Current players or anytime?
For my favorite non-Cowboys players ever it would be:
Johnny Unitas, Paul Warfield, Earl Campbell, John Hannah, Anthony Munoz, Walter Payton, Y.A. Tittle, Andy Robustelli, Rosey Brown, Jack Stroud, Dick Modzelewski, Sam Huff, Erich Barnes, Dick Lynh, Jimmy Patton, Frank Giffod, Alex Webster, Del Shofner, Gene Hickerson, Bill Glass, Jim Brown, Bernie Parrish, Frank Ryan, Bob Reynolds, Larry Stallings, Jerry Stovall, Charley Johnson, John Henry Johnson, Charlie Bradshaw, Ernie Stautner, Andy Russell, Johnny Sample, Sonny Jurgensen, Rick Casares, Johnny Morris, Richie Pettibon, Bill George, Rosey Taylor, Mike Pyle, Ed O'Bradovich, Earl Leggett, Doug Atkins, Herb Adderly, Willie Wood, Jim Taylor, Ray Nitschke, Ordell Brasse, Gino Marchetti, Bobby Boyd, Lenny Lyles, John Gordy, Dick "Night Train" Lane, Yale Lary, Milt Plum, Ollie Matson, Bill Brown, Mick Tingelhoff, Karl Kassulke, Mike Henry, Charley Cowan, Merlin Olsen, Rosey Grier, Deacon Jones, Alvin Haymond, Dick Bass, Marlin McKeever, Billy Cannon, Paul Lowe, Art Powell, Jim Otto, Johnny Robinson, Len Dawson, Clem Daniels, Abner Haynes, Wahoo McDaniel, Peyton Manning, John Elway, Bubba Smith, Julius Peppers, Lance Alworth, George Blanda, Mike Haynes, Eddie Meador, Archie Manning, Larry Wilson, Gale Sayers, Jackie Slater, Lem Barney, Alan Page, Jim Marshall, Gene Washington (Vikings), Roger Brown, Tom Mack, Lamar Lundy, Roman Gabriel, Jack Snow, Lenny Moore, Tom Matte, Jim Parker, Mike Curtis, Raymond Berry, Tommy Nobis, Jeff Van Note, Steve Bartkowski, Tommy McDonald, Ron Mix, Ernie Ladd, Keith Lincoln, Don Maynard, Pat Fischer, Darrell Green, Tim Rossovich, Fred Dryer, Jack Youngblood, Earl McCullough, Earl Morrall, Rick Volk, Matt Snell, Willie Lanier, Buck Buchanan, Jim Tryer, Bobby Bell, Ben Davidson, Daryl Lamonica, Kenny Stabler, Fred Biletinikoff, Rich "Tombstone" Jackson, Tom Jackson, Terry Metcalf, Harry Carson, James Lofton, Doug English, Doug Plank, Gary Fencik, Mike Singletary, Lee Roy Selmon, Dan Fouts, Steve DeBerg, Steve Grogan, Harold Jackson, Sam Cunningham, Stanley Morgan, Wesley Walker, Bert Jones, Jack Lambert, Clay Matthews, Ken Anderson, Isaac Curtis, Pete Johnson, Cliff Branch, Dave Casper, Ted Hendricks, Art Shell, Willie Brown, Louie Kelcher, Charlie Joiner, Steve Largent, Jim Zorn, Dave Brown, Kenny Easley, Billy Sims, William Andrews, Joe Jacoby, Charles Mann, Art Monk, Leonard Marshall, Gary Reasons, Dan Hampton, Richard Dent, Roger Carr, Raymond Chester, Chuck Foreman, Ronnie Lott, Nolan Cromwell, Mark Duper, Mark Clayton, Dan Marino, Freeman McNeil, Fred Smerlas, Darryl Talley, Warren Moon, Mike Munchak, Bruce Matthews, Rulon Jones, Karl Mecklenberg, Dennis Smith, Steve Atwater, Jacob Green, Howie Long, Rod Martin, Marcus Allen, Ed White, Kellen Winslow, Carl Banks, Pepper Johnson, Joey Browner, Keith Millard, Chris Doleman, Kevin Glover, Jerry Ball, Bennie Blades, Alphonso Carreker, Jim Everett, Henry Ellard, Sam Mills, Pat Swilling, Vaughn Johnson, Rickey Jackson, Dalton Hilliard, Bruce Smith, Cornelius Bennett, Andre Reed, Ray Donaldson, Irving Fryar, Bruce Armstrong, Marty Lyons, Jim Sweeney, Hugh Green, David Fulcher, James Brooks, Bernie Kosar, Kevin Mack, Ernest Byner, Gerald McNeil, Felix Wright, Michael Dean Perry, Rod Woodson, Dermotti Dawson, Jeff Bryant, Eugene Robinson, Curt Warner, Greg Townsend, Simon Fletcher, Tim Brown, Jack Del Rio, Neil Smith, Aeneas Williams, Larry Centers, Robert Porcher, Chris Spielman, Herman Moore, Barry Sanders, Brett Favre, Sterling Sharpe, Shannon Sharpe, Keith Van Horne, Trace Armstrong, John Lynch, Hardy Nickerson, Jerry Rice, Joe Montana, Steve Young, Tom Rathman, Michael Haynes, Jessie Tuggle, Keith Brookings, Chuck Smith, James Geathers, Roger Harper, Jerome Bettis, Jim Kelly, Steve Tasker, Glenn Parker, Nate Odoms, Keith Jackson, Louis Oliver, Richmond Webb, Drew Bledsoe, Ben Coates, Tony Siragusa, Eric Green, Levon Kirkland, Joe Juevicius, Tiki Barber, Michael Strahan, Tre Johnson, Bobby Taylor, Randall McDaniel, Jeff Christy, Jamie Sharper, Derrick Brooks, Charlie Batch, Luther Elliss, Olin Kreutz, Jamal Anderson, Tim McDonald, Bryant Young, Mark Fields, Steve Beuerlein, Mushin Muhammad, Wesley Walls, Kevin Greene, Orlando Pace, Roman Phifer, Isaac Bruce, Mo Lewis, Aaron Glenn, Curtis Martin, Wane Crebet, Sam Madison, Jason Taylor, Sam Cowart, Tedy Bruschi, Ted Johnson, Ty Law, Willie McGinnest, Tarik Glenn, Marshall Faulk, Marvin Harrison, Tony Boselli, Seth Payne, Donovin Darius, Keenan McCardell, Steve McNair, Frank Wycheck, Orpheus Roye, Mike Vrabel, Carnell Lake, Hines Ward, Priest Holmes, Takeo Spikes, Ed McCaffrey, Cortez Kennedy, Derrick Thomas, Tony Gonzalez, Junior Seau, DeShaun Foster, Nick Goings, Brad Hoover, Kris Jenkins, Dan Morgan, LaDanian Tomlinson.
I'll stop there...
