Dak beats Herbert in accuracy challenge

[TheMarathonContinues]

Dak isn't even in the same league as Herbert. One of them hit their ceiling his rookie year, the other keeps getting better.

One of them made the playoffs his rookie year…the other is still trying to….

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Justin Herbert missed the playoffs, and Dak’s Cowboys beat him head-to-head.

Rank them wherever you’d like. Herbert’s potential is sky high and he’s clearly very talented physically.

Thus far, Dak has the upper hand where it matters - on the football field.

I do love seeing Dak’s haters in shambles, like they are in this thread.

His haters are panicking and scrambling right now lol…

 

[Nav22]

Dak has had the upper hand on the field because the results were horrible when Dak is not surrounded by the best RB, oline, WRs, etc., in the NFCE. Dak’s short-comings caused the team to overcompensate with their investments on the offensive side of the ball. Herbert has never had the luxury of having position group after position group that ranks among the best in the O

LOLLLLL, look who crawled out from under his hole to embarrass himself again.

“DURRRR HERBERT HAS NOBODY AROUND HIM!!!”

Austin Ekeler is twice the RB Zeke is at this stage of their careers.

Mike Williams, Keenan Allen and Jared Cook is AT LEAST as good a trio as Cooper, Lamb and Schultz, if not better.

The Chargers LT and C (Slater and Linsley) were All-Pros last year.

Keep embarrassing yourself. Maybe some day you’ll tell us the REAL reason you hate Dak so much, if you have the guts to do so.

Remember when you said you’d NEVER support Dak no matter what? Gee, I’m still trying to figure out WHY that is!

“DURRR I’VE ALREADY SAID IT!” (No, you haven’t)

 

[Nav22]

Dak's rookie year and each year after has had one of the better roster's in the league. Herbert came to a team that was 5-11 the season before his arrival.

Dak probably had a much better record overall than Payton Manning did after year 3 or 4 also.

Nobody said anything about taking the record, we were talking about the player. And only a total Dak homer would take Dak over Herbert if you were starting a team tomorrow and those were your 2 QB choices.

LOLLL “Herbert had no help” is the excuse now. I love it.

Austin Ekeler’s better than Zeke.

Mike Williams and Keenan Allen are as good OR BETTER than Cooper and Lamb.

The Chargers left tackle and center were All-Pros in 2021.

When Dak has that kind of help, “ANYONE COULD PLAY WELL WITH THOSE GUYS AROUND HIM!”

When it’s Herbert, the poor guy has a bare cupboard.

 

[Nav22]

I'm not sure watching Dak repeatedly implode under pressure is exactly "proving it on the field".

How has Herbert done under pressure?

15-17 record, 0 playoff trips.

Good thing Dak isn’t THAT big of a “choker,” huh?

 

[BoyzBlaster]

How has Herbert done under pressure?

15-17 record, 0 playoff trips.

Good thing Dak isn’t THAT big of a “choker,” huh?

I would look at it a bit differently. Herbert is in a completely different universe than Dak in terms of his skill set, but you're absolutely right he hasn't won anything yet, and maybe he never will. The difference is Dak is what he is at this point (an imploder) whereas the book is still out on Herbert, and he's starting from a place of immensely more natural ability. But we'll see.

 

[America's Cowboy]

I'm not sure watching Dak repeatedly implode under pressure is exactly "proving it on the field".

When has Dak imploded under pressure? Name the games. I'll wait.

 

[America's Cowboy]

I would look at it a bit differently. Herbert is in a completely different universe than Dak in terms of his skill set, but you're absolutely right he hasn't won anything yet, and maybe he never will. The difference is Dak is what he is at this point (an imploder) whereas the book is still out on Herbert, and he's starting from a place of immensely more natural ability. But we'll see.

Really? Herbert sucked recently in the QB throwing challenge. Dak and others even beat him big time. Quit talking smack without facts.

 

[Nav22]

I would look at it a bit differently. Herbert is in a completely different universe than Dak in terms of his skill set, but you're absolutely right he hasn't won anything yet, and maybe he never will. The difference is Dak is what he is at this point (an imploder) whereas the book is still out on Herbert, and he's starting from a place of immensely more natural ability. But we'll see.

