FWST: RICK HERRIN: LaFleur is proof draft is a gamble

Cbz40

The Grand Poobah
Messages
31,387
Reaction score
39
LaFleur is proof draft is a gamble

By RICK HERRIN
STAR-TELEGRAM STAFF WRITER



Tight end David LaFleur only played four seasons with the Cowboys.


If the Cowboys' draft plans had gone right, tight end David LaFleur would probably be winding down a successful career.


Instead, the No. 22 overall pick in the 1997 draft is long out of football and the team hasn't selected an offensive player in the first round since.
By the time he was released before the 2001 season, the Cowboys were basically doing him a favor.


"It was really a relief," LaFleur said of being cut after training camp. "It was such a struggle to just get up and perform with a body that had definitely given out."


LaFleur, with grizzly bear-like size at 6-foot-7, 280 pounds, had an arthritic spine condition and a broken body by age 27 and left the league as a first-round bust. But the Cowboys could end the streak this year by drafting an offensive player in the first round.


The Cowboys are aging at receiver with 30-somethings Terrell Owens and Terry Glenn and are in their best position in years to take the best talent on the board. And 10 years later, they sit at No. 22 again.


Once considered the complete package of pass-catching ability and blocking, the Cowboys liked LaFleur better than Kansas City Chiefs eight-time Pro Bowler Tony Gonzalez.


"We also thought David was going to provide us more of a blocker and pretty good pass catcher than Gonzalez," said former Cowboys scouting director Larry Lacewell said. "We certainly didn't get the best player as it has proven."


LaFleur, 33, played only four years, 53 games and caught 85 passes for 729 yards and 12 touchdowns.


"I thought David was the more complete player as far as what he could do blocking," said former Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman, who had a pre-draft workout with LaFleur and Tony Gonzalez. "David was pegged as the right guy for us. He had some injuries and football as it ended up wasn't something that was a real priority in his life."


Since his football career ended, LaFleur has had plenty of success in business. He moved to Sulphur, La., which is near his hometown of Westlake, and is a part-owner and operator of 23 medical imaging facilities. LaFleur, who played at LSU, and his wife Melody have three children -- Jake (6), Jolie (5) and John David (7 months).


The Cowboys wanted LaFleur so bad in the 1997 draft that they moved up from the No. 25 spot to No. 22 in the first round in a trade with Philadelphia and also gave the Eagles a fifth-round pick in 1997 and a third-round choice in 1998. That third-round pick in 1998 landed the Eagles Pro Bowl linebacker Jeremiah Trotter.


"Sometimes you do things out of need," Lacewell said. "Moving up in the draft was probably wrong. Drafting him was probably wrong. We definitely needed him, but we probably overpaid for him a little."


Cowboys Pro Bowl tight end Jason Witten, a third-round pick out of Tennessee in 2003, eclipsed LaFleur's career total for catches and yards -- in a single season (2004).


LaFleur isn't troubled by an unfulfilled career with the Cowboys, only with a back that won't allow him to run and get out of bed without a struggle. Before his back problems knocked him out of the NFL, LaFleur had already lived his football dream playing at LSU. He still attends LSU games and talks often with Tigers head coach Les Miles, who was his position coach with the Cowboys from 1998-2000.


LeFleur's first signs of a back problem came at LSU, but Lacewell said there were no pre-draft red flags to cause concern. He played 16 games as a rookie and started the next three seasons.


LaFleur, who dealt with back spasms daily, had a career-best season in 1999 with 35 catches for 322 yards and a team-high seven touchdown catches. The Cowboys made the playoffs under Chan Gailey.
But the following year he needed back surgery for a herniated disc and played only eight games.


"After the surgery, I thought I had kicked it," LaFleur said. "I had a decent season, then I ended up herniating the disc above it. Then I knew the clock was ticking. It was a constant battle each day."


LaFleur's career with the Cowboys began in Westlake. Before the draft, the Cowboys rolled into Westlake High School and brought Aikman for a workout.


"I remember being nervous and star struck," LaFleur said. "And I was surprised how big Troy Aikman was."
LaFleur's workout went well and the team also did the same thing with Gonzalez. Gonzalez was drafted well ahead of LaFleur at No. 13 by the Chiefs.


"Jerry [Jones] wanted him, [Barry] Switzer wanted him and Troy [Aikman] wanted him," Lacewell said of LaFleur. "There wasn't anybody against him."
Only his body.
Rick Herrin, 817-685-3864 rickherrin@star-telegram.com
 
Messages
706
Reaction score
1
Cbz40;1458095 said:
"We also thought David was going to provide us more of a blocker and pretty good pass catcher than Gonzalez," said former Cowboys scouting director Larry Lacewell said. "We certainly didn't get the best player as it has proven."

