Best QB Game

[Skinsmaniac]

Roger Staubach 122+
Joe Montana 60-

Roger Staubach 120-
Joe Montana 61+


With the way the scoring is now, it would take twice as many people to vote for Montana for him to win.

 

[The Rawhide Kid]

Yeah it's been pretty clear, for a while, in both this thread and the RB one that it would likely be a lot of homer voting.

Nothing wrong with, the guys being voted for are both fantastic, but I think it's a little on the bias side to honestly believe that either Roger or Emmitt are the best, all time, at their positions.

While the homer in me says Roger was the best, I wholeheartedly believe the facts support Emmitt as the best RB of all time. He broke Walter's record and, although Brown and Sanders COULD have set records, they didn't because they left the game. Whether it be because they didn't love the game or couldn't take the wear and tear, they left the game. Even though he might have played a year or two longer past his prime, Emmitt was able to play and survive his career in the NFL to be able to set the records. Just because he played for the Cowboys, I don't believe it's biased to think he was the greatest.

Roger Staubach 118-
Joe Montana 62+

 

[DallasEast]

Scoring system= +1 & -2

Roger Staubach 119+
Joe Montana 60-

 

[Eskimo]

Scoring system= +1 & -2

Roger Staubach 117-
Joe Montana 61+

 

[Jimz31]

Scoring system= +1 & -2

Roger Staubach 118+
Joe Montana 59-

 

[jackrussell]

Like it wasn't going to happen anyway?

Some people can look past there homeristic views and appreciate football greatness for what it really is...and some just aren't mature enough to handle that reality.

While this game would never settle a debate on who the absolute greatest of anything is...it can at least quantify some of the integrity and merit each individual voter holds, or lack thereof.

I'd like to especially thank Thumper for at least presenting fundemental knowledge of the game and it's past, for taking the time and effort for shedding some intellectual light on the subjects presented. He exemplified exactly what I was hoping could take place. And it's not like I say that because I agree with him on everything, as our voting records will attest that we don't.

But it was just great to try and reason out some rational thinking, and not just he's the greatest because he was a Cowboy. But that's how the big boys do it, I'll leave the rest to the adolescent mindset.

 

[Pukindog]

Roger Staubach 119 +
Joe Montana 57 -

 

[jackrussell]

Roger Staubach 117-
Joe Montana 58+

 

[THUMPER]

Some people can look past there homeristic views and appreciate football greatness for what it really is...and some just aren't mature enough to handle that reality.

While this game would never settle a debate on who the absolute greatest of anything is...it can at least quantify some of the integrity and merit each individual voter holds, or lack thereof.

I'd like to especially thank Thumper for at least presenting fundemental knowledge of the game and it's past, for taking the time and effort for shedding some intellectual light on the subjects presented. He exemplified exactly what I was hoping could take place. And it's not like I say that because I agree with him on everything, as our voting records will attest that we don't.

But it was just great to try and reason out some rational thinking, and not just he's the greatest because he was a Cowboy. But that's how the big boys do it, I'll leave the rest to the adolescent mindset.

Very kind words Jack and I thank you for them. I also thank you for the games as they have given me something to look forward to every morning (or before I go to bed) during this down time of "pacman" speculation and mock drafts.

That said, here's my new vote:

Roger Staubach 118 +
Joe Montana 56 -

I don't believe that Staubach was the greatest of all time but he was better than Montana IMO.

 

[Cowboy Bill Watts]

+1; -2

Roger Staubach 119+
Joe Montana 54-

 

[Wolfpack]

+1; -2

Roger Staubach 117-
Joe Montana 55+

 

[Rackat]

+1; -2

Roger Staubach 118+
Joe Montana 53-

 

[zrinkill]

+1; -2

Roger Staubach 119+
Joe Montana 51-

 

[adamknite]

Roger Staubach 120+
Joe Montana 49-

 

[big dog cowboy]

Roger Staubach 121+
Joe Montana 47-

 

[Chuck 54]

Roger Staubach 119-
Joe Montana 48+

 

[Dhragon]

Roger Staubach 117-
Joe Montana 49+

 

[Boom]

Roger Staubach 115-
Joe Montana 50+

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Roger Staubach 113-
Joe Montana 51+

 

[coach316]

Roger Staubach 111-
Joe Montana 52+