Cowboys OL vs Eagles OL

[xwalker]

ESPN recently claimed the Eagle have a top 5 OLine.

Maybe even at LT but Peters is getting old.
Eagles better at RT.
Cowboys significantly better on all interior positions.
Cowboys with better backups.


Eagles
Jason Peters 7x Pro Bowl, 6x All Pro, Age 33
Allen Barbre 8 games started in 8 year career.
Jason Kelce Pro Bowl 2014, has played 4 years.
Matt Tobin UDFA 2013, 7 games started
Lane Johnson 1st round pick, has played 2 years.

Top Backups
Andrew Gardner 8 starts in 5 seasons, cut by 4 other teams
Dennis Kelly 10 starts in 3 seasons, 5th round pick
David Molk Undersized 7th round pick by SD, but after 1 year
John Moffitt 3rd round pick by Seattle, traded for player that was cut after 3 weeks. Retired in 2013. Signed with the Eagles in 2015.

Cowboys
Tyron Smith 2x All Pro, 2x Pro Bowl
Ron Leary 33 games started, shut down JJ Watt
Travis Frederick 1x All Pro, 1x Pro Bowl
Zack Martin Pro Bowl and All Pro as a rookie
Doug Free I've heard he is a good golfer.

Top Backups
La'el Collins Projected 1st round pick in 2015 draft
Mackenzy Bernadeau 48 games started
Darrion Weems Developmental player in 2012, 2013, IR 2014

 

[Irvin88_4life]

If Collins was RT he would be better then Lane Johnson

 

[darthseinfeld]

ESPN recently claimed the Eagle have a top 5 OLine.

Maybe even at LT but Peters is getting old.
Eagles better at RT.
Cowboys significantly better on all interior positions.
Cowboys with better backups.


Eagles
Jason Peters 7x Pro Bowl, 6x All Pro, Age 33
Allen Barbre 8 games started in 8 year career.
Jason Kelce Pro Bowl 2014, has played 4 years.
Matt Tobin UDFA 2013, 7 games started
Lane Johnson 1st round pick, has played 2 years.

Top Backups
Andrew Gardner 8 starts in 5 seasons, cut by 4 other teams
Dennis Kelly 10 starts in 3 seasons, 5th round pick
David Molk Undersized 7th round pick by SD, but after 1 year
John Moffitt 3rd round pick by Seattle, traded for player that was cut after 3 weeks. Retired in 2013. Signed with the Eagles in 2015.

Cowboys
Tyron Smith 2x All Pro, 2x Pro Bowl
Ron Leary 33 games started, shut down JJ Watt
Travis Frederick 1x All Pro, 1x Pro Bowl
Zack Martin Pro Bowl and All Pro as a rookie
Doug Free I've heard he is a good golfer.

Top Backups
La'el Collins Projected 1st round pick in 2015 draft
Mackenzy Bernadeau 48 games started
Darrion Weems Developmental player in 2012, 2013, IR 2014

I would say Smith is better then Peters right now. Peters has always reminded me of Adams in that he will be dominant but will have a few games a year where he struggles.
The only stretch the last couple yeara Smith has struggled was last year when he had a high ankle sprain, and even then it was only against JPP it was noticable

 

[Manwiththeplan]

Hey xwalker, you know the rules, marry, shag, kill between Brian Broadus, Doug Free and Nick Hayden

 

[darthseinfeld]

If Collins was RT he would be better then Lane Johnson

I dont know, Lane is pretty good and could start at LT for most teams

 

[xwalker]

If Collins was RT he would be better then Lane Johnson

I would really like to see him practice at RT, but reports indicate he has all he can handle mentally to learn 1 position. Physically, I'm certain he could be better than Free.

 

[darthseinfeld]

Hey xwalker, you know the rules, marry, shag, kill between Brian Broadus, Doug Free and Nick Hayden

Kill Hayden, marry Free, shag Broadus

I mean, is there any other answer really

 

[Outlaw Heroes]

Kill Hayden, marry Free, shag Broadus

I mean, is there any other answer really

Feel like silence might work a bit better.

 

[DFWJC]

Not sure that
2014 Pro Bowler Frederick is significantly better than 2014 Pro Bowler Kelce.

Better yes.

I see our main advantage as being Zack Martin over who ever they put out there.
Also our top end depth is better

 

[darthseinfeld]

Feel like silence might work a bit better.

That's not how you play game mannnnnn

FMK is only for the most hardcore.

 

[xwalker]

Hey xwalker, you know the rules, marry, shag, kill between Brian Broadus, Doug Free and Nick Hayden

I think that is
Kill.
Have a beer with.
Fight.

I'll fight Bryan Broaddus.

I would like to go back in time to Aug 2014 and kill Doug Free (Then sign Parnell to a new contract before he proved himself).

I'll have a beer with Nick Hayden (hopefully during a Cowboys game).

 

[Manwiththeplan]

I think that is
Kill.
Have a beer with.
Fight.

I'll fight Bryan Broaddus.

I would like to go back in time to Aug 2014 and kill Doug Free (Then sign Parnell to a new contract before he proved himself).

I'll have a beer with Nick Hayden (hopefully during a Cowboys game).

yea, you cheated...well you did answer 1 out of 3 by the rules

 

[darthseinfeld]

FMK is to be played similarly to the Russian Roulette scene from Deer Hunter.

You guys aren't doing it right

 

[xwalker]

Not sure that
2014 Pro Bowler Frederick is significantly better than 2014 Pro Bowler Kelce.

Better yes.

I see our main advantage as being Zack Martin over who ever they put out there.
Also our top end depth is better

I said the group was significantly better. I didn't say each player was significantly better than their counterparts.

Having said that, Frederick was All Pro and a Pro Bowler. Kelce was not All Pro.

Martin was All Pro.

Leary shut down JJ Watt and played at a Pro Bowl type level when healthy. A lower body injury mid season caused him to be a little slowed for a few games including the 1st game against the Eagles. If healthy all season he would likely have received consideration for the Pro Bowl.

 

[darthseinfeld]

I said the group was significantly better. I didn't say each player was significantly better than their counterparts.

Having said that, Frederick was All Pro and a Pro Bowler. Kelce was not All Pro.

Martin was All Pro.

Leary shut down JJ Watt and played at a Pro Bowl type level when healthy. A lower body injury mid season caused him to be a little slowed for a few games including the 1st game against the Eagles. If healthy all season he would likely have received consideration for the Pro Bowl.

Factor in group play is critical and the Eagles will have 2 new starters at OG and lost ine of the best OG's in football

 

[xwalker]

I would say Smith is better then Peters right now. Peters has always reminded me of Adams in that he will be dominant but will have a few games a year where he struggles.
The only stretch the last couple yeara Smith has struggled was last year when he had a high ankle sprain, and even then it was only against JPP it was noticable

I was trying not to be too much of a homer.

 

[Manwiththeplan]

Factor in group play is critical and the Eagles will have 2 new starters at OG and lost ine of the best OG's in football

Eagles lost 2 very good guards in Evan Mathis and Todd Herremans (mid season IR)

 

[TrailBlazer]

Cowboys oline is much much better. Eagles still probably have one of the better lines in the league. Cowboys put a ton of resources into the oline and it shows. I've never heard anyone say the eagles line is as good as Dallas'.
.

 

[itsaboat]

If Peters gets injured the eagles are done. they have no depth on their line

 

[Plumfool]

Eagles loss of their guards is going to be a problem for them IMO.