Brandin Cooks, who has played with Tom Brady and Drew Brees, with some high praise for Dak Prescott

[Captain-Crash]

Dak has won more playoff games than Herbert. Just saying.

Tim Tebow has a better play off record. Just saying

 

[GINeric]

OK.
Yet younger QBs than Prescott have had their teams win playoff games equal too or more than him, plus been in conference championship games with their teams - which Prescott has not.
Mahomes, Allen, Burrow, Hurts, Purdy.
Why single out Herbert for a comparison?

For starters those quarterbacks you've listed all had very good to great offensive coordinators as well. Dak had Garrett and Kellen Moore.

Which one of those coordinators are Garrett and Moore better than? I'll wait....

And while I wait for that one... you mentioned what Dak hasn't done, "big game" wise correct??? Ok, that's fair. Now let me ask you to please explain why Nick Foles and Trent Dilpher has the same amount of Superbowl wins as Aaron Rodgers??

- Jim Kelly has less Superbowl wins than Nick Foles and Trent Dilpher and both Foles and Dilpher have more Superbowl wins than Dan Marino.
- Jimmy Garoppolo is 4-0 vs Aaron Rodgers, did you know that?

Marino and Kelly are in the Hall of Fame. Many believe Aaron Rodgers is first ballot. Now with all of this information I've shared with you.... according to your logic, Foles, Dilpher and Garoppolo should all be in the Hall of Fame as well, according to your "QB big game win record", correct??

 

[GINeric]

Tim Tebow has a better play off record. Just saying

Nick Foles and Trent Dilpher have the same amount of Superbowl rings as Aaron Rodgers. Just saying....

 

[Motorola]

For starters those quarterbacks you've listed all had very good to great offensive coordinators as well. Dak had Garrett and Kellen Moore.

Which one of those coordinators are Garrett and Moore better than? I'll wait....

And while I wait for that one... you mentioned what Dak hasn't done, "big game" wise correct??? Ok, that's fair. Now let me ask you to please explain why Nick Foles and Trent Dilpher has the same amount of Superbowl wins as Aaron Rodgers??

- Jim Kelly has less Superbowl wins than Nick Foles and Trent Dilpher and both Foles and Dilpher have more Superbowl wins than Dan Marino.
- Jimmy Garoppolo is 4-0 vs Aaron Rodgers, did you know that?

Marino and Kelly are in the Hall of Fame. Many believe Aaron Rodgers is first ballot. Now with all of this information I've shared with you.... according to your logic, Foles, Dilpher and Garoppolo should all be in the Hall of Fame as well, according to your "QB big game win record", correct??

The discussion started about the young QBs entering the league - but you went down memory lane

 

[GINeric]

The discussion started about the young QBs entering the league - but you went down memory lane

Oh okay, well let me stay on track then. Dak had the same amount of playoff wins in his first 5, 6 seasons as Peyton Manning and Drew Brees.

That's what happened when he was a young qb coming into the league.

For the record, everything you've mentioned is memory lane at this point. This is a new season.

But before we end the conversation, can you explain why Jimmy Garoppolo is 4-0 vs Aaron Rodgers? Again, according to your logic does this mean that Garoppolo is the better quarterback between the two? Rodgers apparently can't beat this younger quarterback, right??