Blogging The Boys - NFC East Grade Chart from nine sites

[Carter]

Saw one site that gave the Vikings a D and the Bears a C+. Rest was only A's and B's

 

[Joe Realist]

Walter football graded C+

 

[Kwyn]

Saw one site that gave the Vikings a D and the Bears a C+. Rest was only A's and B's

PFF gave Niners a D and the Vikings a C-

 

[rambo2]

Means absolutely nothing

However, they had an outstanding draft.

 

[conner01]

Means absolutely nothing

Nope. Educated guess. We won’t know for 3 years if it was good or bad. Overall I liked our draft. I wouldn’t have went WR at 12 but I do think the player we got will be really good

 

[gimmesix]

https://www.profootballnetwork.com/final-nfl-draft-grades-2025/

2025 NFL Draft Grades: Your One-Stop Shop for Analysis and Insights on Every Pick​

PFN
April 26, 2025

New York Giants​

Overall Draft Grade: B​

For better or worse, the ultimate ruling of the New York Giants’ 2025 NFL Draft class will be decided by Jaxson Dart’s outcome. If he becomes the franchise QB they believe he can be, then this class is a success. If Dart ends up being a bust, then it’ll be an irreconcilable stain on an otherwise excellent haul.

The Dart move was aggressive, and somewhat borne out of desperation for Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll, but at the very least, Dart does have the athleticism, toughness, and elastic arm to grow into a quality starter in time.

And credit where credit is due: The rest of the draft was stellar for New York. Abdul Carter is a blue-chip player, Darius Alexander and Marcus Mbow can be starters in the trenches. Cam Skattebo is a great RB to add to the stable, Thomas Fidone is a quality TE2, and Korie Black is good depth.

Dart’s development will make or break this group to a degree, but players like Carter also have the potential to impact the franchise in a positive way far past any QB transition. The Giants’ talent core has greatly improved, but it’s the wild card at QB that will shape the fate of the entire regime... Read more

___________________

PFN's grade is really the only outlier for the Giants. Remove its B grade and its composite grade would have remained an A- (3.81) but closer to an A (e.g. 3.90). More impressively, omitting the single T18 rank would shave its 4.8 overall rank to an even lower 3.1.

Essentially, BTB's summary suggests that New York's draft haul was not only head-and-shoulders above the rest of the NFC East. They blew the other division members completely out of the water. It is all speculation but a tiny bit humbling at the same time, albeit in an abstract way.

Thanks, Jaxson Dart. You really skewed their grade curve, lol.

It'll be interesting to see how the pass rushers turn out. There's clearly a reason that Carter was at the top of the class, but our guy may be the more NFL-ready player.

 

[shabazz]

Universally great draft we had. But we can revisit the grade in 3 years. I give them an A for effort.

I have no issue with the positions drafted. There weren't many DTs or MLBs we could have gotten true value from.

My issue is way more with the zero interest in spending money in FA to get REAL starters that aren't either over the hill or young busts

 

[Rayman70]

I have no issue with the positions drafted. There weren't many DTs or MLBs we could have gotten true value from.

My issue is way more with the zero interest in spending money in FA to get REAL starters that aren't either over the hill or young busts

Free agency was definitely concerning but at least we made a decent effort this time.

 

[Rayman70]

However, they had an outstanding draft.

We really did.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

 

[DallasEast]

LOL! Did the Browns get an incomplete from USA Today? Or did Rene Bugner not obtain the grade before their deadline?

 

[Rockport]

Means absolutely nothing

Not true. If the grade was C or worse you’d be crapping all over the draft. Oh wait, you’re doing that anyways.

 

[Kwyn]

LOL! Did the Browns get an incomplete from USA Today? Or did Rene Bugner not obtain the grade before their deadline?

Yep. Incomplete. lol

https://www.usatoday.com/story/spor...sses-2025-browns-shedeur-sanders/83271495007/

(incomplete)​

Think this assessment is a copout? Fine. But there’s no legitimate way to know what to make of this until the bigger picture comes into focus – at least a year from now. It’s tough to even know where to begin.

But let’s start with Thursday, when the Browns stunningly vacated the No. 2 spotand opportunity to take Travis Hunter, the 2024 Heisman Trophy winner quite possibly a generational prospect – not to mention one who seemingly would have fit well onto this roster and was glowingly praised by GM Andrew Berry the week before the draft.

But Berry punched out and wound up with DT Mason Graham (No. 5 pick) and battering ram RB Quinshon Judkins (No. 36 pick) as part of the compensation – both very good football players and doubtless Week 1 starters.

Second-round LB Carson Schwesinger should also be instantly productive, while electric fourth-round RB Dylan Sampson should be a fantastic foil to Judkins, who paired so well with Henderson at Ohio State.

 

[Kwyn]

great chart!

 

[XXLMike]

I don’t listen to a word Calvin Watkins says it’s all motivated for other reasons.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

LOL! Did the Browns get an incomplete from USA Today? Or did Rene Bugner not obtain the grade before their deadline?

I think the idea is since they gained a 2026 1st in a trade down, you can’t know how good these draft decisions were until that pick is used

 

[DallasEast]

Yep. Incomplete. lol

(incomplete)​

Think this assessment is a copout? Fine. But there’s no legitimate way to know what to make of this until the bigger picture comes into focus – at least a year from now. It’s tough to even know where to begin.

But let’s start with Thursday, when the Browns stunningly vacated the No. 2 spotand opportunity to take Travis Hunter, the 2024 Heisman Trophy winner quite possibly a generational prospect – not to mention one who seemingly would have fit well onto this roster and was glowingly praised by GM Andrew Berry the week before the draft.

But Berry punched out and wound up with DT Mason Graham (No. 5 pick) and battering ram RB Quinshon Judkins (No. 36 pick) as part of the compensation – both very good football players and doubtless Week 1 starters.

Second-round LB Carson Schwesinger should also be instantly productive, while electric fourth-round RB Dylan Sampson should be a fantastic foil to Judkins, who paired so well with Henderson at Ohio State.

lol. Nate Davis' rationale is quite literally a copout in and of itself. Every grader is using foresight, not hindsight. Everyone is going guesswork.

You assess what happened, including question marks, and make a decision. This is 2025, not 2026. As far as the Browns is concerned, his entire assessment is Kiper-like.

 

[5Stars]

I give them an F.

Until further notice.

 

[rambo2]

I give them an F.

Until further notice.

Their draft was outstanding.

 

[tomokawan]

Everyone gets As and Bs on this its like public school

Not my public school.