Detroit Free Press: Matt Millen's Top 10 Draft Blunders

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
10. JEFF BACKUS, Round 1, 18th overall in 2001 This one will be done quicker than a Jeff Backus blown blocking assignment. Backus was a really good lineman at Michigan. He was selected by the Lions with the 18th overall pick in the 2001 draft, and never blocked quite as well again. Also, Duece McCallister was selected five picks later. And here we are seven years later and the Lions still don't have a solid running back. Backus is a decent player, but he was not worth the contract of one of the highest-paid linemen in the NFL.

9. SHAUN ROGERS, Round 2, 61st overall in 2001 What more can be said about Big Baby? The two-time pro bowler was one of Detroit's best players, and best bargains at the 61st overall pick in the 2001 draft. But the 320-plus pounder could never keep his weight down. Heck, he couldn't even keep his breath. Now like so many other Lions draft picks as of late, Roger is playing for someone else- Cleveland. He was traded to the Browns this offseason for Leigh Bodden. Rogers may have been the Lions biggest waste of talent in the last decade.

8. TEDDY LEHMAN, Round 2, 37th overall in 2004 The Lions got the 37th overall pick in the 2004 NFL draft in a trade with Cleveland, and used it to draft another injury prone linebacker. Lehman missed 23 games spanning the 2005 and 2006 seasons with foot and ankle injuries. After four seasons, Lehman left the Lions and signed with the Buccaneers.

7. BOSS BAILEY, Round 2, 34th overall in 2003 Nothing like getting only four seasons out of a second round draft pick (35th overall, 2003). The often-injured linebacker missed the entire 2004 season with a knee injury and five more games in 2005. In four seasons Bailey recorded only seven sacks, one forced fumble and two interceptions; so maybe it was good thing he bolted for Denver this offseason to play with his more talented brother, Champ.

6. KEVIN JONES, Round 1, 30th overall in 2004 If the object of the game were to sustain serious injuries to the mid to lower leg, Kevin Jones would be No.1 in the league. We all know that's not the case, and so like so many who have come before him, Jones is another Detroit casualty. Jones did show some spark, but he was never the explosive top running back the Lions needed. That's what happens when you wait until pick No. 30 (2004) to address the second-most important position on the team. And here's a dash of irony for you; the next running back selected after Jones was Tatum Bell (sigh), followed by Julius Jones; who by passed the Lions in free agency this offseason. Maybe Millen shouldn't have passed him by the first time around.

5. KALIMBA EDWARDS, Round 2, 35th overall in 2002 The 2002 second round pick was released by the Lions after five seasons. Edwards recorded only three sacks in each of his last two seasons with Detroit. At least Millen didn't use the same formula as he did with Redding, otherwise, Edwards might still be in Detroit banking $21-million-a-year. Lastly, Edwards has possibly the least informative Wikipedia page of any professional athlete. You can view the entire paragraph here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalimba_Edwards

4. ENTIRE 2003 DRAFT The Lions selected 11 players. Only one of them , Redding, is still on the team.The others: Charles Rogers-Out of league, Boss Bailey- gone to Denver, Ben Johnson- gone to San Diego, David Kircus- gone to Denver, James Davis- gone to New York, Artose Pinner- gone to New Orleans, Terrance Holt-gone to Carolina., Travis Anglin- never played, Brandon Drumm-never played, Greg Adams-never played.

3. JOEY HARRINGTON, Round 1, 3rd overall in 2002 Harrington, the third overall pick in the 2002 NFL Draft, was born in Oregon, but raised in futility after being drafted by Matt Millen and immediately placed as the Lions starting quarterback. In his first season in Honolulu Blue and Silver, Harrington threw 12 touchdowns to 16 interceptions for a 59.9 quarterback rating. His 3-13 rookie record was subpar, even by Marty Morhinwheg's standards. In 2005, Steve Mariucci decided to fight mediocrity with more mediocrity, naming Jeff Garcia the starter. Not to be outdone, Garcia lost the starting job to Harrington three weeks later after throwing a game losing interception to Chicago. Harrington was released before the 2006 season and also enjoyed awful campaigns in Miami and Atlanta. On a positive note, Harrington is a terrific piano player.

