MountaineerCowboy
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 29,419
- Reaction score
- 72,960
Because of the pedestal you have him on.Why would I think that?
Because of the pedestal you have him on.Why would I think that?
I give you the contract situation but everything else is bs.He is entering his 4th season. His setbacks have been not being good enough to even be a backup. His setback last year was not being good enough to beat out Sam Darnold for a backup job. Meanwhile every time he saw the field in his first 2 years his setback was being wildly inaccurate.
The thing about pretending he is a 2024 4th rounder is he is going to not be on a rookie deal after this year. If he starts next year and even looks like Goff out there (so a tier below Dak) he is going to get 2 years 90 million plus the 40 million in dead cap after Dak leaves. Now I think it is highly unlikely he looks good if he gets any play time based on the past 3 years of seeing him try to play but again the best case scenario does not save money and has you downgrading at QB for the same level of cap hit and just hoping in 2-3 years maybe some nice drafts can you get back into contention.
You sure you aren’t the one that has him on this pedal stool? You’re created more threads on him then I have….Because of the pedestal you have him on.
Again by that logic do not pay Micah, or Lamb, try to trade Martin because it is entirely possible all their cheap backups might suddenly become better than them and now you have more draft picks to get players who might be the future best ever at their positions. Just because it is possible does not make it likely.I give you the contract situation but everything else is bs.
You arent willing to let it play out. Jumping the gun for the told ya so.
That's no Horsemen.
More like Sheepherders!!!
Many people have been traded away due to contract consideration. That's nothing new. I expect each person on the team to earn their job. If we pick up a LBer/end, who either beats Micah, or execs don't want the contract, then Micah goes.Again by that logic do not pay Micah, or Lamb, try to trade Martin because it is entirely possible all their cheap backups might suddenly become better than them and now you have more draft picks to get players who might be the future best ever at their positions. Just because it is possible does not make it likely.
For context in this entire century there has been 1 QB who looked like a bust for 3 years and then suddenly turned it around to be great and that is Drew Brees. For those who do not know his first 3 years with the Chargers were so bad that they actually drafted Rivers (well they drafted Eli but were forced to trade him) but because this was pre rookie wage scale Rivers held out for a better deal and Brees was therefore the starter and had a Pro Bowl season and then actually did it again the following season and if not for a major injury to his shoulder they probably would have been forced to sign him and just see if anyone wanted Rivers. The thing is even factoring in the massive inflation of stats from 20 years ago to now (INTs across the league are way down and completion % is up about 6-7% just to name a few things) Brees in his 2 full seasons of starting STILL looked better than Lance.
So basically I cant find someone who looked as bad as Lance has the past 3 years being in the tier 1 QB lists this century.
8 years of results and you still cannot make up your mind?Fair point. A good chunk of fans already have their mind made up on Dak and won’t move off that stance for anything.
is it LIKELY that Lance is going to be a top NFL QB?Many people have been traded away due to contract consideration. That's nothing new. I expect each person on the team to earn their job. If we pick up a LBer/end, who either beats Micah, or execs don't want the contract, then Micah goes.
I don't believe there's enough sample size to make your claim Trey is a waste bust. The situation in SF was a mix of injury and success of the successor. The notion that they ONLY ditched Trey "because he sucks"...is pure supposition and cherry picking of events.
You just saying "well it's his fourth year he HAS to be a bust by now"...ignores his limited opportunity...and much of it because of injury and new team with a top 5 QB. Not *necessarily* because he sucks.
But hey..if it plays out as you say...you totally own the "told ya so". Congrats.
I mean its less of an "I told you so" and more "Looking at every single QB who has played this century, there is not a single example of a QB being awful for his 3 years and then becoming a t1 QB". If Trey Lance was good enough to beat out Sam Darnold the 49erswould have kept him as their backup but every single report that came out every single day during that competition would talk about how Darnold looked significantly better. So what we know is after 3 years in the NFL he had the skill level of a low end backup.Many people have been traded away due to contract consideration. That's nothing new. I expect each person on the team to earn their job. If we pick up a LBer/end, who either beats Micah, or execs don't want the contract, then Micah goes.
I don't believe there's enough sample size to make your claim Trey is a waste bust. The situation in SF was a mix of injury and success of the successor. The notion that they ONLY ditched Trey "because he sucks"...is pure supposition and cherry picking of events.
You just saying "well it's his fourth year he HAS to be a bust by now"...ignores his limited opportunity...and much of it because of injury and new team with a top 5 QB. Not *necessarily* because he sucks.
But hey..if it plays out as you say...you totally own the "told ya so". Congrats.
Just in cap space, he can keep the cash.Great news, can you give us back a 100 million on your way out?
Who’s holding out? He’s literally at OTAs while his teammates aren’t lol.A guy who doesn't play for money doesn't hold out on contract negotiations.
I'm OK w/ it if someone plays for the money, but man up and be truthful.
There are some people who think Romo could come out of retirement and win right now. Years in the league means nothing about your future.8 years of results and you still cannot make up your mind?
Option 3: Dak has agents to handle his business for him.Sounds to me like 1 of 2 things:
Lance looks more formidable than Dak thought he would and he feels the heat.
or
Dak is terrified to leave the comforting no consequence environment that has been created for him in Dallas and join a team that will hold him accountable that he is putting it out there he might be willing to not break the bank again and take a slight discount.
Either way this isn't the "confident a deal will be done Dak" we've seen in the past.
I think option 2 is too little too late. He's been a loser far to long to warrant another contract here. Tough luck and enjoy your new team next year, Dak!