ESPN: NFL's five best improvising QBs of all time

03EBZ06

Need2Speed
Messages
7,984
Reaction score
411
Playing quarterback in the NFL is one of the most meticulously orchestrated and regimented jobs in football. There are dozens of excruciatingly specific plays, often with various permutations and variables.

Like Tony Romo and Brett Favre, there have been quarterbacks in NFL history who have broken out of the usual box and made things up on the fly. Here are five fantastic football improvisers who sometimes seemed as if they were playing a scaled-down sandlot version of the game:

Randall Cunningham

The all-time leading rusher among NFL quarterbacks, with 4,928 yards (and 35 touchdowns). … Played for the Philadelphia Eagles from 1985 to '96 and threw for 407 yards in the "Fog Bowl" playoff game at Chicago. … Commanded NFL's highest-scoring offense (556 points) at Minnesota in 1998. … Named to four Pro Bowls.

Signature improv play(s): (1) In a "Monday Night Football" game in 1988, Eagles versus Giants, Cunningham was crushed by linebacker Carl Banks. Cunningham somehow defied gravity, twisted his body in midair, touched his hand to the ground for balance and then threw a touchdown pass to tight end Jimmie Giles.

(2) Throwing from his end zone in 1990, Cunningham eluded Bills defensive end Bruce Smith and, off his back foot, heaved the ball 60 yards (into the wind) to wideout Fred Barnett, who took it in for a 95-yard touchdown.

John Elway

With 3,417 yards, ranks sixth in rushing among quarterbacks. … Enshrined in the Hall of Fame in 2004. … Named to nine Pro Bowls. … Led the Denver Broncos to wins in Super Bowls XXXII and XXXIII (MVP). … Holds the NFL record for 47 game-winning or game-tying drives in the fourth quarter.

Signature improv play: With the score of Super Bowl XXXII tied at 17, Elway faced a critical third-and-6 at the Packers' 12-yard line. Flushed from the pocket, he scrambled, was hit by Green Bay safety LeRoy Butler and was sent spinning like a helicopter. Elway got the first down, which set up the go-ahead touchdown.

Roger Staubach

Roger "The Dodger" led the Dallas Cowboys to four NFC titles and victories in Super Bowls VI (MVP) and XII. … Winner of the 1963 Heisman Trophy at the Naval Academy. … Named to six Pro Bowls. … Led the NFL in passer rating in four seasons. … Rushed for 2,264 yards and 20 touchdowns. … Led Dallas to 23 comeback victories.


Signature improv play: In a 1975 divisional playoff game at Metropolitan Stadium, Staubach launched a 50-yard touchdown pass to receiver Drew Pearson to lift the Cowboys to a last-minute, 17-14 victory over the Vikings. Afterward, Staubach told reporters he had said a "Hail Mary" before throwing the pass and the phrase entered the football lexicon.


Fran Tarkenton

The original scrambling quarterback, "Scramblin' Fran" or "Frantic Fran" bought time with his feet and consistently made spectacular plays down the field. … Fourth in career rushing yards (3,674) for a quarterback. … Named to play in nine Pro Bowls. … Led Minnesota to three Super Bowls in the 1970s. … Named NFL MVP in 1975.

Signature improv play: In a 1964 regular-season game, the Vikings trailed Green Bay, 23-21, with less than a minute left. In the huddle, Tarkenton instructed his receivers to run 25 yards downfield, adding, "I'll scramble around until I find one of you open." It might have been the first time Tarkenton -- or probably any quarterback -- actually called a scramble play. It worked when Tarkenton found Gordie Smith for a first down. Fred Cox later kicked a field goal to give Minnesota a 24-23 victory.

Steve Young

The only left-handed quarterback enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame (2005). … Played with the San Francisco 49ers from 1987 to '99. … Holds the record for the highest career passer rating ever, 96.8. … Led the NFL in passing a record-tying six times. … Named to seven Pro Bowls. … Second among quarterbacks in career rushing and holds the record for most rushing TDs, with 43. … MVP of Super Bowl XXIX.

Signature improv play: In a 1988 regular-season game against the Vikings, Young replaced injured Joe Montana and scrambled for a spectacular, zigzagging 49-yard touchdown, eluding seven would-be Minnesota tacklers. His dive into the end zone with 1:58 left gave the 49ers a 24-21 lead that held up for the victory.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/columns/story?columnist=garber_greg&id=3128930
 

Mavs Man

All outta bubble gum
Messages
4,672
Reaction score
0
If Romo continues his success for another five years or more, he'll cement his place among these names for his play. He already has a number of "how did he do that??" type plays.
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
#6

Tony Romo

Tony "Romomentum"
was the first player in Eastern Illinois and Ohio Valley Conference history to win the Walter Payton Award, given annually to the nation's top player at the NCAA Division I-AA level. Romo has thus far led the Dallas Cowboys to an undefeated NFC division record with an NFC East title on the horizon. Romo was selected to his first MVP with less than one season under his belt.

Signature improv play: Retrieving a ball snapped over his head that takes him 30+ yards away from LOS and running it back past midfield for a 4 yard first down.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,472
Randall Cuningham doesn't belong on this list. Good grief.

You mentioned Favre in the intro... Why not just put him on it?
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
Chocolate Lab;1794789 said:
Randall Cuningham doesn't belong on this list. Good grief.

You mentioned Favre in the intro... Why not just put him on it?

Why doesn't Cunningham belong on the list? Early in his career his whole game was improvising.
 

nathanlt

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,042
Reaction score
3,045
YoMick;1794773 said:
#6

Tony Romo

Tony "Romomentum"
was the first player in Eastern Illinois and Ohio Valley Conference history to win the Walter Payton Award, given annually to the nation's top player at the NCAA Division I-AA level. Romo has thus far led the Dallas Cowboys to an undefeated NFC division record with an NFC East title on the horizon. Romo was selected to his first MVP with less than one season under his belt.