2. CHARLES ROGERS, Round 1, 2nd overall in 2003 The former Spartan and Saginaw native looked spectacular in his Lions debut by hauling in two touchdown catches on his first two receptions. But I guess the Arizona Cardinals have been known to do that to players. Rogers' production was steady for the next few weeks until a broken clavicle landed him on the injured reserve. In 2004, Rogers broke his collarbone and was placed on the IR once more. Rogers completed the trifecta early in the 2005 season by failing his third NFL drug test and being suspended for four games. He never played in the NFL again, but did run a 4.8 40-yard dash in a private workout with the Kansas City Chiefs- more than a half second slower than his 2003 NFL Combine time. Smoking will do that to you.

1. MIKE WILLIAMS, Round 1, 10th overall in 2005 It looks like the Vikings made the smart decision after all by skipping on Williams, and selecting Troy Williamson in the 2005 NFL Draft. Unfortunately for the Lions, it was Millen, who once again made a draft day blunder. Williams started only four games as a rookie, and in 2006, the large wideout was even surpassed on the depth chart by Josh McCown, the Lions third string quarterback. For his Motor City finale, Williams dropped a handful of passes including a potential game-winning touchdown in a week 16 loss to Chicago. The USC-product was traded before the 2007 season to Oakland along with Josh McCown and now plays for Tennessee.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
That is such a short time period to have 10 really big blunders. I am still unclear as to how he keeps his job.
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
Millen has GOT to have pictures of the owner with a dog or duck or something. There is no other explanation.
 

Chief

"Friggin Joke Monkey"
Messages
8,543
Reaction score
4
The Fords are known for their patience when it comes to the Lions. Wayne Fontes stuck around much longer than he should have.

I hope they keep Mongo around for a long time. It's just another NFC team the Cowboys will never have to worry about and Millen provides plenty of comedy every year.
 

FCBarca

New Member
Messages
2,475
Reaction score
0
It's remarkable really how Millen still has a job...Just goes to show you in the world of Billionaire business and a monopoly, different standards in place than the real world and how one measures productivity & syccess.

Any other area of work, Millen would have been on the street
 

adamknite

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,226
Reaction score
805
10. JEFF BACKUS, Round 1, 18th overall in 2001


wow..... I didn't even remember who that was until I read the description about him.
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,684
Reaction score
12,394
Hostile;2146465 said:
7. BOSS BAILEY, Round 2, 34th overall in 2003 Nothing like getting only four seasons out of a second round draft pick (35th overall, 2003).

This is an idiotic statement. Just four years? Most teams would be happy if a guy could come in and start for that long. Bailey isn't great but he's hardly a bust.
 
Messages
3,013
Reaction score
586
Haha, I remember everybody going nuts wanting to sign Jeff Backus as a RT before we got Columbo. :laugh2:

Also,
It looks like the Vikings made the smart decision after all by skipping on Williams, and selecting Troy Williamson in the 2005 NFL Draft

Yeah, the vikings look really smart for drafting another bust WR who is no longer on their team.
 

adamknite

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,226
Reaction score
805
Doomsday;2146528 said:
LOL, the title of the article makes it seems like he has been a GM for 20 years or something.

I'm sure it's felt that long for Lions fans.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
LOL I found this as I was exiting that site.

Top 10 Players Matt Millen Passed Up

10. Nate Clements, Round 1, 21st overall in 2001 In 2001, the Lions took left tackle Jeff Backus of Michigan with the 18th pick in the draft. Cornerback Nate Clements of Ohio State went three picks later to Buffalo at 21. While Backus has been decent and dependable, Clements has been to the Pro Bowl twice and the Lions have been looking for secondary help ever since. The 2001 team had a poor defensive backfield led by Todd Lyght and Bryant Westbrook.

9. Marcus McNeill, Round 2, 50th overall in 2006 The 2006 draft saw the Lions take safety Daniel Bullocks of Nebraska at No. 40 while San Diego took Pro Bowl left tackle Marcus McNeill of Auburn at No. 50. While Bullocks might end up as a solid player, offensive line is still a major weak point on the Lions’ offense and McNeill is a star for San Diego.

