Best QB Game

[cowboyeric8]

And I grasp your inability.

So my opinion is my inability? If you are just going to bash who vote for, whats the point of putting said player on the list? If a player I like is on the list I will vote for them.

 

[CaptainAmerica]

I don't think so, Elway won, what, like 6 SB's singlehandedly.

You mean got to 6 SBs, right?

 

[CowboyMike]

Roger Staubach 92
Joe Montana 91-
Otto Graham 57
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 20+
Troy Aikman 8

 

[Rampage]

Roger Staubach 92
Joe Montana 92+
Otto Graham 57
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 19-
Troy Aikman 8
_______________

 

[rcaldw]

Oh I grasp the concept and its my opinion. And anytime

Just realize that if you don't buy the hype that has been attached to a lot of these guys for years, then you are viewed as having an "inability".

I've seen John Elway stink it up with the best of them. Same with Roger (who is my 2nd favorite of all time). Legends don't have to mirror reality, they just have to mirror perception.

I agree with you Eric, Aikman was better, but he will never be PERCEIVED as better, because it doesn't look as hard to throw 15-20 yard patterns on perfect time, again and again and again, as it does to scramble around and then throw it half way across the field. One LOOKS more dynamic than the other. Troy's abilities won more games. More games than any QB of any decade, PERIOD.

 

[The Rawhide Kid]

Just realize that if you don't buy the hype that has been attached to a lot of these guys for years, then you are viewed as having an "inability".

I've seen John Elway stink it up with the best of them. Same with Roger (who is my 2nd favorite of all time). Legends don't have to mirror reality, they just have to mirror perception.

I agree with you Eric, Aikman was better, but he will never be PERCEIVED as better, because it doesn't look as hard to throw 15-20 yard patterns on perfect time, again and again and again, as it does to scramble around and then throw it half way across the field. One LOOKS more dynamic than the other. Troy's abilities won more games. More games than any QB of any decade, PERIOD.

I'm disappointed in your inability to grasp the concept that Elway is perceived as better because he was never a Cowboy.

 

[rcaldw]

I'm disappointed in your inability to grasp the concept that Elway is perceived as better because he was never a Cowboy.

Actually there is MUCH truth in the point that you make.

 

[The Rawhide Kid]

Actually there is MUCH truth in the point that you make.

Direct all questions to the Anti-Cowboy Propaganda Machine, or ESPN. Both will work.

 

[cowboyeric8]

Just realize that if you don't buy the hype that has been attached to a lot of these guys for years, then you are viewed as having an "inability".

I've seen John Elway stink it up with the best of them. Same with Roger (who is my 2nd favorite of all time). Legends don't have to mirror reality, they just have to mirror perception.

I agree with you Eric, Aikman was better, but he will never be PERCEIVED as better, because it doesn't look as hard to throw 15-20 yard patterns on perfect time, again and again and again, as it does to scramble around and then throw it half way across the field. One LOOKS more dynamic than the other. Troy's abilities won more games. More games than any QB of any decade, PERIOD.

I would not trade Troy's accuracy for anyone's. And he was always cool under pressure.

 

[jackrussell]

Just realize that if you don't buy the hype that has been attached to a lot of these guys for years, then you are viewed as having an "inability".

Well then you realized wrong. The question was as not to an inability of opinion...but rather an inability to grasp the concept of the game. I clearly stated that, obviously you all are having an inability on comprehension also.

When the poster flat comes out and says he took points off player A because 'he had some to give' as opposed the real reason you're supposed to subtract them...then yes...an absolute inability to understand the concept, it can't be denied.

 

[cowboyeric8]

Well then you realized wrong. The question was as not to an inability of opinion...but rather an inability to grasp the concept of the game. I clearly stated that, obviously you all are having an inability on comprehansion also.

When the poster flat comes out and says he took points off player A because 'he had some to give' as opposed the real reason you're supposed to subtract them...then yes...an absolute inability to understand the concept, it can't be denied.

:laugh2: is it really that easy to get under your skin?

You can't tell me that most of the people on this board did exactly what I did.

Ok, its settled than.

Joe Montana 299

Well we can't put Roger there because then we would be homers right?

 

[jackrussell]

:laugh2: is it really that easy to get under your skin?

You can't tell me that most of the people on this board did exactly what I did.

Ok, its settled than.

Joe Montana 299

Well we can't put Roger there because then we would be homers right?

I work with mentally challenged kids every day...you're a walk in the park.

 

[Vintage]

Roger Staubach 92
Joe Montana 90
Otto Graham 56-
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 20+
Troy Aikman 10


I figure, Graham's got some points to spare...

 

[Wolfpack]

This lasted longer than I thought before it turned into a turd fest.

 

[jackrussell]

Roger Staubach 92
Joe Montana 90
Otto Graham 56-
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 20+
Troy Aikman 10


I figure, Graham's got some points to spare...

Excellent opinion!

 

[jackrussell]

This lasted longer than I thought before it turned into a turd fest.

Well we can thank the children.

 

[rcaldw]

Well we can thank the children.

Truthfully though Jack, I've enjoyed the game, it was a really good idea. And I'm being serious.

 

[Pukindog]

Roger Staubach 93 +
Joe Montana 89 -
Otto Graham 56
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 20
Troy Aikman 10

 

[Jimz31]

Roger Staubach 93
Joe Montana 88-
Otto Graham 57+
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 20
Troy Aikman 10

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

Roger Staubach 94+
Joe Montana 87-
Otto Graham 57
Johnny Unitas 31
John Elway 19-
Troy Aikman 10

Edited to correct count.