Don't want to trade Barber but would Roy Williams !!!

[garyv]

Don't want to trade Barber but would Roy Williams !!! I think Roy Williams is not a #1 Wideout. Hes a vertical runner, not football fast and gets little separation from his defenders. He usually catches pass with someone draped around him or a blown coverage. I really think his lack of Football speed and quickness hurts our Offense.

 

[Bach]

Don't want to trade Barber but would Roy Williams !!! I think Roy Williams is not a #1 Wideout. Hes a vertical runner, not football fast and gets little separation from his defenders. He usually catches pass with someone draped around him or a blown coverage. I really think his lack of Football speed and quickness hurts our Offense.

Gave up way too much for a #2 possession WR. We could really use a GM

 

[RealCowboyfan]

I believe the Cowboys should trade Roy Williams and a draft choice to broncos for Brandon Marshall

 

[CATCH17]

I think if any of the receivers get traded this offseason it will be Crayton that way we could keep Hurd and Austin.




And whats up with all the Roy Williams hate this week? He has been a good player for us this season. Especially when you consider how well this offense gets receivers the ball.

 

[Frozen700]

No..keep williams, he compliments Austin

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Gave up way too much for a #2 possession WR. We could really use a GM

So we criticize our "GM" for over trading for Roy but who's to credit for getting Witten in the 3rd round? Ratliff in the 7th round? Romo as a undrafted free agent? Barber in the 4th? Felix Jones in the 1st? Scandrick in the 5th? Choice in the 4th? Who signed Keith Brooking? Who found Mcbriar? Who found Folk? Now i'm sure someone is going to tell me Parcells was behind the majority of these moves but if I remember correctly Parcells wanted Merriman over Ware and didn't want any part of TO. And for whatever reason he felt Vinny T and Drew Bledsoe were better options at quarterback than Romo. He also thought Barbie Carpenter was warranted a 1st rounder.

My point is, we can criticize Jerry for a lot. But I don't think you can as a talent evaluator. He would've never drafted Barbie. Criticize him for his choices of coaches but not for the talent on this team.

 

[garyv]

No actually Ogletree would best complient Austin !!! Sorry but he runs better routes, gets separation from his defenders and is better after the catch than Roy Williams. In my view Roy Williams is a #3 on this team.

 

[TellerMorrow34]

If Austin becomes the starter then I think it will really benefit Roy cause you'll get Austins speed, and ability, to complement Roy being a really good, move the chains, score in the redzone kind of player. That would be a really good starting unit.

 

[casmith07]

 

[CATCH17]

Does everyone agree that Barber is inexpendable now?

 

[WoodysGirl]

I think Hurd walks..

Crayton is still fairly reliable. You still need those type of guys for injury concerns (ie Roy and Miles).

I think they definitely add another receiver next year. Free agency or draft.

 

[WoodysGirl]

Does everyone agree that Barber is inexpendable now?

I don't.

If nothing else, I think he's even more valuable. We had great depth and an explosive running game for three games. Shows what they can do when they're all healthy.

Games 4-5 shows what they can do when they're not.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Does everyone agree that Barber is inexpendable now?

No. He's still the best back on this team and he was having a GREAT season before he got hurt. He's still the heart of this team especially this offense. I don't know why people fear of having too much depth at running back. When Choice goes down what do you have? When can afford for one of these guys get hurt.

 

[cowboyfan4life_mark]

I don't.

If nothing else, I think he's even more valuable. We had great depth and an explosive running game for three games. Shows what they can do when they're all healthy.

Games 4-5 shows what they can do when they're not.

I agree with WG. I do think that right now it would be better if Choice was the starter and Barber went back to what got him to the ProBowl.

 

[YosemiteSam]

I believe the Cowboys should trade Roy Williams and a draft choice to broncos for Brandon Marshall

I think the Cowboys should trade Bobby Carpenter straight up for Larry Fitzgerald.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

No actually Ogletree would best complient Austin !!! Sorry but he runs better routes, gets separation from his defenders and is better after the catch than Roy Williams. In my view Roy Williams is a #3 on this team.

How do you know Ogletree runs better routes? Where have you seen this guy play other than preseason? Please can we stop this about Ogletree? I'd like to think he's gonna be a player in this league but let's not act like Roy is a bum. He was a pro bowlers a couple of years ago. Yea I know what have you done for me lately but let's atleast give the guy the season. Its premature to write him off after 4 games this season. If Bronco's wrote off Dumervil when he struggled who knows where he'd be right now. It sure as hell wouldn't be leading the league in sacks.

 

[CATCH17]

Whoops I meant to say Non expendable.



We can't afford to lose Barber. He is to good at every area of the game and I dont think either of our backs can develop into the type of blocker he is or the type of short yardage back he is.

I hope he is back to full speed for Atlanta.

 

[es22]

you cannot trade players who are injured. We will not get anything close in return.

Williams has no heart (perhaps he lost it in Detroit). With Barber's contract, it will be hard to more. We will be lucky to get a conditional 4th for either of them.

 

[RS12]

With that contract he is untradeable. Maybe Al Davis is senile enough.

 

[TD-33]

I think the Cowboys should trade Bobby Carpenter straight up for Larry Fitzgerald.

CO-SIGNED!





(will throw in Hamlin for Breaston and Boldin)