Tough question for me because I don't watch Watson enough to know if he's an elite player or not. 4 wins is a huge red flag for me. Elite QB's consistently make the playoffs. So in general my rule is that if the QB can't elevate i'd rather spend the money on the roster and replace the quarterback. This is a backwards way of thinking for most people because the NFL has trained them to think about overpaying the QB but the results are just not there to justify paying non elite guys like Dak. So honest answer is I just haven't watched enough of Watson to know if he is elite. If he's not elite then give me a rookie contract over paying him 40 Million to win 4 games a year. BTW.. Dalton is just a name.. I'd rather draft then have Andy Dalton. I just think Dalton will win and lose the same games the Dak will win and lose for the most part.