Eli Manning
- Thread starter MC KAos
- Start date
burmafrd
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 43,820
- Reaction score
- 3,379
I have watched Eli in about 10 games over the last 3 years. Not just against us, but skins, Eagles, and others. I just do not see what the big deal is all about. IF his name WAS NOT MANNING, he would be getting a lot more heat then he is. He shows a lot of promise, but so far a lot more promise then results when you consider he has a great RB, and a fair number of other good players around him.
TruBlueCowboy
New Member
- Messages
- 7,301
- Reaction score
- 0
Hostile said:
I'm amazed at how many Cowboys fans wanted to tear this kid down. Remember the Henson/Manning comparisons?
:
bobtheflob
New Member
- Messages
- 1,768
- Reaction score
- 0
Here's my 2 cents on Eli. He's obviously young and can improve, but from what I've seen of him he has some major flaws right now.
He stares down his receivers. This is probably a common mistake by younger QBs, but he's particularly bad at it. He has a tendency to decide who he's going to pass to before the ball is even snapped, often forcing passes into tight coverage. He can get away with it sometimes because he has a couple of good big receiving targets in Shockey and Buress who can make catches while covered, but it does hurt him often.
He has trouble reading defenses. He struggled the most when teams changed up the defense and mixed in some good blitzing schemes, which is why I think he'll struggle against our 3-4 and Washington's complex defense.
He's just inaccurate sometimes. I don't know if it's a mechanical thing or if it's related to the first 2 points, but his throws are just off sometimes. When you look at his weapons, he really should have a higher completion percentage.
He actually regressed somewhat as the season went on last year. That's not a good sign for a young QB and may be due to the fact that defensive coordinators learned how to take advantage of his deficiencies. He also has one of the elite RBs in the league and I can guarantee you that if teams weren't so focussed on trying to stop Tiki that Eli's numbers would drop considerably. I think this is a crucial year for Eli, he needs to make improvements in his game or else he may become the below average quarterback that we saw at times near the end of the season last year.
He stares down his receivers. This is probably a common mistake by younger QBs, but he's particularly bad at it. He has a tendency to decide who he's going to pass to before the ball is even snapped, often forcing passes into tight coverage. He can get away with it sometimes because he has a couple of good big receiving targets in Shockey and Buress who can make catches while covered, but it does hurt him often.
He has trouble reading defenses. He struggled the most when teams changed up the defense and mixed in some good blitzing schemes, which is why I think he'll struggle against our 3-4 and Washington's complex defense.
He's just inaccurate sometimes. I don't know if it's a mechanical thing or if it's related to the first 2 points, but his throws are just off sometimes. When you look at his weapons, he really should have a higher completion percentage.
He actually regressed somewhat as the season went on last year. That's not a good sign for a young QB and may be due to the fact that defensive coordinators learned how to take advantage of his deficiencies. He also has one of the elite RBs in the league and I can guarantee you that if teams weren't so focussed on trying to stop Tiki that Eli's numbers would drop considerably. I think this is a crucial year for Eli, he needs to make improvements in his game or else he may become the below average quarterback that we saw at times near the end of the season last year.
SacredStar
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 4,183
- Reaction score
- 1,541
All I'm gonna say is that I would love Eli to be a member of the Cowboys.
I think we would have our franchise QB with him here.
I think we would have our franchise QB with him here.