starfan1
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 12,972
- Reaction score
- 12,086
since its footballSince when is Tulsa a small school?!?
since its footballSince when is Tulsa a small school?!?
He gave the Cowboys a C+.yeah he rarely gets it right. Funny thing is, he praised this kid and then he says we had the worst draft? Both cant be true. Thats an agenda.
I trust Brian Baldinger more than Mel Kiper and Brian broke down Sam Williams
You are on fire!Exactly!!! Yet Mel was saying "Hurr durr durr, Ferguson's blocking is suspect". That was one of the stupidest things he could have said, considering that he's a Wisconsin TE. Plus, it was rubbish because he would've gushed about that had the Ravens picked Ferguson. So yeah, Mel Kiper can go play in traffic.
I tend 2 always go with the opposite of whatever Mel says. He is never right. CBS sports has a completely different take. Espn is agenda driven and biased against all things Cowboys.
agreed. McShay actually sounds legit in comparison lol..btw..my guy has been Dane Bugler. He called this stuff 2 weeks ago. His evals are really consistent. He misses but will admit when he missed. His take is we had a really decent draft. Wasn't sexy, just very methodical and trended towards very physical productive guys.I must give Kudos to Pete Prisco of CBS..he was really accurate as well. He was fair. But yeah, Mel is just nutty.Completely independent of this year’s Dallas draft class, whatever Kiper once had is long gone. His draft analysis borders on absurd at times.
each time he speaks he removes any doubt.He gave the Cowboys a C+.
agreed. McShay actually sounds legit in comparison lol..btw..my guy has been Dane Bugler. He called this stuff 2 weeks ago. His evals are really consistent. He misses but will admit when he missed. His take is we had a really decent draft. Wasn't sexy, just very methodical and trended towards very physical productive guys.I must give Kudos to Pete Prisco of CBS..he was really accurate as well. He was fair. But yeah, Mel is just nutty.
He may be wrong, but I think it is a safe to say this is a questionable class with unknowns.
It's pretty clear McShay puts the work into his analysis. I like listening to him much more than most of the other so called draft experts.agreed. McShay actually sounds legit in comparison lol..btw..my guy has been Dane Bugler. He called this stuff 2 weeks ago. His evals are really consistent. He misses but will admit when he missed. His take is we had a really decent draft. Wasn't sexy, just very methodical and trended towards very physical productive guys.I must give Kudos to Pete Prisco of CBS..he was really accurate as well. He was fair. But yeah, Mel is just nutty.
The reason most of our fans don’t have a clue is because most of them weren't familiar with any of our draft picks .
Most of us who spend a lot of time watching College Football are familiar with many players especially of those which conference you watch the most .
This is why we rely on these draft gurus for info. We don’t necessarily rely on their evaluation of talent level but it is nice to know how they fared at the combines , some video of their performances and history at their school . Most of which we aren’t as familiar going in on all of these players drafted.
Yea, we might not agree with these analyst individual evaluations but we should respect the time they’ve put into their research and knowledge of the players . It’s much more than the average fan puts in or knows.
Id be curious to how many other team grades you’d disagree with or is it just the Cowboys which comes off like more of sour grapes to me . Most are grading the Cowboys with a B or B- so a C+ isn’t that much of a stretch to raise such a fuss about IMO.
Mel is a bull**** artist. Don't worry about him. The former GM for the Colts called him out on it in the mid-90s