Best Quartbacks in NFL History Tier List

[Hawkeye0202]

Moderator Edit: https://www.sogsports.com/best-quarterbacks-of-all-time-tier-list/

Interesting ........Marino with no ring on tier 2 and Aikman with three on tier 3, same as Eli Manning. As good as he is, P Mahomes on the list is a bit premature.

 

[kskboys]

That is one of the poorest attempts at ranking QB's I've ever seen. Whomever did this should have their football card taken away.

 

[john van brocklin]

Interesting ........Marino with no ring on tier 2 and Aikman with three on tier 3, same as Eli Manning. As good as he is, P Mahomes on the list is a bit premature.

What was the ranking criteria?
Regular season stats?
SB wins?
I am confused....

 

[Brax]

Interesting ........Marino with no ring on tier 2 and Aikman with three on tier 3, same as Eli Manning. As good as he is, P Mahomes on the list is a bit premature.

This list is a joke, who are the SOG football morons that put this out.

 

[G2]

Wait, this is a real thing? I admit it's subjective, but this is a big swing & a miss.

 

[rags747]

Aikman and Eli on same tier!? In a world of Fairy Dust and Unicorns maybe.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

I wish they would actually rank these in terms of skill and not just in terms of how you did in your era of competition.

Otto Graham?
Joe Namath?
Sid Luckman?
N.V. Brocklin?
Sammy Baugh?

They should be their own lists. There's back ups in the NFL today that would dominate in their time periods.

P.S. Joe Namath is the most overrated football player ever.

 

[kskboys]

Aikman and Eli on same tier!? In a world of Fairy Dust and Unicorns maybe.

Even worse, Staubach also on the same tier.

 

[kskboys]

Brady is not by himself in tier one. Not even close. There's prolly 5 Qb's in tier one. If all a person wants to do is count super bowls, then there's no reason to make a list anyway.

 

[zrinkill]

I refuse to even comment on this stupidity ...... Oh dang!

 

[tyke1doe]

Once I saw Drew Brees and Aaron Rodgers above Dan Marino and John Elway, I hit the hard stop.

 

[cowboyec]

my #1 will always be roger.
STAUBACH
troy is too low.
don meredith should be in there in my totally biased opinion.

 

[jazzcat22]

What was the ranking criteria?
Regular season stats?
SB wins?
I am confused....

That was my 1st thought as well, what the hell is this based on.
Another useless opinion chart / list.

 

[phildadon86]

Interesting ........Marino with no ring on tier 2 and Aikman with three on tier 3, same as Eli Manning. As good as he is, P Mahomes on the list is a bit premature.

When I saw Roger under Marino I laughed. This is a joke.

 

[baltcowboy]

Interesting ........Marino with no ring on tier 2 and Aikman with three on tier 3, same as Eli Manning. As good as he is, P Mahomes on the list is a bit premature.

Wow. A Cowboys hater made this list. I never saw Stauback play but I hear he was the best overall quarterback in the 70s. Russ, Eli, Big Ben on the same line as Aikman. Drew Brees (stat padder) and Steve Young over Aikman. I will even defend the Romo lovers McNabb, Bledsoe and Stafford are not a tier over Romo.

 

[Ranched]

This is ONLY an individual' opinion. And that individual is DEAD wrong. Again, everyone has their own opinion.

 

[CouchCoach]

Where do y’all find this stuff. Can just anybody do their own ranking? At least this joker found bubble gum pics of the QB’s.

Ya got ya choice of Aikman, Staubach or E. Manning. Who ya gonna call?

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Where do y’all find this stuff. Can just anybody do their own ranking? At least this joker found bubble gum pics of the QB’s.

Ya got ya choice of Aikman, Staubach or E. Manning. Who ya gonna call?

What? Is Otto Graham busy or something?

 

[ShortRound]

I stopped looking after seeing Brees above Marino, Elway, and Aikman. load of crap.

 

[75boyz]

Just on the pure physical ability to consistently and accurately make all the professional throws its Rodgers and Marino.

This is my opinion and does not include ALL the everything else categories that go into being an NFL QB.

Just strictly the physical passing talent of the oblong ball.

Prime Marino or Rodgers.
Its one or the other imo.