Cowboys Truths

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,306
Reaction score
66,476
1: Tavon Austin's fumble problems were on Punts, not on offense. His career fumble rate is better than Zeke's 2016 fumble rate. I don't remember anybody complaining about Zeke fumbling.

2: Kris Richard with no "s" on the end.

3: Switzer didn't prove anything on offense. He didn't show the speed/elusiveness that I had hoped to see. Beasley wins by being a student of the game in regards to route nuances. I don't know if Switzer can do what Beasley has done. Switzer did not appear to be an option at outside WR.

4: Bo Scarbrough was a 7th round pick and didn't really play special teams in College. He'll have difficult time making the 53 if they count Austin as a RB. The coaches seem to love Rod Smith.

5: Where Jerry tried getting value from character or injury issue players, McClay likes to take players here and there that he believes are much better than their combine/ProDay performance. This year the DE Armstrong is that guy; although, both WRs somewhat fall into that category as well. Armstrong's college coach said he ran a 4.5x and almost all scouting reports praised his speed/quickness. Gallup's numbers were decent but he plays even faster than his timed speed. Same for Wilson. It appears that Armstrong gained too much weight prior to the Combine/Pro-Day.

6: The Cowboys are now very focused on good/great route running. Hurns/Gallup/Wilson are all above average route runners. Beasley has made it despite being tiny because he mastered the nuances of route running. TWill's only real skill is being an OK route runner (TWill is good route runner relative to Dez and Butler). We'll see about the TEs but the draft pick and UDFA both said they spent a lot of time over the years studying Jason Witten.

7: Big Fat DTs that can't move are basically extinct. The Zone Running scheme gashes DLines thst can't flow don't the line Laterally. Zone teams love to see a Big Slow DT. Many Man Blocking teams now run some zone. Even man blocking can run away from the Tub Of Lard player such that they just need 1 blocker to get in the way of that player on many run plays. The 340+ DTs like Snacks Harrison and Dontari Poe are freaks that can run faster than some DEnds.

8: Multiple stats and non-Cowboys focused analysis indicate Dak has been much more accurate than most fans believe.

9. When the highest paid player is a malcontent, that team will have problems. That player needs to go regardless of ability. The Patriots move on from those types of players even when they are great players. Chandler Jones, Jamie Collins, Logan Mankins, etc..

10: Jerry's influence on the draft seems to have been near zero the past two years. The 2nd round picks have been Awuzie and Connor Williams.

11: The "Linehan is running Garrett's offense" phrase should be officially buried. Many many things including direct quotes from Stephen Jones indicate Garrett is now out of offense game-planning starting this season. Linehan pushed out Pollack and Dooley as well as Dez. It seems that something happened to cause Witten to retire. The new WR coach has connections to Linehan and seems to be the opposite of previous WR coaches in the Garrett as HC era. It appears that Garrett was not in favor of the Dez cut; although evidence on that is limited.

12: Kris Richard was in the draft War Room often considering they drafted zero DBs.
 
2: Kris Richard with no "s" on the end.
You just took away a lot of extra posts over the next year :(

3: Switzer didn't prove anything on offense. He didn't show the speed/elusiveness that I had hoped to see. Beasley wins by being a student of the game in regards to route nuances. I don't know if Switzer can do what Beasley has done. Switzer did not appear to be an option at outside WR.
I've said it all along .. Switzer is fast. Beasley is quick. There's a difference.

6: The Cowboys are now very focused on good/great route running. Hurns/Gallup/Wilson are all above average route runners. Beasley has made it despite being tiny because he mastered the nuances of route running. TWill's only real skill is being an OK route runner (TWill is good route runner relative to Dez and Butler). We'll see about the TEs but the draft pick and UDFA both said they spent a lot of time over the years studying Jason Witten.
I will be curious in the years to come to find out if Dez was the only one with route issues.

9. When the highest paid player is a malcontent, that team will have problems. That player needs to go regardless of ability. The Patriots move on from those types of players even when they are great players. Chandler Jones, Jamie Collins, Logan Mankins, etc..
I never viewed Dez as a malcontent. He was passionate and let his emotions get the best of him, but I don't think he was a malcontent.

