Discussion in 'Overtime Zone' started by Jeffkills, Jul 15, 2020.
Would you do it???
No. Carr isnt that good. He is mid tier guy that has shown to be gunshy. He isnt taking you anywhere.
If you move on from Dak, your best bet is try to retool with a young QB
The upside would be Carr's contract is very team friendly right now. But you are giving up a first round pick to get him
Please stop it...
Derek Carr wouldn't be an upgrade. In fact he would be a down grade.
Derek Carr pre leg injury, aka 2016 Carr, sure.
But since then he's been a middle of the road at best QB.
I could show you dozens of youtube highlight videos of high school players who look like all-Americans. Dig a little deeper.
There's nothing in Carr's profile or performance to suggest he's better than Dak other than you don't like Dak. He'd be a downgrade, and you'd spend all season lowering the bar to defend this thread.
How is he a downgrade?
At least he's accurate.
Let us not forget:
That's DAVID Carr in the video, not DEREK Carr.
Check the heading for the post...
Hey, there... Both brothers are referenced in this thread, guy...
The heading says:
"Dak for Derek Carr?"
Pray tell, where is David Carr's name in the above? Nowhere. The thread is the title heading. Others can add to it all they want, but it doesn't change the premise of the thread....
step up Ben Denucci lol..you better be a quick study. Your time will be here in 2021. NO WAY Dak is a Cowboy past this year. THIS SNAFU made sure of that
naw you are underestimating dalton.
Every situation is different, and the exclusive franchise tag has been used so seldom, that we can't go by Brees' or Cousins' situations. Not even considering the Covid situation this year. For instance if Dak doesn't do that well this year, he might be far more reasonable in his demands. Or Jerry could give in if he does really well, after the Mahomes deal, a young SB champion quarterback.
Just too many uncertainties to say NO WAY, imho...
I will say this about Carr, statistically he is rebounding. However he wont play downfield. Maybe his mental recovery has been a slower proccess
David is a scrub as an actual QB though. Guy with elite arm talent but without the brains and balls to use it on an actual field
Derek Carr will be out of the NFL in 2 years, so NO. Give me Dak all day long. Dalton is better than Carr...so.
Non Exclusive Dak next year, be prepared to lose him and see if any team is willing to part with two 1st round draft picks for him. Clearly the Cowboys and Dak don't want him in Dallas, better to search for the next QB and let Dalton take the reigns while someone sits on the bench for 1-2 years, meanwhile rebuild the O-Line, CB, Safety and possibly move on from Elliott, through the draft.