All Time - Mike Reid - One of the most dominant DTs ever who was one of the few who was smart enough to walk away at the right time.
Current - Joshua Cribbs - Might be the best special teamer I've ever seen. I can't remember someone being one of the best returners in the league and one of the best coverage players at the same time.
Shaun "Lil Mac" McDonald
Mike Wright
Brian Westbrook
The Shanle
Darelle Revis
Fahkir Brown
Patrick Willis
Ty Law
Steve Weatherford
Trevor Pryce
Wes Welker
I can only give faves a decade removed at least because I love the Cowboys too much to give credence to other teams lol but here's some of mine: (I'm from upstate NY originally)
QB: Dan Fouts, Dave Krieg
RB: Bo Jackson, Christian Okoye, Freeman McNeil
FB: Sam Gash
WR: Andre Reed, Johnny Lam Jones
WR: Sterling Sharpe, Mike Quick
WR: James Lofton, Mark Duper
TE: Kellen Winslow I, Pete Metzelaars, Clint Didier (sue me)