rpntex
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 1,470
- Reaction score
- 1,042
And what has that gotten us besides 2 playoff wins in a decade? Romo isnt Tom Brady. According to the Romo homers, he needs a perfect team to win it all. Should have rebuild this team a long time ago.
First off, I'm not a "Romo Homer". I just don't think it's fair to lay everything at the feet of the quarterback in a sport as team oriented as football. That goes for every team, and every quarterback. I don't look at the patriots and say "Tom Brady won so many Super Bowls, and lost so many". Roger Staubach's Super Bowl record isn't 2-2. Rather, the Dallas Cowboys Super Bowl record is 2-2 with him at quarterback.
Second, I'm not saying that Romo needs a "perfect team" around him to win. He's had all the ingredients at times, but things have happened – some on his part, but more not on his part to sidetrack the Cowboys' opportunities. For instance, hold him accountable or responsible for Parcells' foolish game plan against Seattle in 06 is stupid. Dallas was playing a Seattle secondary that included a grocery bagger and a convenient store clerk, yet Parcells refused to throw the football. It should have never come down to any last-second field goal.
The same can be said for the 2007 playoff loss against the Giants. There were so many individual errors that could've turned this game on it's ear. The only real mistake Romo made – if you can collect that – was the interception on the desperation throw on the last play of the game. Otherwise, there was, in no particular order
1) and offense of game plan that left the line and Marion Barber gassed before the end of the first half
2) A critical (and bogus) offsides penalty against Demarcus Ware, on third down, on the Giants two-minute scoring drive before half.
3) and absolutely stupid pass interference penalty against Jacques Reeves on that same two minute drive before half. It also came on third down and the gated a defensive stop.
4) Patrick Crayton (X 2)
Romo was terrible against Minnesota in the 09 playoffs, but then again, he spent the time throwing from his backside thanks to a porous offensive line.
Then came 2014, in which Romo was absolutely brilliant aside from the open game against the Niners. Dallas did not lose to Green Bay because of Romo… that launch was completely on the defense they could not get a stop at any time, nor could it put any pressure on a one-legged Aaron Rodgers.
Nothing personal, I just think it's stupid to blame the quarterback for things that are beyond his control.