Garret, Hutchinson, Carter, Henson, Leaf, Wright and now Romo.

[Darkhound]

Hello everyone, this is my first post, and well, wanted to see what you guys think about this topic.

We all agree, and it is obvious, that life after Aikman has been anything but certain. I still recall those glorious days of the triplets, but then again, that was another era, and there is no use in living in the past.

There will always be people in favor and people against certain players. But hey, isn’t this the beauty of it? We all gather here, for one common interest... The Dallas Cowboys! Whether you hated them or love them, it is team that never goes unnoticed. Period! That being said, onto the main subject.

Being a fan of the Cowboys since I have a memory, (almost 29 years) I cannot deny that I fear we are in another "era" of hard times. And by era, call it perhaps a decade of decadence! Aside from that solitary playoff appearance a few years ago, the team still needs to define its star qb.

Remember that Thanksgiving game, when Jason Garret replaced Aikman and made one impressive performance? The media talked, and the chit chat began. Not that there were ever serious doubts that Garret should have replaced Aikman, but there was hype. What ever happened to Garret, I personally don’t know but the fact is that he is not a starting QB to date. Chad Hutchinson… same story, the controversy between him and Quincy Carter was there and what is of them today? Both are not even on the spotlight anymore. I have no clue to be honest, if they are even currently backups this season. I still remember, some folks on the media refer to Hutchinson as the QB of the future for the Cowboys? It amazes me how words are blown away by the wind. Back in those days, I wanted to believe in Carter, I wanted to believe in Hutchison, nothing happened. Anthony Wright anyone? Iirc, he had some moments in Baltimore, but after that? Ryan Leaf? Shall I even go into that subject? That was more a desperate move at the time that anything else. Testaverde? Same story, a temporary QB to mentor the future guy. And we come to Bledsoe. Well, all that I was expecting for Bledsoe was to “drive the wagon” while we found our new franchise QB. The Romo time is here, call it era, call it a season.

What makes us believe that this will be any different? Carter had its moments, Carter was improving. Hutchison had its moments, and so did Romo on SNF. It was ridiculous, if you guys saw the game, I SWEAR I heard I think AL or Madden compare Romo to early Montana!!! I was like what!!!! ???? Give this guy a break.

I seriously want our time to began again. I want to see our team blast, and pulverize opponents like we did in those days. I know our time will come, and I am proud to be a Cowboy. I feel now more proud than EVER, because back in the 90’s a lot of opportunist suddenly became Cowboys fans, it was here and there, it is something that I don’t chew on. You follow a team through think and thin. It makes me laugh to see how there are much more Patriot fans, Colts fans and Seahawk fans than what there used to be. Well after all who cheers a loose, and those teams were losers for decades! It has been tough for us Cowboys. But do you think, Romo will be (with all proportion guarded) the next Tom Brady?

 

[Dallas31]

Garrett was never really considered by us or any other team as a possible NFL starter.

He was a career backup at best. No one ever thought he'd ever be Dallas' qb.

 

[theogt]

Romo >> God >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Brady >>>>>>>>> Garrett

 

[5Stars]

Romo >> God

 

[theogt]

:tongue:

 

[Darkhound]

I know Garrent was never in question, but my point it, that why didnt he shine on other teams? He did gave a couple of DECENT performances. And yet he never got to build up his carrer. If we compare, and make an exagerration, Favre was a backup and so was Steve Young at some point.

IIRC, Young was in Tampa was a starter right? Then came to backup Montana for several Years. And Favre (correct me if i am wrong) was a backup in Atlanta?

Point is, Dallas has NEVER had anything solid since Aikman. I hope Romo is not just an fantasy from we will awake in a few games!

 

[dboyz]

I think we are in danger of getting too hyped about Romo, but I think you're going in the other direction.

I think one thing is clear is that Romo is physically superior to players like Jason Garrett, Stoerner, etc.

He also passes the eye test. He has a quick release. He moves well, is good at moving and throwing and seems to have an instinctive feel for the game. That is evident in watching him. He played well in the preseason, and in training camp, so it isn't like this was a complete fluke out of nowhere.

