Comp pick question

[Verdict]

If we end up losing more than 4 net comp pick qualifying players does the formula bump up the level of the comp picks to a higher round??

 

[erod]

If we end up losing more than 4 net comp pick qualifying players does the formula bump up the level of the comp picks to a higher round??

I think it depends on how many Dallas signs.

But you have to have the **** decoder to figure out how the comp system works.

 

[KingintheNorth]

According to Nick at OvertheCap.com, here is where we are at right now with all of our signings & losses:

https://overthecap.com/compensatory-draft-picks-cancellation-chart/#nfc-east-2018

A 4th for Leary
A 5th for Church
Two 6's for Crawford and Wilcox

 

[Cowboys22]

I know what your asking but I don't know for sure. I don't think so though. If we lose 7 net qualifying free agents and the top 4 equate to a 4, 5, 5, 6, I don't think they take the value of the remaining 3 and add it in giving the team higher picks.

 

[KingintheNorth]

Talking to Nick some more on Twitter, if Claiborne signs a contract elsewhere for $5.6M APY or more, one of the 6's would turn into a 5.

 

[Cowboys22]

According to Nick at OvertheCap.com, here is where we are at right now with all of our signings & losses:

https://overthecap.com/compensatory-draft-picks-cancellation-chart/#nfc-east-2018

A 4th for Leary
A 5th for Church
Two 6's for Crawford and Wilcox

Church and Leary were UDFAs. The team got good use of them and look to gain a 4 & 5 back. That's not to shabby and should be the MO going forward.

 

[Alexander]

Talking to Nick some more on Twitter, if Claiborne signs a contract elsewhere for $5.6M APY or more, one of the 6's would turn into a 5.

That figures. If he signs with Baltimore at their current rumored offer, it is below the $5.6M.

 

[kiheikiwi]

According to Nick at OvertheCap.com, here is where we are at right now with all of our signings & losses:

https://overthecap.com/compensatory-draft-picks-cancellation-chart/#nfc-east-2018

A 4th for Leary
A 5th for Church
Two 6's for Crawford and Wilcox

So If Claiborne signs with the Ravens for $5,000.000 (think that's the rumor) that would be another 6th rounder ? Guess we will see if Carr signs with anyone also ....

 

[AbeBeta]

According to Nick at OvertheCap.com, here is where we are at right now with all of our signings & losses:

https://overthecap.com/compensatory-draft-picks-cancellation-chart/#nfc-east-2018

A 4th for Leary
A 5th for Church
Two 6's for Crawford and Wilcox

Don't fall in love with the 6ths. Those could easily be 7ths and may not exist at all if there are 32 higher value comp picks

 

[erod]

So If Claiborne signs with the Ravens for $5,000.000 (think that's the rumor) that would be another 6th rounder ? Guess we will see if Carr signs with anyone also ....

But these will all be for next year. Not this draft.

 

[LittleD]

It may be a few weeks before we have a good idea. We can only get a max of 4 comp picks for the 2018 (next year's draft) but,
since there are only 32 total comp picks for the NFL ours will get ranked in the 32. We could get 3 or less under many
scenarios depending who signs for higher money.

 

[KingintheNorth]

The goal should be to go out and get the best talent to help the team; comp picks 5 years down the road should not be a motivation.

 

[jterrell]

Don't fall in love with the 6ths. Those could easily be 7ths and may not exist at all if there are 32 higher value comp picks

agreed.
a WAG from me would be come next draft we have an extra 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th.
that's a great haul but we aren't exactly stacking top 100 picks.
re-signing DMC versus signing AP helps obviously.
team appears very aware of stacking these picks.

 

[kiheikiwi]

But these will all be for next year. Not this draft.

Yep, we get nothing this year. Was Just looking to see if we can somehow increase the value of the picks - doesn't really look like it. Really struggling to get a grip on this years draft, so many different positions needed to fill with late round picks. It's going to be difficult, and I keep going back and forth on our first pick, which will be critical to get right ! DE, CB, SS I've looked at each in the first and honestly have no idea what way to go - I guess in Will we trust ...

 

[Nightman]

If we end up losing more than 4 net comp pick qualifying players does the formula bump up the level of the comp picks to a higher round??

The max is 4 and there is no extra bonus for losing more than 4 net

At 9m AAV Leary is right on the cusp of 3rd/4th round..... it would have been a 3rd last year but will most likely be a 4th this years since more players were signed to larger deals

they had 11 3rd comps this year and that is way too many

the only benefit to losing more than 4 net FAs is that we can sign a couple of our own before losing one of the 4 comp picks

 

[erod]

Personally, I don't think comp picks should be given to teams, period.

 

[kiheikiwi]

The goal should be to go out and get the best talent to help the team; comp picks 5 years down the road should not be a motivation.

The only positive is that now that comp. picks can be traded, is that they can be used to help in trading up if we felt the need to. I.E. say if next year we wanted to trade up from 4th back into third and offer the 4th and say a 6th comp. pick. Just a hypothetical but more picks better - usually.

 

[Nightman]

Yep, we get nothing this year. Was Just looking to see if we can somehow increase the value of the picks - doesn't really look like it. Really struggling to get a grip on this years draft, so many different positions needed to fill with late round picks. It's going to be difficult, and I keep going back and forth on our first pick, which will be critical to get right ! DE, CB, SS I've looked at each in the first and honestly have no idea what way to go - I guess in Will we trust ...

Knowing we are getting 4 comp picks this year we could always trade a 2018 4th for a 5th this year

A little instant gratification and present day value of money to even things out

We don't need 11 picks next year and no 5th this year

 

[jterrell]

The goal should be to go out and get the best talent to help the team; comp picks 5 years down the road should not be a motivation.

this is part of the rules of operation and utilizing an approach that nets extra draft picks is simply smart management.
dallas look to be on an every other year plan regarding free agency and that is all built into the cap spreadsheets as well.
keep in mind Dak was added with a comp selection.

the draft comp is 12 months down the road not 5 years. the Dak selection paid dividends 12 months later not 5 years.

 

[Cowboys22]

Don't fall in love with the 6ths. Those could easily be 7ths and may not exist at all if there are 32 higher value comp picks

There won't be 32 higher picks awarded. There are always 7th round comps picks given out. Dallas will get their 4 unless they sign several more free agents.