Durant a starter or gone? 5 wonders

TrailBlazer

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,841
Reaction score
3,525
http://m.espn.go.com/general/blogs/blogpost?blogname=dallas-cowboys&id=4729092

The Cowboys could use Justin Durant to fill in for Sean Lee or look to go younger at the position.
I believe Justin Durant will be the opening day starter at middle linebacker with Sean Lee out for the year. He has the most experience. He was OK in his spot work there last year before getting hurt himself. But let's say things don't go well for him in training camp and the preseason and he outplayed by DeVonte Holloman orAnthony Hitchens. I wonder if it would be worth it to keep him around. If he is cut (or traded) then the move would save $1.25 million against the cap. Every little bit of room helps. I know what you're saying. The Cowboys can't entrust the position to two players with little to no experience. Well, why not? They did it last year when they cut safety Will Allen and named J.J. Wilcox the starter. Wilcox almost immediately got hurt and that put undrafted rookie Jeff Heathin the starting lineup. Was cutting Allen a mistake last year? Perhaps it was, but he did not play that well and he was not a big special teams help. It would be a risky move, but Durant will not be around in 2015. Is it better to get Holloman or Hitchens the work with the future in mind? The coaches who are fighting for their jobs might think otherwise, but it's something to ponder.

• One of the biggest benefits of practicing against a team in training camp is to break up the monotony. You hear players all the time say they just enjoy seeing another color jersey on the practice field. So that's what the Cowboys will get when they work against the Oakland Raiders, as expected, in Oxnard, Caliornia. But I wonder if there is more of a benefit in the player evaluation side of things. In addition to the monotony of camp, players can figure out offensive and defensive tendencies. Players have been known to see the practice scripts over the years, which give them a heads up as to what to expect. When that happens, they'll obviously look better than perhaps they are. With the Raiders bringing in fresh schemes on offense and defense, a corner won't be as familiar with the routes, splits and speed and a receiver and offensive tackle won't know every move he'll see from a defensive end. It will only be two practices, but those sessions figure to be the most hotly contested of the summer and the personnel department will have some fresh tape to see.

• I'll admit I don't know much about Terrell McClain. He did not play very much for theHouston Texans last year. The Cowboys signed him to a modest deal that included a $300,000 signing bonus. But I wonder if McClain will be this year's version of George Selvie. Last summer Selvie had the look of a training camp body with the injuries the Cowboys suffered along the defensive line. He ended up not only making the team but he started every game and had a career-high seven sacks. McClain has been one of the more impressive players in team drills during the OTAs. The line has had a hard time blocking him. He has had to play the three-technique mostly because of Henry Melton's recovery from knee surgery, and has shown the ability to pressure the quarterback and make a tackle or two for a loss. I think he ends up as the starting nose tackle on this defense when Melton is back on the field.

• The Cowboys finally found a home for Kyle Wilber late last season when they were forced to move him to outside linebacker. He started the final six games on the strong side and had 31 of his 42 tackles. He also had two tackles for loss and two quarterback pressures. He has been working with the first team in defense so far this offseason and looks the part. But last week's OTA offered up another opportunity for Wilber that I had not previously expected. Perhaps it was due to a shortage of defensive ends because a number of them were sitting out the team drills, but Wilber moved to defensive end in two-minute drills. I wonder if he can play a split role the way the New York Giants use Mathias Kiwanuka. He played linebacker in his career and would put his hand on the ground in pass-rushing situations. I'm not saying Wilber will be Kiwanuka, whom I believe has been a little underrated, but Wilber can add to his versatility by showing the ability to play both spots.

• What would a Wonders be without checking in on a contract situation? I wonder if the Cowboys should look at extending the offers to receiversDwayne Harris and/or Cole Beasley this summer. What? Hear me out. Both players are expected to be restricted free agents after this season. The bottom tender offer for a restricted free agent this year was about $1.4 million. The Cowboys thought that was too high of a price forPhillip Tanner and chose not to tender an offer to the running back this year. That number will go about in 2015 when the team will have to make decisions on Harris and Beasley. I do believe it will be easier to justify putting the tender on Harris because he is a valuable special teamer in the return and coverage games. Beasley is a punt returner, but not nearly as effective as Harris. But Beasley will have a role in this offense because of his work in the slot. It should be noted that he is only running routes in the slot during the offseason, so with that comes some limitation on what he would be paid in the future. Can the Cowboys figure out a way to give Beasley a little bump in pay this year, a good base salary in 2015, but less than the projected RFA tender and buy out his unrestricted free agency year? It sure would seem possible and it would guarantee Beasley a job in the future with a quarterback that really believes in him in Tony Romo.
 

Risen Star

Likes Collector
Messages
89,491
Reaction score
212,465
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Crawford McClain Melton Lawrence

That's what I'm hoping will be our starting DL week 1.

I'd like to see Bishop make Hayden an ex-Cowboy.

I agree with Archer on Durant. If he doesn't start, I don't know how much sense he makes as a backup. I think it's at least a possibility that it's starter or bust for him.
 

cowboyschmps3

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,371
Reaction score
1,880
Crawford McClain Melton Lawrence

That's what I'm hoping will be our starting DL week 1.