8. Osi Umenyiora, Round 2, 56th overall in 2003 Matt Millen took a gamble with 34th pick on Georgia’s, talented-but-injury prone linebacker, Boss Bailey in 2003, but he could have had, pass-rushing stud defensive end, Osi Umenyiora from Troy State instead. Umenyiora went at pick No. 56 to the New York Giants.

7. Lofa Tatupu, Round 2, 45th overall in 2005</B> The Lions took defensive tackle Shaun Cody at No. 35 out of USC in the 2005 NFL Draft only to see Seattle take his teammate, middle linebacker and tackling machine Lofa Tatupu at No. 45. The Lions are still looking for a middle linebacker while Cody hasn’t done enough to justify his draft position.

6. Brian Westbrook, 3rd round, 91st overall in 2002 Matt Millen made cornerback Andre Goodman the 68th pick of the 2002 draft out of South Carolina. With the 91st pick, Philadelphia snagged running back Brian Westbrook out of Villanova. Westbrook is one of the NFL’s most dangerous running backs while Goodman is an average player at best.

5. Andre Johnson, Round 1, 3rd overall in 2003 Detroit took local hero and receiver Charles Rogers of Michigan State with the second pick in 2003 despite possible character issues while the Houston Texans grabbed fellow receiver Andre Johnson with the next pick. Rogers’ injuries and off-the-field problems contributed to his demise while Johnson has become a star even with a bad Texans offense.

4. Dwight Freeney, Round 1, 11th overall in 2002 In 2002, the Lions took Joey Harrington of Oregon to play quarterback with the third overall pick. Needless to say, that didn’t work out too well. The choice was a difficult one to make because the Lions didn’t seem to have a lot of options, but Indianapolis managed to find one of the NFL’s best pass rushers at No. 11 when they took Dwight Freeney of Syracuse.

3. Shawne Merriman, Round 1, 12th overall in 2005 Millen simply couldn’t resist taking receiver Mike Williams at No. 10 in 2005 out of USC, but he could have had perennial Pro Bowler and outside linebacker Shawne Merriman of Maryland instead. Merriman went at No. 12 to the Chargers. Even though Merriman is more of a 3-4 linebacker by trade and the Lions run a 4-3, he’s so good that he could play in any system.

2. Bob Sanders, Round 2, 44th overall in 2004 The 2004 draft was another clear example of how great franchises are able to find great players late while the Lions continue to struggle. The Lions took linebacker Teddy Lehman from Oklahoma at No. 37, but the Indianapolis Colts found a future NFL Defensive Player of the Year at No. 44 when they took safety Bob Sanders out of Iowa.

1. Clinton Portis, Round 2, 51st overall in 2002 In 2002, the Lions were thin at running back with the injury-prone James Stewart slotted to be the starter. But instead of taking explosive running back Clinton Portis of Miami, they took defensive end Kalimba Edwards, from South Carolina, at No. 35. Portis went to the Denver Broncos at No. 51 and became a star while Edwards frustrated the Lions for years before finally being cut this off-season.
 

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
'Boys fans can't exactly throw stones, but I guess a small chuckle wouldn't hurt.

Truthfully, I don't know that many of the players on that list should be knocked as a blunder. Some were hailed as solid picks at the time.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,936
Reaction score
112,995
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm still waiting for someone to explain to me how Millen still has his job.
 

Yeagermeister

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,629
Reaction score
117
WoodysGirl;2146579 said:
'Boys fans can't exactly throw stones, but I guess a small chuckle wouldn't hurt.

Truthfully, I don't know that many of the players on that list should be knocked as a blunder. Some were hailed as solid picks at the time.

I agree, any team that drafted Quincy Carter and Tony Dixon shouldn't laugh to hard.
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,684
Reaction score
12,394
Hostile;2146561 said:
LOL I found this as I was exiting that site.

