Game 1: Steelers - 13 vs Titans - 10 *Final*

ajk23az

Through Pain Comes Clarity
Messages
7,953
Reaction score
422
rcaldw;2932474 said:
Funny, I thought Young was rookie of the year and led his team to the playoffs? I guess I missed that.

And then got benched. :rolleyes:
 

ejthedj

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,290
Reaction score
619
Kangaroo;2932468 said:
ejthedj;2932456 said:
CJ is way smaller than Felix. And I'm not banking on him getting hurt, I'm just saying it happens. Felix plays a full year and he is at least close if not better.

And this whole argument was about who has a better offense... so, I win.

I wouldn't trade (even for a year)
Collins for Romo
Gage for Roy
Washington for Crayton
Scaife for Witten
Crumpler for Bennett Le
ndal for BBarbr Ringe
er for Choice

Maybe B Britt for Miles or Hurd, Maybe CJ for Felix, but that's about i R
]


You realize CJ made it a full season last year and Felix did not

Really? I stop watching after week 6. It just gets too boring.

Come on guys, they are both great, but the arg is who's offense is better. It's no question, just as a healthy Felix is close to as good as CJ. Time will tell but CJ hasn't looked that great this week and he's only one year in. Felix never got hurt in college. Let's just see. I feel confident.

And there is no doubt we have a better O.
 

Bluestang

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,161
Reaction score
1,583
Well it also does help that JF didn't want VY at all and the owner drafted him anyways so I think VY never really got a fair shake when he was on the Titans. He should leave after his contract is up and develop someplace where they want him to succeed.
 

rcaldw

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,067
Reaction score
1,181
ajk23az;2932469 said:
Your saying VY is a better QB than Collins, yet you say he doesn't make the throws Collins makes as consistently...hmmm...odd.

Your a Longhorn fan aren't you?

I didn't say he wasn't as consistent, I said if YOU wanted to make THAT argument, at least it could be argued. To say Young can't make those throws is just foolish.

No, I'm not a big Longhorn fan, but I'll bet you're a Longhorn hater :)
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
Vince Young did - Titans started 0-4 and then he turned them around to 8-8 after starting 1-5 I think, and barely missed the playoffs.
 

dadymat

I'm kind of a Big Deal
Messages
6,023
Reaction score
1
Bob Sacamano;2932479 said:
what makes Sharon Osbourne qualified to judge if anyone has talent?

she is actually the mastermind behind Ozzys career....
 

rcaldw

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,067
Reaction score
1,181
ajk23az;2932478 said:
And then got benched. :rolleyes:

When he got hurt in GAME 1. And then Collins played the exact same style and has people like you acting like they have never seen such great QB play in their life. :) All the while they have 10 whole points with 7:25 to go in the 4th Quarter.
 

Hoofbite

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,884
Reaction score
11,596
casmith07;2932418 said:
Unless you're Tony Romo taking that shot in a preseason game, while getting blown up on a great blitz by the linebacker against San Francisco. In that case it's a horrible bonehead play.

I *heart* some of our fans.

Uh, those two throws are not the same.
 

ajk23az

Through Pain Comes Clarity
Messages
7,953
Reaction score
422
rcaldw;2932484 said:
I didn't say he wasn't as consistent, I said if YOU wanted to make THAT argument, at least it could be argued. To say Young can't make those throws is just foolish.

No, I'm not a big Longhorn fan, but I'll bet you're a Longhorn hater :)

Not a "big" longhorn fan? So that means you are a fan though? I'm from North Dakota, I have no animosity towards UT at all. I'm an Arizona State fan, Pac 10 baby. :p:

Collins makes the tough throws a lot more consistently than VY, which is why VY is warming the bench and Collins is out leading his team on the field.
 
Top