ESPN - Favre can come back not guaranteed starting job

[utrunner07]

Lost by a field goal because he PASSED THE BALL DIRECTLY TO COREY WEBSTER!

And one interception equates to tanking the playoffs? No, especially considering the team he was on.

I can gurantee you the reason the packers do not want favre back has nothing to do with him "tanking the playoffs".

Im done arguing with you, you go from one thing to another and every time it becomes obvious you are wrong you move on to something else, tiresome...just no you are wrong...that is enough.

 

[Kangaroo]

Maybe you're right but Favre makes too many mistakes. He made them his whole career. I'm still stunned that he actually won a Super Bowl.

He also played against dead slow that made a lot of stupid mistakes

Two reason why they won they had a running game and special team Farve only threw the ball 27 times 14/27 (that is only 51%) but he had no picks and 2 tds

He also ran a td in

Bledsoe threw it 48 times 25/48 had 2 td's but the picks where awful 4 yes some where trying to come back but he had two picks that where down right stupid he threw long and threw the ball to the inside of the sideline instead of over the top and to the outside shoulder of the wr

I also thought NE got away from the run to quickly when the kick when they let Greenbay go off in the 2nd qtr

 

[Cochese]

And one interception equates to tanking the playoffs? No, especially considering the team he was on.

No, 10 years of awful performances does!

Yea, poor Brett and his 13-3 Packers. No talent on that team.

 

[utrunner07]

No, 10 years of awful performances does!

Yea, poor Brett and his 13-3 Packers. No talent on that team.

"Im done arguing with you, you go from one thing to another and every time it becomes obvious you are wrong you move on to something else, "

case and point.

 

[Cochese]

He also played against dead slow that made a lot of stupid mistakes

Two reason why they won they had a running game and special team Farve only threw the ball 27 times 14/27 (that is only 51%) but he had no picks and 2 tds

He also ran a td in

Bledsoe threw it 48 times 25/48 had 2 td's but the picks where awful 4 yes some where trying to come back but he had two picks that where down right stupid he threw long and threw the ball to the inside of the sideline instead of over the top and to the outside shoulder of the wr

I also thought NE got away from the run to quickly when the kick when they let Greenbay go off in the 2nd qtr

Desmond Howard was flat out awesome that game. I wonder if he is on Bretts christmas card list?

 

[Cochese]

"Im done arguing with you, you go from one thing to another and every time it becomes obvious you are wrong you move on to something else, "

case and point.

Aww, I thought you were done! Obviously not.

 

[Kangaroo]

Desmond Howard was flat out awesome that game. I wonder if he is on Bretts christmas card list?

No argument there he had the single biggest impact by a special team player that I ever seen in a SuperBowl

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

1998 - Loss - 2 TD, 2 INT, 79.7 rating
1999 - No playoffs
2000 - No playoffs
2001 - 1 Win, 1 Loss - 4 TD, 7 INT, 67.0 rating
2002 - Loss - 1 TD, 2 INT, 54.4 rating
2003 - 1 Win, 1 Loss - 3 TD, 1 INT, 94.2 - Hey, Dawkins is WIDE open!!
2004 - Loss - 1 TD, 4 INT, 55.4 rating
2005 - No playoffs
2006 - No playoffs
2007 - 1 Win, 1 Loss - 5 TD, 2 INT- Awesome pass to Corey Webster.

12 TD
17 INT

Wow... in 3 of 6 playoff seasons he throws more INT's than TD's - for some thats a please disregard - WOW

sigh...we have been over this...what you thought if you typed it out like this it would make you right? No...does not work that way.

Ok. Facts to prove a point dont work anymore... is that as of 2008? lmao

Lost by a field goal because he PASSED THE BALL DIRECTLY TO COREY WEBSTER!

Didnt he also hit McQuarters right in the numbers too!?!?

No, 10 years of awful performances does!

Yea, poor Brett and his 13-3 Packers. No talent on that team.

And I quote Brett Favre, "This the probably the MOST TALENTED team I have ever been on"

 

[CrazyCowboy]

Farve knows a thing or two about playing in the playoffs

 

[MichaelWinicki]

I think Farve is just another "It's all about me" player.

 

[CATCH17]

Brett Favre is one of the best Quarterbacks to ever play the game and he is still playing at a high level.

Put it like this...

If the Vikings get Favre they will win the division. If the Packers have Favre they will win the division.

 

[Sarge]

Aaron Rodgers is better than him.

............

 

[Sarge]

Uh no, I actually made it pretty clear that Im judging him on 10 years of ineptitude in the playoffs, a post which you conveniently diddnt respond to.

So, you're not basing it on his all-time passing yards? Care to guess where he stands in the area?

 

[Kilyin]

since it's relevant to this thread too...

http://cowboyszone.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2143403&postcount=96

 

[Cochese]

So, you're not basing it on his all-time passing yards? Care to guess where he stands in the area?

How predictably tiresome.

This doesnt change the fact that he has been blowing it in huge games for the last decade...

NEXT.

 

[dogunwo]

Rogers looked pretty good against us after Farve did his playoff performance impression.

John freaking Kitna looked good against us last year.

 

[dogunwo]

Prove it? Ok...Favre was great in the playoff! He was 39TD and 28INT, with MOST of those INTs comming in a couple of bad games that if you take out make him 36 TD and 18 INT...pretty dang good! Plus a super bowl and almost winning another....

then add onto that the level of talent around him (which was never up to his level)...he is one of the most solid playoff guys of all time!!!!
Proven.

(BTW it is truly ridiculous and meaningless to say someone is good with out comparing them to their competitors)

I cannot stand it when people take out one play or stat line to make their point stronger. If you are going to take out the "worst" performance, than you have to take out the "best" one too, if you are going to chalk it up as an anomaly.

Same thing people did with Julius 77yd run against the Saints. Its part of the average, get over it.

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

I would tell Favre that he can find a trade partner in the AFC for at least a second rounder or he can come back and compete with Rodgers. They dont owe him a damn thing and they certainly dont need to just let him run off and improve a team in their own conference much less division.

 

[gbrittain]

In 16 years Brett Favre led the Packers to one Super Bowl victory and another Super Bowl defeat.

11 Playoff appearances.

4 Conference title games.

Lets see what happens in the post-Favre era.

I mean when Dallas lost Aikman, it was a breeze to replace him and the success we had.

Aarond Rodgers is going to have to be pretty good to "suck" the way Favre has.

 

[switzersflask]

Brett Favre is one of the best Quarterbacks to ever play the game and he is still playing at a high level.

Put it like this...

If the Vikings get Favre they will win the division. If the Packers have Favre they will win the division.

Captain Obvious here.