I'd like to see Bishop make Hayden an ex-Cowboy.

I agree with Archer on Durant. If he doesn't start, I don't know how much sense he makes as a backup. I think it's at least a possibility that it's starter or bust for him.

Bishop and Coleman perhaps Okoye if he shows anything this offseason. When Spencer gets healthy and if he can comeback and play like he did in 2012 will be a good problem too have IMO.
 

dogunwo

Franchise Tagged
Messages
10,322
Reaction score
5,702
Crawford McClain Melton Lawrence

That's what I'm hoping will be our starting DL week 1.

I'd like to see Bishop make Hayden an ex-Cowboy.

I agree with Archer on Durant. If he doesn't start, I don't know how much sense he makes as a backup. I think it's at least a possibility that it's starter or bust for him.
That would make Selvie a rotational guy, probably what he is best suited for.
 

Bullflop

Cowboys Diehard
Messages
25,732
Reaction score
30,920
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Right now, Holloman appears to be the odds-on favorite with many of the so-called "gurus" to claim the MLB spot. For sure, that promises to be an interesting competiton with Durant. Bass and Crawford are working well together right now in OTAs as well. Competition should be keen at more than several spots on defense, which should prove to be just what the doctor ordered. Let's just stay healthy, fellas.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,936
Reaction score
112,995
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
• I'll admit I don't know much about Terrell McClain. He did not play very much for theHouston Texans last year. The Cowboys signed him to a modest deal that included a $300,000 signing bonus. But I wonder if McClain will be this year's version of George Selvie. Last summer Selvie had the look of a training camp body with the injuries the Cowboys suffered along the defensive line. He ended up not only making the team but he started every game and had a career-high seven sacks. McClain has been one of the more impressive players in team drills during the OTAs. The line has had a hard time blocking him. He has had to play the three-technique mostly because of Henry Melton's recovery from knee surgery, and has shown the ability to pressure the quarterback and make a tackle or two for a loss. I think he ends up as the starting nose tackle on this defense when Melton is back on the field.

Might be a few servings of crow around here if he ends up being a player.
 

silver

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,874
Reaction score
1,698
I'd keep Durant if anything as a backup. The Cowboys learned the hard way last year with both the LB's and safeties that you can't have too many of them.
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,326
Reaction score
20,107
It seems a little early to be wondering if a 4th round rookie who has never played a down in the NFL and who most analysts think was selected at least two rounds too early is going to beat out a veteran. Let's at least see a preseason game or two first.
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Crawford McClain Melton Lawrence

That's what I'm hoping will be our starting DL week 1.

I'd like to see Bishop make Hayden an ex-Cowboy.

I agree with Archer on Durant. If he doesn't start, I don't know how much sense he makes as a backup. I think it's at least a possibility that it's starter or bust for him.

Agree with all that.

I think between McClain, Bishop and Coleman, that Hayden's a goner.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I think there's very little chance we're cutting an experienced LB who's played decently for us at two positions with this current group. Before Lee's injury, he was a likely cut if one or more of the young guys played well. Now he's a near lock to make the roster and play a reasonable number of snaps.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Is that the worst starting DL in the league?

I keep going back and forth on how bad I think it is. Melton's a question mark, but ACL recovery at this point is really not a gray area. He's clearly an above-average player in this defense otherwise. Crawford, too, I think has a legit shot to be an above average player at his position here in his third year. The team obviously loves him...you can tell they expect good things from him. McClain is a journeyman, but it's at the 1-tech. He'll likely be a below average player for us, but you never know. That leaves Lawrence. We had him as the equivalent of a late first round pick on our board. If he is, he's probably an average player in his first year at his position. Add it all up, and that's a slightly above average line, overall. Our depth is all over the place, too, but I'd say there's a decent shot that our top four backups (Selvie, Okoye, Bishop/Coleman/Gardener, whoever) are equivalent players to everybody else's backups.

If that's the case, I'd be pretty happy to have lost Ware and Hatcher and, effectively, Spencer in one offseason and come away with an average performance from the DL. Now...Crawford and Lawrence could both be well below average for us this year. But I don't think 'average' is all that much of a stretch for them, either. They could both end up being above average players this season, too.
 

Zman5

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,147
Reaction score
20,605
Crawford McClain Melton Lawrence

Do you know how many sacks these guys had last year in the NFL?
.
.
.
ZERO.

Yep. If those guys are the starters, none of our DL starters would have had a sack in 2013. Just think about that.
 

Fla Cowpoke

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,025
Reaction score
12,046
I look at it this way. Selvie and Hayden were starters a year ago. Chances are both are going to be reserves and in Hayden's case a very possible cut. I am also just very positive for some reason that we are going to get enough out of backups to make a good rotation. Whether it's Bass, or Coleman or Okoye or even Bishop or Gardner, I think the overall group is going to be better than what we had a year ago AND they are going to be used more to their strengths....fewer plays for all but more effective per play.
 
Top