Which version of Thor? Cause Thor with Odin's power would probably trounce most of the list (Due to his powers considered being "magic," Kal El would likely not win (Much less Jon Kent) ) Thor without his fathers mantle would struggle against a lot of them. Captain Atom or Spectre would probably win overall (from what I remember of all these characters).
Per CBR's character mini-bio:
Marvel's God of Thunder is the Asgardian hero Thor, often considered the strongest superhero in the Marvel universe. His unmatched strength as an Asgardian god means he has few rivals. However, Thor increased his strength beyond Asgard's most powerful warriors through ancient runes and his connection to Mjolnir.
Thor performed feats of strength that would've been impossible for any other superhero, and he did so with ease. Other powerful characters referred to him as one of the strongest beings in the universe. Thor became one of the few characters who could challenge characters like Sentry and Hercules when needed.
The site does not distinguish which version but they do not mention Odin or even his royal lineage. I would say it is the latter version who replaced All-Father.
I have tons of respect for Thor Odinson. In my opinion, Jon Kent is more prone to magical attacks than his father as a Kryptonian/Human hybrid. I can see Jon being overwhelmed by Thor in short order.
Magic can potentially kill Kal-El but I would not automatically give Thor the victory in a head-to-head face-off. I would completely agree if Thor did a Loki and conjured kryptonite during the fight. Then I would consider Clark toast.
In this tournament, Thor is a #4 seed and Superman is a #3 seed. The only way they meet is in the final.
What I say next is just me and does not apply to anyone else's opinion. Unless something changes my mind, I do not see Thor advancing pass the Sweet Sixteen in my bracket. Personally, I blame CBR for ranking a certain mutant/cosmic entity as low as 10 in their list.
Like I said earlier, I do not completely agree with their rankings. And completely agree is an understatement.