LaFleur, 33, played only four years, 53 games and caught 85 passes for 729 yards and 12 touchdowns.

"I thought David was the more complete player as far as what he could do blocking," said former Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman, who had a pre-draft workout with LaFleur and Tony Gonzalez. "David was pegged as the right guy for us. He had some injuries and football as it ended up wasn't something that was a real priority in his life."

The Cowboys wanted LaFleur so bad in the 1997 draft that they moved up from the No. 25 spot to No. 22 in the first round in a trade with Philadelphia and also gave the Eagles a fifth-round pick in 1997 and a third-round choice in 1998. That third-round pick in 1998 landed the Eagles Pro Bowl linebacker Jeremiah Trotter.

Cowboys Pro Bowl tight end Jason Witten, a third-round pick out of Tennessee in 2003, eclipsed LaFleur's career total for catches and yards -- in a single season (2004).

i feel for the guy (lafleur). i'm sorry he was injured. i'm sorry his career was cut short.

but you simply absolutely unequivocally cannot miss that badly in the first round. the drafting of lafleur handcuffed the cowboys for 5+ seasons, and we have only recently recovered from that IMHO.

he and rod hill have to be two of the biggest draft-busts in franchise history...
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Cowboy Bill Watts;1458105 said:
i feel for the guy (lafleur). i'm sorry he was injured. i'm sorry his career was cut short.

but you simply absolutely unequivocally cannot miss that badly in the first round. the drafting of lafleur handcuffed the cowboys for 5+ seasons, and we have only recently recovered from that IMHO.

he and rod hill have to be two of the biggest draft-busts in franchise history...


Handcuffed the Cowboys for 5+ years?

Double "Wow".

The Galloway trade along with his subsequent injury in his very first game did far more to set this franchise back than blown 1st round pick on LaFluer.

LaFluer is an all-time great Cowboy compared to Billy Cannon Jr.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
Cowboy Bill Watts;1458105 said:
i feel for the guy (lafleur). i'm sorry he was injured. i'm sorry his career was cut short.

but you simply absolutely unequivocally cannot miss that badly in the first round. the drafting of lafleur handcuffed the cowboys for 5+ seasons, and we have only recently recovered from that IMHO.

he and rod hill have to be two of the biggest draft-busts in franchise history...

I don't know about the 5+ years, but I didn't like the pick at all at that time. Everything from that point just reinforced my opinion. He just did not look like a good player to me. I never thought he was as great a blocker as they claimed he was, either. I would watch him block and thought at best that he looked okay. Nothing special and Dallas hasn't been hindered since he retired as Spagnola has written a couple of times.

He certainly was no threat as a receiver. The thing I really remember was ESPN showing a highlight package after he was selected. In it he must have fumbled the ball 3 or 4 different times. These were highlights. He was not worth a late 1st round pick and especially worth trading up to get. Lacewell and Jerry tagged the wrong player. Heck, there is a reason why tight ends generally are not picked in the first round. The ones that are picked are seen as special. LaFleur did not look special.
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
Cowboy Bill Watts;1458105 said:
i feel for the guy (lafleur). i'm sorry he was injured. i'm sorry his career was cut short.

but you simply absolutely unequivocally cannot miss that badly in the first round. the drafting of lafleur handcuffed the cowboys for 5+ seasons, and we have only recently recovered from that IMHO.

he and rod hill have to be two of the biggest draft-busts in franchise history...

huh? sorry, dont agree at all

LaFleur was a concensus 1st rd pick...the guy wasnt some 2nd day talent type scrub that we grossly reached for...one scouting service even had him rated as the 9th best player in the draft (I think it was Blesto)

David
 

Sandyf

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,248
Reaction score
1,379
Another example of a team drafting for need instead of the BPA and also overpaying for him. A fifth and a third for outway the value to move 3 slots.

Everyone gets enamoured by the trade value chart but as we can see it is only a tool and if a team really wants to move up for someone or wants a certain player, they many times overpay according to the draft chart for it.
 

SultanOfSix

Star Power
Messages
12,956
Reaction score
8,174
He could have been a stud if it wasn't for his back. So, I don't know how he can be diminished as a "bust".
 

Big Country

Rolling Thunder
Messages
3,761
Reaction score
40
MichaelWinicki;1458107 said:
Handcuffed the Cowboys for 5+ years?

Double "Wow".

The Galloway trade along with his subsequent injury in his very first game did far more to set this franchise back than blown 1st round pick on LaFluer.