10: Jerry's influence on the draft seems to have been near zero the past two years. The 2nd round picks have been Awuzie and Connor Williams.
He will take credit if they do well though :)

11: The "Linehan is running Garrett's offense" phrase should be officially buried. Many many things including direct quotes from Stephen Jones indicate Garrett is now out of offense game-planning starting this season. Linehan pushed out Pollack and Dooley as well as Dez. It seems that something happened to cause Witten to retire. The new WR coach has connections to Linehan and seems to be the opposite of previous WR coaches in the Garrett as HC era. It appears that Garrett was not in favor of the Dez cut; although evidence on that is limited.
Neither have impressed me with their game plans, play calling or adjustments. Hopefully all of the personnel changes implies they will be making changes and improvements to their/his/whatever offensive system as well.

12: Kris Richard was in the draft War Room often considering they drafted zero DBs.
Likely part of the grooming process.
 
1: Tavon Austin's fumble problems were on Punts, not on offense. His career fumble rate is better than Zeke's 2016 fumble rate. I don't remember anybody complaining about Zeke fumbling.

2: Kris Richard with no "s" on the end.

3: Switzer didn't prove anything on offense. He didn't show the speed/elusiveness that I had hoped to see. Beasley wins by being a student of the game in regards to route nuances. I don't know if Switzer can do what Beasley has done. Switzer did not appear to be an option at outside WR.

4: Bo Scarbrough was a 7th round pick and didn't really play special teams in College. He'll have difficult time making the 53 if they count Austin as a RB. The coaches seem to love Rod Smith.

5: Where Jerry tried getting value from character or injury issue players, McClay likes to take players here and there that he believes are much better than their combine/ProDay performance. This year the DE Armstrong is that guy; although, both WRs somewhat fall into that category as well. Armstrong's college coach said he ran a 4.5x and almost all scouting reports praised his speed/quickness. Gallup's numbers were decent but he plays even faster than his timed speed. Same for Wilson. It appears that Armstrong gained too much weight prior to the Combine/Pro-Day.

6: The Cowboys are now very focused on good/great route running. Hurns/Gallup/Wilson are all above average route runners. Beasley has made it despite being tiny because he mastered the nuances of route running. TWill's only real skill is being an OK route runner (TWill is good route runner relative to Dez and Butler). We'll see about the TEs but the draft pick and UDFA both said they spent a lot of time over the years studying Jason Witten.

7: Big Fat DTs that can't move are basically extinct. The Zone Running scheme gashes DLines thst can't flow don't the line Laterally. Zone teams love to see a Big Slow DT. Many Man Blocking teams now run some zone. Even man blocking can run away from the Tub Of Lard player such that they just need 1 blocker to get in the way of that player on many run plays. The 340+ DTs like Snacks Harrison and Dontari Poe are freaks that can run faster than some DEnds.

8: Multiple stats and non-Cowboys focused analysis indicate Dak has been much more accurate than most fans believe.

9. When the highest paid player is a malcontent, that team will have problems. That player needs to go regardless of ability. The Patriots move on from those types of players even when they are great players. Chandler Jones, Jamie Collins, Logan Mankins, etc..

10: Jerry's influence on the draft seems to have been near zero the past two years. The 2nd round picks have been Awuzie and Connor Williams.

11: The "Linehan is running Garrett's offense" phrase should be officially buried. Many many things including direct quotes from Stephen Jones indicate Garrett is now out of offense game-planning starting this season. Linehan pushed out Pollack and Dooley as well as Dez. It seems that something happened to cause Witten to retire. The new WR coach has connections to Linehan and seems to be the opposite of previous WR coaches in the Garrett as HC era. It appears that Garrett was not in favor of the Dez cut; although evidence on that is limited.

12: Kris Richard was in the draft War Room often considering they drafted zero DBs.
Preach it....:flagwave:
 
11: The "Linehan is running Garrett's offense" phrase should be officially buried. Many many things including direct quotes from Stephen Jones indicate Garrett is now out of offense game-planning starting this season. Linehan pushed out Pollack and Dooley as well as Dez. It seems that something happened to cause Witten to retire. The new WR coach has connections to Linehan and seems to be the opposite of previous WR coaches in the Garrett as HC era. It appears that Garrett was not in favor of the Dez cut; although evidence on that is limited.