Signature improv play: Retrieving a ball snapped over his head that takes him 30+ yards away from LOS and running it back past midfield for a 4 yard first down.

You forgot this one.
In Super Bowl XLII, Passed for 25/32 for 527 yards and 8 touchdowns, and rushed for 1 more, in an 82-0 blowout of the Patriots. Unconfirmed reports that he called the Patriots "slut". Tom Brady cried, Belicheck pouted. The nation cheered at the whuppin the Patriots had coming.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,472
joseephuss;1794795 said:
Why doesn't Cunningham belong on the list? Early in his career his whole game was improvising.

Because IMO Favre is a much better candidate. And I'd think you'd give some consideration as to how good overall the player was. This list is like one of those Sesame Street "Which one of these things is not like the others" list. Elway, Staubach, Tarkenton, and Young are truly all-time greats. Cunningham was pretty good for a few years.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
Chocolate Lab;1794807 said:
Because IMO Favre is a much better candidate. And I'd think you'd give some consideration as to how good overall the player was. This list is like one of those Sesame Street "Which one of these things is not like the others" list. Elway, Staubach, Tarkenton, and Young are truly all-time greats. Cunningham was pretty good for a few years.

He was not as good overall as those others, but he was probably the top improviser of the bunch.
 

SportsAnalyzer

New Member
Messages
507
Reaction score
0
Chocolate Lab;1794789 said:
Randall Cuningham doesn't belong on this list. Good grief.

You mentioned Favre in the intro... Why not just put him on it?


Come on Choclate Lab, we all hate the Eagles but you have to give credit when credit is due. Randall was known for creating something that wasn't there and turning it into a big play. Like the Buffalo game in 1990 when he was trapped in back of the endzone and started to scramble and threw a 95 yd TD pass. The man was very exciting to watch.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,472
SportsAnalyzer;1794833 said:
Come on Choclate Lab, we all hate the Eagles but you have to give credit when credit is due. Randall was known for creating something that wasn't there and turning it into a big play. Like the Buffalo game in 1990 when he was trapped in back of the endzone and started to scramble and threw a 95 yd TD pass. The man was very exciting to watch.
So you think he deserves to be on this list over Favre?

But somehow I know you aren't totally impartial in this argument.

And BTW, I remember that play and the one where he stayed on his feet when hit by Banks, but I don't think you put guys on all-time lists based on a couple of plays. Not surprised ESPN does, though.
 

SportsAnalyzer

New Member
Messages
507
Reaction score
0
Chocolate Lab;1794867 said:
So you think he deserves to be on this list over Favre?

But somehow I know you aren't totally impartial in this argument.

And BTW, I remember that play and the one where he stayed on his feet when hit by Banks, but I don't think you put guys on all-time lists based on a couple of plays. Not surprised ESPN does, though.


A couple of Plays? Now you are going to make me go into my NFL video Library and give you more
 

03EBZ06

Need2Speed
Messages
7,984
Reaction score
411
Chocolate Lab;1794867 said:
So you think he deserves to be on this list over Favre?
Since this article is predicated on incredible signature plays, it would depend on what signature play Favre has orchestrated an improbable victory.
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
03EBZ06;1794880 said:
Since this article is predicated on incredible signature plays, it would depend on what signature play Favre has orchestrated an improbable victory.

Didnt Favre pass the all time INT record of 277?....

So he has over 277 incredible signature plays :lmao2:
 

Jerry Tagge

New Member
Messages
106
Reaction score
0
YoMick;1794884 said:
Didnt Favre pass the all time INT record of 277?....

So he has over 277 incredible signature plays :lmao2:
Favre also has the lowest interception/pass attempt ratio in Packers history. Yes, it's better than Bart Starr's.

Don't worry, if Romo plays another 10 years he'll break Favre's interception record. ;)

Seriously, I like Romo a lot. Best young QB in the game. The guy has all the tools to be an HOF QB.
 

Jerry Tagge

New Member
Messages
106
Reaction score
0
YoMick;1794884 said:
Didnt Favre pass the all time INT record of 277?....

So he has over 277 incredible signature plays :lmao2:
Favre also has 436 incredible signature plays. Where's Staubach, Meredith and Aikman on that list?
 

03EBZ06

Need2Speed
Messages
7,984
Reaction score
411
Jerry Tagge;1794909 said:
Favre also has the lowest interception/pass attempt ratio in Packers history. Yes, it's better than Bart Starr's.
Wow, Packers' history, that is very impressive, simply amazing. Where does he stand in NFL history?
 

03EBZ06

Need2Speed
Messages
7,984
Reaction score
411
Jerry Tagge;1794910 said:
Favre also has 436 incredible signature plays. Where's Staubach, Meredith and Aikman on that list?
There was no mention of Mededith and Aikman so I don't know why you are digging.

BTW, how many SB ring does Favre have? I'm pretty sure Aikman have more than Favre.
 

Royal Laegotti

Dyin' ain't much of a livin', boy!
Messages
4,971
Reaction score
0
nathanlt;1794799 said:
You forgot this one.
In Super Bowl XLII, Passed for 25/32 for 527 yards and 8 touchdowns, and rushed for 1 more, in an 82-0 blowout of the Patriots. Unconfirmed reports that he called the Patriots "slut". Tom Brady cried, Belicheck pouted. The nation cheered at the whuppin the Patriots had coming.

And ruined the Patriots quest for a undefeated season!;)
 
Top