LaFluer is an all-time great Cowboy compared to Billy Cannon Jr.

agree exponentially!!!

one of the worst sports management decisions in history!
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,680
Reaction score
12,392
Cbz40;1458095 said:
Once considered the complete package of pass-catching ability and blocking, the Cowboys liked LaFleur better than Kansas City Chiefs eight-time Pro Bowler Tony Gonzalez.

If this is the case then everyone involved needs to be locked out of the draft room from now on.
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,680
Reaction score
12,392
dbair1967;1458127 said:
huh? sorry, dont agree at all

LaFleur was a concensus 1st rd pick...the guy wasnt some 2nd day talent type scrub that we grossly reached for...one scouting service even had him rated as the 9th best player in the draft (I think it was Blesto)

David

He was a 1st round talent -- he wasn't worth moving up for. Typical Jerry "I can't wait" mentality.
 

CaptainAmerica

Active Member
Messages
5,030
Reaction score
26
Imo, this is the key point of the whole article and the real reason LaFleur was a BUST... "David was pegged as the right guy for us. He had some injuries and football as it ended up wasn't something that was a real priority in his life."

I hope we've learned to look at that aspect of a prospect and determine if the guy has a genuine desire to be the best and not just collect a paycheck.

That desire to be the best, combined with their first round ability, is what made Emmitt, Troy and Mike the great players they were in their day.
 

JPM

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,301
Reaction score
1,236
aardvark;1458175 said:
agree exponentially!!!

one of the worst sports management decisions in history!

I would venture and say it's probably the worst decision the team ever made.
 

dmq

If I'm so pretty, why am I available?
Messages
7,436
Reaction score
941
Do you remember where you were when we drafted David Lafleur?
I was sitting at a computer in Kuwait during my time in the military. I thought it was a good pick until I heard them mention a history of back problems.:banghead:
 

superpunk

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,330
Reaction score
75
JPM;1458212 said:
I would venture and say it's probably the worst decision the team ever made.
It may not have been, had Galloway actually produced here like he has in Tampa Bay.

But then the pickle juice game happened, and we got a mudhole stomped in our ill-prepared hard knocks participating behinds, and Dave Campo kept Joey Galloway in the game during the waning minutes of a 20 point blowout....and then...it was all over.
 

adamknite

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,226
Reaction score
805
I have an old LeFluer reversable jersey somewhere I got after he was drafted........:banghead:
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
JPM;1458212 said:
I would venture and say it's probably the worst decision the team ever made.


The Galloway trade combined with Jerreh's great desire to overpay aging stars did more to wreck this franchise than any 5 of his crummy draft picks.
 

ZeroClub

just trying to get better
Messages
7,619
Reaction score
1
CaptainAmerica;1458207 said:
Imo, this is the key point of the whole article and the real reason LaFleur was a BUST... "David was pegged as the right guy for us. He had some injuries and football as it ended up wasn't something that was a real priority in his life."

I hope we've learned to look at that aspect of a prospect and determine if the guy has a genuine desire to be the best and not just collect a paycheck.

That desire to be the best, combined with their first round ability, is what made Emmitt, Troy and Mike the great players they were in their day.
Yeah, that quote sticks out, doesn't it?

I wonder if Aikman thinks that LaFleur could have played through the back pain and/or that LaFleur refused treatments that might have put him back on the field?
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,104
Reaction score
11,429
CaptainAmerica;1458207 said:
Imo, this is the key point of the whole article and the real reason LaFleur was a BUST... "David was pegged as the right guy for us. He had some injuries and football as it ended up wasn't something that was a real priority in his life."

I hope we've learned to look at that aspect of a prospect and determine if the guy has a genuine desire to be the best and not just collect a paycheck.
Exactly... I noticed that quote as well as the one that LaFleur had already reached his dream by playing football for LSU. I can see that... Some of these kids, especially in the southeast where college football is bigger than the NFL, grow up dreaming of playing in the SEC or for the state school, not for a pro team on Sundays.

But anyway... I didn't see anything hugely wrong with taking him, it was more that we gave up so much. A fifth? Okay. But a third as well? Gawd, the Eagles played us for such fools back in those days. Maybe the days of Jerry falling in love with players is over. (I remember Jerry drooling about how incredibly huge LaFleur's hands were... Good grief.) I do think Jerry has learned a lot since those days, so maybe -- hopefully -- he's smarter now.
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
ZeroClub;1458239 said:
Yeah, that quote sticks out, doesn't it?

I wonder if Aikman thinks that LaFleur could have played through the back pain and/or that LaFleur refused treatments that might have put him back on the field?


There is no "treatment" for keeping disks from herniating. Having the guy come back from one is remarkable in itself... I'd never expect anyone to come back from two hence that's why Rivera isn't expect back by anyone.
 
Top