Gibbs II
New Member
- Messages
- 186
- Reaction score
- 0
BigDFan5 said:Ryan Leaf and Jason White won alot of awards in college, it did them alot of good didnt it
It did Carson Palmer some good.
BigDFan5 said:Ryan Leaf and Jason White won alot of awards in college, it did them alot of good didnt it
Gibbs II said:It did Carson Palmer some good.
BigDFan5 said:Ryan Leaf and Jason White won alot of awards in college, it did them alot of good didnt it
SkinsHokieFan said:To compare Jason Campbell to either of those 2 guys is a joke
Leaf had no head on his shoulders and got thrust into a bad situation
Jason White did not have anywhere near the physical tools that Jason Campbell has
Come back with a much better argument there littedfan
rdsknsbaby said:its not my team... its your team.
BigDFan5 said:You talking college right> Jason White was FAR superior to Cambell in college. If you want to discuss facts let me know otherwise button your mouth .
littledfan how original did you think that up yourself or did you make a post on extreme asking people to elp you battle the mean Cowboys fans?
SkinsHokieFan said:Danny Wuerfall also had FAR superior stats in college when compared to QB's that were in school at the same time he was. Jake Plummer was in his draft. Who had better college numbers and who has had a better pro career?
Let me know when you wish to discuss facts
BigDFan5 said:Now your onto something then you agree college awards have nothing to do with the NFL and how a QB will perform therefore you agree that skinsfan26 is a complete and utter moron for even mentioning college awards like they mean something.
As for disucssing facts. One thing I learned on extremeskins is facts are not allowed when talking about the Commanders players.
SkinsHokieFan said:So what our facts here with Jason Campbell and why he is destined to be a collasal bust?
Because he played in 4 different systems in college? Because he improved his senior year? Because he is now in a situation where he has been able to sit for a year, and will have a very good offensive line, a terrific WR corps, and a running game to back him up? That he is playing under one of the best OC's in the NFL, who was on a staff that turned Kurt Warner into a star?
Or is it those silver and blue glasses clouding your vision again?
SkinsHokieFan said:So what our facts here with Jason Campbell and why he is destined to be a collasal bust?
Because he played in 4 different systems in college? Because he improved his senior year? Because he is now in a situation where he has been able to sit for a year, and will have a very good offensive line, a terrific WR corps, and a running game to back him up? That he is playing under one of the best OC's in the NFL, who was on a staff that turned Kurt Warner into a star?
rdsknsbaby said::bravo: i believe youre right ol' chap.
SkinsHokieFan said:So what our facts here with Jason Campbell and why he is destined to be a collasal bust?
Because he played in 4 different systems in college? Because he improved his senior year? Because he is now in a situation where he has been able to sit for a year, and will have a very good offensive line, a terrific WR corps, and a running game to back him up? That he is playing under one of the best OC's in the NFL, who was on a staff that turned Kurt Warner into a star?
Or is it those silver and blue glasses clouding your vision again?
HeavyHitta31 said:1: The SEC is not the best conference in America, the ACC is
2: They do when they have 3 offensive superstars, the best O-Line and the best defense in America
BigDFan5 said:you can throw all your burgandy eggs in the Cambell basket if you like. I expect to see you here in a few years repenting and apoligizing for your mistakes.
Mentioning palmer and Cambell together is like me mentioning Henson and Palmer together makes no sense
SkinsHokieFan said:So what our facts here with Jason Campbell and why he is destined to be a collasal bust?
Because he played in 4 different systems in college? Because he improved his senior year? Because he is now in a situation where he has been able to sit for a year, and will have a very good offensive line, a terrific WR corps, and a running game to back him up? That he is playing under one of the best OC's in the NFL, who was on a staff that turned Kurt Warner into a star?
Or is it those silver and blue glasses clouding your vision again?
silverbear said:Bringing in Todd Collins was a REAL vote of confidence... LOL...
I admire your confidence, but you might want to pause to consider that it just might be misguided... remember the last quarterback the Skins drafted late in the first round, their last "quarterback of the future"??
If you don't, here's a clue-- he's now playing for the Jets, and y'all got a SIXTH round pick for him... Patrick Ramsey didn't turn out to be all that, did he??
SkinsFan26 said:Todd Collins - Inexpensive, veteran #3 QB with knowledge of Saunders' system. Horrible signing, I agree.
Ramsey - drafted by Spurrier to run the fun n gun.
RYan Leaf had so much more talent than Campbell it isnt even worth discussing. To this day I still think Ryan Leaf had more pure football talent than Peyton Manning, Manning is just a football genius while Leaf is a headcase and freaks out when he is under pressure.SkinsHokieFan said:To compare Jason Campbell to either of those 2 guys is a joke
Leaf had no head on his shoulders and got thrust into a bad situation
Jason White did not have anywhere near the physical tools that Jason Campbell has
Come back with a much better argument there littedfan
silverbear said:Spurrier obviously had input on draft decisions, but he didn't make those calls... it was the Skins' personnel people who decided that Ramsey had the potential to be a long-time starting QB, and those are basically the same people who analyzed Jason Campbell... similarly, Gibbs had input on the Campbell decision, but he didn't make the final call, and that decision was based on the input provided by those personnel people...