley

Awe, Timmy's gonna cry

 

[gjkoeppen]

Yes those are facts. He does not have elite arm strength or accuracy. And LOL at you thinking arm strength = solely how far you can throw a football

Gee I remember when in the off season on ABC they had the NFL football challenge and the last event was the QB's throwing the ball as far as they could and the winner was always proclaimed the QB with the strongest arm.
.

 

[GMO415]

He has the highest completion ever by any QB in his first three years.....

He has the highest 4th quarter comebacks than any other QB

Dude was a rookie and brought his team back from 17 points in his first playoff game.

The dudes a winner. That alone can't be disputed

 

[WillieBeamen]

Gee I remember when in the off season on ABC they had the NFL football challenge and the last event was the QB's throwing the ball as far as they could and the winner was always proclaimed the QB with the strongest arm.
.

Trust me you dont want to bring up skills challenge while discussing Dak

 

[TexasHillbilly]

What a stupid post


Refute anything I said. Tell me how smart it is to evaluate a QB based of his record.

Because the coach everyone on here hates has the same record over that span....

I am just saying that you could say that about many a player (all your questions).

After 11 years, let's compare the 2 qb's. Right now there really is no comparison.

Oh yes, Dak is the better qb.

 

[jazzcat22]

Gee I remember when in the off season on ABC they had the NFL football challenge and the last event was the QB's throwing the ball as far as they could and the winner was always proclaimed the QB with the strongest arm.
.

Man, I forgot about those competitions. That was as close to we got for off season news back then.

 

[Jake]

Pipe dream to get him in Dallas.

Some of us wholeheartedly disagree. He can stay in Michigan. Maybe he'll manage to beat Ohio State someday?

 

[morat1959]

If we’re going to cherry pick ex NFL players, you should know that the ones who think this about Dak are in the minority

How do you know this? Are you in the NFL inner circle? I think you’re just saying this to fit your narrative.

 

[ESisback]

Nothing but facts spoken from an elite NFL defender in this short clip. Dak is a 20M/yr QB MAX.

And yet, guys like him go gaga over guys like Watson or Haskins or the kid from Baltimore.

 

[morat1959]

All those dump offs on 3rd and 8+ yards that don’t get first downs really pull those #s up. A lot of em would get a first down if he could hit a receiver in stride at 5-8 yards.

He lacks elite arm strength and accuracy



Now go ahead and quote his completion % and make a fool of yourself...

 

[jazzcat22]

Some of us wholeheartedly disagree. He can stay in Michigan. Maybe he'll manage to beat Ohio State someday?

Nah, let him keep losing to them. My neighbor down the street will be in pain.

He is an UM fan, me OSU. His 2 sons, one UM, the other OSU. His 2 sons went to high school with Jim Tressel's kids. So imagine that when he was named HC for OSU.

 

[atlantacowboy]

The fact Dak has a lot to prove is not news. He was really good as a rookie. His 2nd year was a mess. Last year he seemed to have turned a corner once Cooper arrived..............but that advantage might not hold after DC's get an offseason to study our offense. We just don't know enough to give him 30+ million per and not worry about it. Jerry is doing the right thing not rushing into a contract. If Dak has a good year, its probably a done deal.

 

[bsbellomy]

I agree with Bart but he is wayyyy better then Alex Smith.

He's not FOUR y's better than Alex Smith. Lets not get carried away here.

 

[DFWJC]

He has the highest 4th quarter comebacks than any other QB

Dak is fine, but this is fake news.

 

[gjkoeppen]

Trust me you dont want to bring up skills challenge while discussing Dak

I noticed that you didn't say anything about your strong arm comment.
.