Top 10 Players Matt Millen Passed Up

10. Nate Clements, Round 1, 21st overall in 2001 In 2001, the Lions took left tackle Jeff Backus of Michigan with the 18th pick in the draft. Cornerback Nate Clements of Ohio State went three picks later to Buffalo at 21. While Backus has been decent and dependable, Clements has been to the Pro Bowl twice and the Lions have been looking for secondary help ever since. The 2001 team had a poor defensive backfield led by Todd Lyght and Bryant Westbrook.

9. Marcus McNeill, Round 2, 50th overall in 2006 The 2006 draft saw the Lions take safety Daniel Bullocks of Nebraska at No. 40 while San Diego took Pro Bowl left tackle Marcus McNeill of Auburn at No. 50. While Bullocks might end up as a solid player, offensive line is still a major weak point on the Lions&#8217; offense and McNeill is a star for San Diego.

8. Osi Umenyiora, Round 2, 56th overall in 2003 Matt Millen took a gamble with 34th pick on Georgia&#8217;s, talented-but-injury prone linebacker, Boss Bailey in 2003, but he could have had, pass-rushing stud defensive end, Osi Umenyiora from Troy State instead. Umenyiora went at pick No. 56 to the New York Giants.

7. Lofa Tatupu, Round 2, 45th overall in 2005</B> The Lions took defensive tackle Shaun Cody at No. 35 out of USC in the 2005 NFL Draft only to see Seattle take his teammate, middle linebacker and tackling machine Lofa Tatupu at No. 45. The Lions are still looking for a middle linebacker while Cody hasn&#8217;t done enough to justify his draft position.

6. Brian Westbrook, 3rd round, 91st overall in 2002 Matt Millen made cornerback Andre Goodman the 68th pick of the 2002 draft out of South Carolina. With the 91st pick, Philadelphia snagged running back Brian Westbrook out of Villanova. Westbrook is one of the NFL&#8217;s most dangerous running backs while Goodman is an average player at best.

5. Andre Johnson, Round 1, 3rd overall in 2003 Detroit took local hero and receiver Charles Rogers of Michigan State with the second pick in 2003 despite possible character issues while the Houston Texans grabbed fellow receiver Andre Johnson with the next pick. Rogers&#8217; injuries and off-the-field problems contributed to his demise while Johnson has become a star even with a bad Texans offense.

4. Dwight Freeney, Round 1, 11th overall in 2002 In 2002, the Lions took Joey Harrington of Oregon to play quarterback with the third overall pick. Needless to say, that didn&#8217;t work out too well. The choice was a difficult one to make because the Lions didn&#8217;t seem to have a lot of options, but Indianapolis managed to find one of the NFL&#8217;s best pass rushers at No. 11 when they took Dwight Freeney of Syracuse.

3. Shawne Merriman, Round 1, 12th overall in 2005 Millen simply couldn&#8217;t resist taking receiver Mike Williams at No. 10 in 2005 out of USC, but he could have had perennial Pro Bowler and outside linebacker Shawne Merriman of Maryland instead. Merriman went at No. 12 to the Chargers. Even though Merriman is more of a 3-4 linebacker by trade and the Lions run a 4-3, he&#8217;s so good that he could play in any system.

2. Bob Sanders, Round 2, 44th overall in 2004 The 2004 draft was another clear example of how great franchises are able to find great players late while the Lions continue to struggle. The Lions took linebacker Teddy Lehman from Oklahoma at No. 37, but the Indianapolis Colts found a future NFL Defensive Player of the Year at No. 44 when they took safety Bob Sanders out of Iowa.

1. Clinton Portis, Round 2, 51st overall in 2002 In 2002, the Lions were thin at running back with the injury-prone James Stewart slotted to be the starter. But instead of taking explosive running back Clinton Portis of Miami, they took defensive end Kalimba Edwards, from South Carolina, at No. 35. Portis went to the Denver Broncos at No. 51 and became a star while Edwards frustrated the Lions for years before finally being cut this off-season.

wow, no Ware?

Even people who write about the Lions are terrible at scouting talent.
 

