There is tape against top WR's like Perriman and Parker and ECU had the third best passing offense in the nation.
You are using a generalization to dismiss. You want to talk about my supposed lack of tangible evidence well your handwaving at his conference and stat lines is no better and less specific.
I am telling you specific talented offenses and WR he played and that there is tape on to make a apples to apples evaluation. If you do not understand how that subsumes your generalization for blanket dismissal then oh well.
Well I don't understand how naming his competition is generalizing. I guess you don't believe strength of competition means anything. That's almost as foolish to me as remarking about his inexperience as a positive when discussing his ability.
That's ok, we can agree to disagree. I'll be as specific as specific as possible. Let's look at ECU.
Here are some stats, can't get much more specific than this:
Shane Carden 38/64 445 2td 1int
Justin Hardy 14/186
Cam Worthy 7/138
Isaiah Jones 10/75
Here is the tape:
@:35 he gives up a ten yard completion and is literally barely in the frame.
@:45 gets away with blatant PI as he tackles the reciever
@1:06 gets a great jam,much props
@1:20 trips and falls down, gets flagged, gets bailed out by an "uncatchable ball" call.
@1:47 good job running through traffic
@2:06 gets away with holding the receivers arm down--that will get flagged in the NFL ( I point this out because even scouts have noted he is too handsy, because he lacks proper technique)
@2:54 does alright until his man changes direction, then loses him pretty bad
@3:50 gets a gift of a pick, although on a better thrown ball, he gives up a TD
@4:15 gets away with PI again and I believe this is where he hurt his shoulder...
Watch the tape. I am absolutely open to your interpretation. What I see is a guy who struggles when asked to do anything but run in a straight line with a receiver. He shows some great raw athleticism and some versatility to play in different schemes. He doesn't really show anything special in his coverage though. Without his combine I don't think he's done anything to separate himself from most of the other mid round corners.
As I have said and repeated ad infinitium, I don't think he is a bad player. I just don't think he is first round talent.