Right, because good QBs like Dak NEVER win big after their 6th years in the league, right?

Were Peyton Manning and Stafford and Brees “imploders” after their 6th years too?

 

[Cowboysheelsreds053]

LLLOOOLLL, not looked at all of the postings on page 1 BUT know for sure 1 Horsemen replied to this thread.

 

[dcstar]

No disrespect intended but I'd trade Mr Prescott straight up for Mr Herbert. Even throw in Mr Elliott as a good will gesture. That's just me.

Go Cowboys!

 

[CowboyRoy]

He wasnt healthy last year? oh........

No he wasnt. Did you forget?

 

[Kevinicus]

Dak - 2
Herbert - 1

Dak hits the rim on all his shots tho (meaning his receiver in all likelihood catches those). Herbert misses air on the majority of his shots.

Dak didn't hit the rim on all shots, he hit it on 2. That's where the 2 points came from.
Herbert hit it on one.

 

[Kevinicus]

Justin Herbert missed the playoffs, and Dak’s Cowboys beat him head-to-head.

Rank them wherever you’d like. Herbert’s potential is sky high and he’s clearly very talented physically.

Thus far, Dak has the upper hand where it matters - on the football field.

I do love seeing Dak’s haters in shambles, like they are in this thread.

Dak's upper hand "where it matters" was the rest of his team.

Dak vs. Herbert directly is a huge advantage in Herbert's favor.

 

[Swagger]

really ? he beat Herbert H2h last year, was rookie of the year had better rookie campaign..Herbert yet to see the playoffs going into year 3..Beat NE on the road went 6-0 early on.. how about shut it on dak hate maybe to remind yourself that having 11 penalty's from your OL in like 4 of the last 6 games might affect the offense OL was bad in those games..but heyt its dak...

Conveniently forgetting to mention the bogus flags against the Chargers which lost them the game. But hey, let's not deviate from the narrative that Dak is amazing and carries others like Parsons, Smith, Martin, etc

How did Prescott play from and including the Denver game last season and what about the final 5 minutes against the 49ers in the play offs? Two opportunities to produce a game winning drive and justify his contract...what happened?

 

[RustyBourneHorse]

Well done, Dak!

 

[conner01]

I don't believe for one second anyone here actually cares about any of this nonsense. This is football not the state fair..

To be fair Dak beat him in accuracy in real games too

 

[America's Cowboy]

No disrespect intended but I'd trade Mr Prescott straight up for Mr Herbert. Even throw in Mr Elliott as a good will gesture. That's just me.

Go Cowboys!

Romoholic. ^^^^

 

[America's Cowboy]

LOLLLLL, look who crawled out from under his hole to embarrass himself again.

“DURRRR HERBERT HAS NOBODY AROUND HIM!!!”

Austin Ekeler is twice the RB Zeke is at this stage of their careers.

Mike Williams, Keenan Allen and Jared Cook is AT LEAST as good a trio as Cooper, Lamb and Schultz, if not better.

The Chargers LT and C (Slater and Linsley) were All-Pros last year.

Keep embarrassing yourself. Maybe some day you’ll tell us the REAL reason you hate Dak so much, if you have the guts to do so.

Remember when you said you’d NEVER support Dak no matter what? Gee, I’m still trying to figure out WHY that is!

“DURRR I’VE ALREADY SAID IT!” (No, you haven’t)

 

[acr731]

LOLLLLL, look who crawled out from under his hole to embarrass himself again.

“DURRRR HERBERT HAS NOBODY AROUND HIM!!!”

Austin Ekeler is twice the RB Zeke is at this stage of their careers.

Mike Williams, Keenan Allen and Jared Cook is AT LEAST as good a trio as Cooper, Lamb and Schultz, if not better.

The Chargers LT and C (Slater and Linsley) were All-Pros last year.

Keep embarrassing yourself. Maybe some day you’ll tell us the REAL reason you hate Dak so much, if you have the guts to do so.

Remember when you said you’d NEVER support Dak no matter what? Gee, I’m still trying to figure out WHY that is!

“DURRR I’VE ALREADY SAID IT!” (No, you haven’t)

You sound like a 6th grader....