CoCo

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,603
Reaction score
187
Hostile;2146561 said:
LOL I found this as I was exiting that site.

Top 10 Players Matt Millen Passed Up

10. Nate Clements, Round 1, 21st overall in 2001 In 2001, the Lions took left tackle Jeff Backus of Michigan with the 18th pick in the draft. Cornerback Nate Clements of Ohio State went three picks later to Buffalo at 21. While Backus has been decent and dependable, Clements has been to the Pro Bowl twice and the Lions have been looking for secondary help ever since. The 2001 team had a poor defensive backfield led by Todd Lyght and Bryant Westbrook.

9. Marcus McNeill, Round 2, 50th overall in 2006 The 2006 draft saw the Lions take safety Daniel Bullocks of Nebraska at No. 40 while San Diego took Pro Bowl left tackle Marcus McNeill of Auburn at No. 50. While Bullocks might end up as a solid player, offensive line is still a major weak point on the Lions’ offense and McNeill is a star for San Diego.

8. Osi Umenyiora, Round 2, 56th overall in 2003 Matt Millen took a gamble with 34th pick on Georgia’s, talented-but-injury prone linebacker, Boss Bailey in 2003, but he could have had, pass-rushing stud defensive end, Osi Umenyiora from Troy State instead. Umenyiora went at pick No. 56 to the New York Giants.

7. Lofa Tatupu, Round 2, 45th overall in 2005</B> The Lions took defensive tackle Shaun Cody at No. 35 out of USC in the 2005 NFL Draft only to see Seattle take his teammate, middle linebacker and tackling machine Lofa Tatupu at No. 45. The Lions are still looking for a middle linebacker while Cody hasn’t done enough to justify his draft position.

6. Brian Westbrook, 3rd round, 91st overall in 2002 Matt Millen made cornerback Andre Goodman the 68th pick of the 2002 draft out of South Carolina. With the 91st pick, Philadelphia snagged running back Brian Westbrook out of Villanova. Westbrook is one of the NFL’s most dangerous running backs while Goodman is an average player at best.

5. Andre Johnson, Round 1, 3rd overall in 2003 Detroit took local hero and receiver Charles Rogers of Michigan State with the second pick in 2003 despite possible character issues while the Houston Texans grabbed fellow receiver Andre Johnson with the next pick. Rogers’ injuries and off-the-field problems contributed to his demise while Johnson has become a star even with a bad Texans offense.

4. Dwight Freeney, Round 1, 11th overall in 2002 In 2002, the Lions took Joey Harrington of Oregon to play quarterback with the third overall pick. Needless to say, that didn’t work out too well. The choice was a difficult one to make because the Lions didn’t seem to have a lot of options, but Indianapolis managed to find one of the NFL’s best pass rushers at No. 11 when they took Dwight Freeney of Syracuse.

3. Shawne Merriman, Round 1, 12th overall in 2005 Millen simply couldn’t resist taking receiver Mike Williams at No. 10 in 2005 out of USC, but he could have had perennial Pro Bowler and outside linebacker Shawne Merriman of Maryland instead. Merriman went at No. 12 to the Chargers. Even though Merriman is more of a 3-4 linebacker by trade and the Lions run a 4-3, he’s so good that he could play in any system.

2. Bob Sanders, Round 2, 44th overall in 2004 The 2004 draft was another clear example of how great franchises are able to find great players late while the Lions continue to struggle. The Lions took linebacker Teddy Lehman from Oklahoma at No. 37, but the Indianapolis Colts found a future NFL Defensive Player of the Year at No. 44 when they took safety Bob Sanders out of Iowa.

1. Clinton Portis, Round 2, 51st overall in 2002 In 2002, the Lions were thin at running back with the injury-prone James Stewart slotted to be the starter. But instead of taking explosive running back Clinton Portis of Miami, they took defensive end Kalimba Edwards, from South Carolina, at No. 35. Portis went to the Denver Broncos at No. 51 and became a star while Edwards frustrated the Lions for years before finally being cut this off-season.

Ware needs to be on this list. Didn't we grab him right after Detroit took Mike Williams?
 
Top