Game Day ***Cowboys vs Bills post game thread***

mldardy

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,621
Reaction score
7,317
It still reads better than Garrett except for 1 season.

So, overall, he's certainly better than what we've unfortunately been saddled with in Dallas.

Garrett has a playoff win, a 12-4 season and a division title. That's not better than Garrett.
 

PoundTheRock

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,255
Reaction score
1,246
It's always fun to cherry pick isn't it?

We could point to many more situations where rebuilds take longer.

Also what you're so ignorantly ignoring is the fact that in 2012 the Cardinals did not have Carson Palmer.

In 2013 the Cardinals did have Carson Palmer.

That means they had a double digit win roster with an Pro Bowl QB. And a terrible team without one.

Hey look...Cowboys 3-1 (12-4 pro rated) with Romo. And 1-10 (1-15 pro rated) without him.

Stop embarrassing yourself.

The Texans are 16-0 pro rated with Brandon Weeden.
 

TellerMorrow34

BraveHeartFan
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
5,076
Garrett has a playoff win, a 12-4 season and a division title. That's not better than Garrett.

I guess you missed where I said better except 1 season.

Garrett was good for 1 season.

He's been bad to worse in the other years.

I'd rather Dallas have been in the playoffs a few times, instead of 1, and had at least a shot at a playoff win on more than 1 occasion, rather than just the one good season.

So, yeah, overall it is better.

But hey Garrett was really good for that 1 year so I suppose 1 out of 5 isn't too bad.


Not to mention that when you take Andy Reid's career as a whole....FAR better than Jason Garrett. It's laughable to even consider thinking Garrett would be better.


But I realize that all that was mentioned here was his time in KC.
 

jwitten82

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,717
Reaction score
16,736
It's always fun to cherry pick isn't it?

We could point to many more situations where rebuilds take longer.

Also what you're so ignorantly ignoring is the fact that in 2012 the Cardinals did not have Carson Palmer.

In 2013 the Cardinals did have Carson Palmer.

That means they had a double digit win roster with an Pro Bowl QB. And a terrible team without one.

Hey look...Cowboys 3-1 (12-4 pro rated) with Romo. And 1-10 (1-15 pro rated) without him.

Stop embarrassing yourself.

Arians had them winning games when Palmer was injured.
 

Zordon

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,306
Reaction score
46,767
Pete Carroll starting coaching the Seahawks the same year Garrett took over the Cowboys in midseason, 2010. Carroll inherited a 5-11 team.

Carroll is 69-42 with two SB appearances and a championship.

Coaching matters.

Did you know the Steelers and Packers have replaced more starters from their Super Bowl XLV teams than the Cowboys have since Garrett took over.
 

Avery

The Dog that Saved Charleston
Messages
19,465
Reaction score
20,518
Niners SOS will be higher than ours after this week by my count.
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,356
Reaction score
32,743
Yes...let's blame Kellen for this mess. :popcorn:

Moore has moxie. I like his anticipation and ability to get rid of the ball. But ... he has a weak arm. He threw a few ducks. And he couldn't put the ball in the end zone, even though the Cowboys throw when they get to the end zone.

And, truth be told, do you REALLY think Moore is going to be successful with this team? All of our backups are 1-10. Meanwhile, Brandon Weeden, who treated the end zone like it was a no-fly zone when he was here, found the end zone TWICE today playing with the Texans.

Combined with his weak arm and this staff not really knowing what to do with backup quarterbacks, I don't think Moore has a future with this team. Sorry.
 
Top