Although you've got some "truths," there's a lot of speculation in this inclusion.
 
13. Not every player that isn't capable of going to the pro bowl is "JAG"

14. Terrance Williams in 10 gamed without Dez averages 61.7 yards per game and .4 TDs per game. 61.7 yards per game would have tied with Jarvis Landry for 22nd in the league. Landry just signed a 5 yr/$75.5M contract

15. Once Richard took over as DC in Seattle each year the defense regressed until he was canned at the end of last season. It's hard to quantify how much of this regression was due to injuries/players lost in free agency.

16. We lost a very good ST coach

17. Just because we signed/drafted them this year doesnt mean they'll make the team over indentured playerd, despite them being the shiny new toy.

18. The odds of LVE being a borderline-pro bowler his rookie year or making a big impact in a positive way is low.
 
1: Tavon Austin's fumble problems were on Punts, not on offense. His career fumble rate is better than Zeke's 2016 fumble rate. I don't remember anybody complaining about Zeke fumbling.
Austin's problems seem to have been more injuries and general ineffectiveness.
 
Surprisingly I agree with most of what you said...

Only slight issues I have are in #5 and #7...

If Armstrong wasn’t as athletic as expected because he added weight and he weighed in at 257, what the heck is his natural weight?? He’s going to have to figure how to effectively add weight/strength without losing his athleticism. Hopefully an NFL training staff can figure that out for him and he has the desire to follow through.

While I agree that 330+ DT’s are going extinct, someone like Tony Siragusa...there is still plenty of talent between what we have and the big freaks like Snacks/Poe. Can’t we just find a guy that’s is around 6’4 315 lbs that is both fairly quick and doesn’t get blown up in the run game? Doesn’t have to be 1st round or high $ free agent either.
 
Kris Richard was in the war room but mostly because they were considering drafting DBs at that spot but went elsewhere like Gallup instead of Justin reid
 
Kris Richard was in the war room but mostly because they were considering drafting DBs at that spot but went elsewhere like Gallup instead of Justin reid

Justin Reid was drafted well before our 3rd round pick(Gallup). I believe you mean Williams instead of Reid.
 
For #5 they really seem to be trying to get value with players whose draft stock fell after scheme changes. Collins, Tapper and Armstrong were very productive earlier in their careers in one gap 4-3 defenses. But their production fell as their roles changed under different defensive schemes.
 
Surprisingly I agree with most of what you said...

Only slight issues I have are in #5 and #7...

If Armstrong wasn’t as athletic as expected because he added weight and he weighed in at 257, what the heck is his natural weight?? He’s going to have to figure how to effectively add weight/strength without losing his athleticism. Hopefully an NFL training staff can figure that out for him and he has the desire to follow through.

While I agree that 330+ DT’s are going extinct, someone like Tony Siragusa...there is still plenty of talent between what we have and the big freaks like Snacks/Poe. Can’t we just find a guy that’s is around 6’4 315 lbs that is both fairly quick and doesn’t get blown up in the run game? Doesn’t have to be 1st round or high $ free agent either.
Poe is on his 3rd team in 3 years.
Even freaks at Nose Tackle are finding themselves minimally valued.

Snacks played on the 27th best run defense last year.

Teams have simply figured out how to limit NT types.
 
Great stuff there.

Witten's issue was a job offer. He was smart and got advice and that was almost all go for it while it's there. Those are really hard jobs to get.

Dez issue was pretty clearly that no one could count on him being physically right ever again. Knee and ankle stuff adds up at WR. I think to a man the guys on the team loved him and his passion was a positive thing most of his career. With his injuries and Dak being so young, it was turning into something else. But mostly you just didn't wanna keep paying big-time money for a guy who you can't count on being healthy. You could see the limp in his regular walk at times.
Dez did not age gracefully like Witten but he's going to eventually go in the Ring of Honor.

The team has to teach Austin to handle punts or go with someone else. That bears watching but I agree the point of the move was to get him for offense. The offense just flat needed raw speed. Austin has it. Once they worked out Dunbar and saw he may have lost a step I think it made Austin inevitable.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,658
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top