Oh for sure. I think all it takes is a ring to get most in the discussion….without it? I would be tough. I think Romo would’ve got in if he just had more post season appearances not even a ring.
Eli for sure should…not first ballot but he has the resume. His major drawback is he has so many lukewarm to bad seasons….
If that's the case then you put McNabb in. Similar stats to Romo and got his team to the big dance at least without a ring. Do you believe McNabb should be in?
No question.......he finished his career with a ton of record stats but not enough post-season though.
You think Romo and McNabb have similar stats?
Eli is 118-118. That sounds elite.
Horrible defensive gameplan didn't help....it's as if Quinn wanted to lose so he could start the interviews...That is a hard graphic to stare at. Kansas City's receiving corps was criticized all season long. *I think* Patrick Mahomes' most dependable receiver was Travis Kelcie.
The Chiefs are sitting at the top with the most dropped passes. Dallas' receivers dropped six less passes.
Kansas City went all the way last season. Dallas stumbled into and out of its own stadium in the wild card round.
Dropped passes alone do not provide an obstacle for success.
Life can be so unfair at times.
This is an interesting question........I def think he should get in at some point. He and Andy Reid once dominated the NFC. Not sure he doesn't get more respect. His post season resume is crazy.....
I missed it who said he was elite?
People talk about Mahomes weapons….people should go see what McNabb had outside of To for a little while.
Saying he should be in the HOF.
Exactly why Reid took a chance on TO........
A reasonable argument can be made that he is already the second greatest QB ever.
Thank you.
They aren't?
You don’t have to be elite to be in the hall you just need a hall of fame career and beating Brady twice in the SB is more important than his record.
I am sure this is Dak's fault somehow
One guy has a qb rating of a 97….one has a 85….i think McNabb was underrated but I mean you conveniently left that off for a reason also helps one guy played 11 more games than the other so when you just list totals kind of hard to gauge guys that way.
