Cowboyszone Report Card...Roy Williams...GPA = 1.76

[Hostile]

Grade Roy Williams.

I think this one will be all over the place.

 

[Ashwynn]

Grade Roy Williams.

I think this one will be all over the place.

Especially without buttons to push. maybe I am missing something.

Edit. I swear that poll was not there when I first clicked it.

 

[rash]

I actually think hes gunna get a 2.0.

Now whether its a C-, C, or C+ is to be determined

 

[SDCowboy]

With Romo a B+. He was wasn't just better, he was actually a weapon. After, a C-. Completely disappeared.

 

[Ashwynn]

Now I dont usually chime in on the polls, but Roy I think more then anyone stepped up last year. After the drop years, last year was a big deal for him. He held on to a lot of balls last year he could have dropped before.

I went B cause hes still far from perfect, but the pressure he faced from the fans, he stepped up and had a fine year actually.

 

[Hagman]

C -

He's a below average receiver. Drops passes and runs bad routes--or whatever reasons mean he can't connect with the Quarterback.

However, he complicates matters by getting an A+ salary and we gave up A+ level compensation to get him.

 

[casmith07]

C.

I think he improved, but he cost us the game against the Saints. He also continues to be somewhat lackluster for what his expectations were coming to Dallas.

He's average, but not awful.

 

[Stautner]

If his salary and expectations are ingored and he is judged soley on what he does for the team he is a C. That's my grade.

 

[JVita17]

D. Picked it up somewhat from his failing past season.

 

[CowboyDan]

B-/C+ for me, so I chose B. He made some great catches and had a much better season than the previous season......when he got the ball. The arrival of Dez took away a lot of chances from Roy. I graded him on his play when he was thrown to, and of course, his run blocking, which is very good. Two plays absolutely killed me last year....the fumble against the Saints and the fumble against the Bears. You could argue that those plays lost both games. And for that, I'd really like to give him a big fat F, but I didn't.

 

[LucaBrasi]

I like the guy, I want him to do well, and I was all for the trade when it occurred. For whatever the reason the production just isn't there, at least not where it should be.
He worked to limit the drops from the previous year, he actually produced some the first 5 weeks of the season - especially scoring- but really tailed off late. I actually thought the change to Kitna would benefit him because they had previously worked together, but it didn't happen.

I hope he stays because I think there is a chance for him to contribute significantly especially with Dez Bryant's style of play. Tough call for me between a C or a D but I gave him the lower grade.

 

[dffl11]

"C" from me...I like RW11 and I really would like to see him back......with a healthy #88 and a healthy #9!

Give em a line JERRY......Please for the love of GOD, can The Dallas Cowboys just get a good and healthy OL for the upcoming season.......


ROY WILLIAMS can play at a high level..........This much I know

 

[rash]

Tough call for me between a C or a D but I gave him the lower grade.

Harsh like The Tuna himself eh?

 

[YosemiteSam]

Gave him a B. I think he clearly played better, but all the WRs had issues after Romo went down. Kitna had trouble getting to ball outside to them. I can't blame them for that.

 

[JohnnyHopkins]

C. At this point, Roy Williams running long distances with the football when the game is on the line makes me cringe. One thing you have to say is that he had a much better rapport with Romo and the guy will man up for any interview regardless of his being the hero or the goat.

 

[laythewood28]

With Romo probably a B (was our most consistent receiver at the time imo)
With Kitna a F (started dropping balls, lost focus, and cost us a game)

 

[CATCH17]

C- for me.

 

[baj1dallas]

I gave him a C, he was B+ or even A early in the season when he made some big plays, but was more like a C- or even D later.

 

[Clove]

I gave him a "C". He wasn't horrible, but his pay doesn't match his production. Pay him like a 3rd receiver, and his grade is an "A-"

 

[Plankton]

C. Had a terrific early part of the season, one of the few on the roster. Was completely invisible the end of the year. Fumble against the Saints was a killer.