Dak Top 5. Let's talk argument against it

[Whirlwin]

Mahomes
Allen
Jackson
Purdy
Dak

Alt Lawrence

I don’t think Mahomes is better than Alan or Jackson. He’s definitely regressing without that offensive line that he used to have.

 

[cowboyec]

i think he is.
and thats the only opinion that matters.
the end.

 

[Whirlwin]

A very good 0-3 team.

They scored 30 points against the bills, and 30 against us,

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

OMG
here we go again
it took minutes

nice 2nd half though!
Take the W!

Sometimes you gotta take the W and be happy. I don’t know about all this top anything talk. He did shred up a very good defense. That’s about all I’ll say.

 

[jazzcat22]

Most would consider 0-3 a bad team.

Sure. But a win is a win.
Come playoff time. They won’t say that win against an0-3 team at the time doesn’t count.

Oh, and what if Houston ends up 12-5. And in the playoffs. Will this still count as a win against a bad team?
I bet some will say yes.

 

[JayFord]

That’s only relevant to this if you thought Jalen were top 5. I think he’s better than Mariota too, personally.

Make your Jalen top 5 case

Jalen has never been nor will he be top 5

Hes just the best qb philly could have the past couple years he fits what they want to a T

 

[MonkeymanWoes]

IMO hes in the top 5-7 surrounded by a ton of offense talent. Draw back...coaching revolving door

However like ive been outspoken about hes only up there as the state of talent of the quarterbacks the last 5+ years has been atrocious to the what we have seen over the last what seems like....forever. But he has no control over that

Exactly, he's had 3 coaches. Despite that he shows up.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Jalen has never been nor will he be top 5

Hes just the best qb philly could have the past couple years he fits what they want to a T

I don’t disagree, but why then use Jalen as an argument for why Dak is top 5?

 

[Hardline]

I knew this thread was coming right after the game was over,
Dak pulled out a victory in the final 2 minutes, Great for him and the team. What about the 99% of the time he chokes.

Lamb bailed him out today with a monster game,

 

[Dorsett99Yards]

Mahomes
Allen
Jackson
Purdy
Dak

Alt Lawrence

He needs the playoff victories to lift him up pass Allen, Jackson, and Purdy.

 

[America's Cowboy]

That’s only relevant to this if you thought Jalen were top 5. I think he’s better than Mariota too, personally.

Make your Jalen top 5 case

You already did when y'all won the SB and Jalen won SB MVP.

Game. Set & Match.

 

[America's Cowboy]

I knew this thread was coming right after the game was over,
Dak pulled out a victory in the final 2 minutes, Great for him and the team. What about the 99% of the time he chokes.

Lamb bailed him out today with a monster game,

Lamb threw to himself?

Shut up.

 

[shabazz]

OMG
here we go again
it took minutes

nice 2nd half though!
Take the W!

Pssssst......don't bring up zero TDs in the entire 1st half.

It never happened.

The same ones ALWAYS overplay their hand

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

You already did when y'all won the SB and Jalen won SB MVP.

Game. Set & Match.

And when did Dak do those things