The Quincy Carter comparison may have the most merit. The MNF game against the Giants Parcells first year I think a lot of us including me thought that Quincy could be the answer. Having said that it was really drugs that derailed Quincy... AND

Romo even if the comparison is somewhat apt, is definitely a more polished version of Quincy. His accuracy is definitely superior, and he makes quicker decisions.

 

[DallasDomination]

I never thought anything about any of those guys. They were Chumps at best.

Henson was a joke since day one..Hutchinson played horrible and never showed much potential.

Romo HAs been here basically 4 years and BIll PArcells LIkes him....

We're not talking about chumps like Campo and others that dont know a thing about Football.


Not to mention Sean PAyton was all over him aswell.

 

[Doomsday101]

It is still a bit too early to claim Romo to be the next anything. His 1st start was very good and if he can show consistency in his play then Dallas very well may have found the QB to lead us for seasons to come. I don't concern myself of Romo being the next Brady or who ever, I just want him to be Tony Romo and play football the way he knows how.

 

[baj1dallas]

I wonder if Parcells learned anything about the pressure of the Dallas QB under the QC years and if that has to do with how they brought Romo around so slowly.

 

[Doomsday101]

I wonder if Parcells learned anything about the pressure of the Dallas QB under the QC years and if that has to do with how they brought Romo around so slowly.

I think that is true I also feel that coaches go by what they see and know fans want to see what they don't know. Romo is playing because Parcells feels he is ready. That is good enough for me.

 

[Darkhound]

By Tom Brady, I mean a QB that (im sure many of you fall in here) many people didnt knew, or knew what to expect. Brady is the result of a Bledsoe injury and well the rest is history. The guy has talent, and he want even drafted in the 1st round! Yet, in my opinion, Brady is one of the best QB that currently plays.

I want to ask you guys something. Why did the Cowboys organization was so patient with guys like Carter, Henson and Hutchinson? Sending them to NFL europe etc etc? How much are we willing to stand for Romo to mature? 1 whole season as a starter? Just this season? I know it all depends on performance, but even the best have had its worst moments.

I remember an intervire with Mike Holgrem (spelling) where he confesses that at some point, in the early seasons of Favre he was VERY close to benching him. Yet he never did, and well see the results. We are all currently happy with Romo's performance from last night, but what will we say if he plays poorly next week?

 

[jksmith269]

BTW Jason is now a QB coach with the Dolphins or was last I checked....

 

[TtownCowboy]

I think we are in danger of getting too hyped about Romo, but I think you're going in the other direction.

I think one thing is clear is that Romo is physically superior to players like Jason Garrett, Stoerner, etc.

He also passes the eye test. He has a quick release. He moves well, is good at moving and throwing and seems to have an instinctive feel for the game. That is evident in watching him. He played well in the preseason, and in training camp, so it isn't like this was a complete fluke out of nowhere.

The Quincy Carter comparison may have the most merit. The MNF game against the Giants Parcells first year I think a lot of us including me thought that Quincy could be the answer. Having said that it was really drugs that derailed Quincy... AND

Romo even if the comparison is somewhat apt, is definitely a more polished version of Quincy. His accuracy is definitely superior, and he makes quicker decisions.

I think this may be the case even more than I would like to believe. I'm sure I'll get stoned for this, but I honestly believe Parcells felt like Quincy was his answer. I think he actually believed Quincy would be a solid starter in this league. I think you're right in that the drug issue killed his career not so much his game. Now having said that I was not a Carter fan. I don't believe and this is just my uneducated opinion Romo is in the Troy Aikman mold we grew acustom to around here. He is more of a Pennington/Delhhome type QB. But here's to hoping he's the next Brady

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

I think we are in danger of getting too hyped about Romo

Its Dangerous?

 

[Darkhound]

BTW, thanks everyone for their responses. The main objective of this post is to see what we think its promising and what is not.

Dont tell me you guys, 9some of you might, some of you might not) never felt some hope when we saw that Quincy had mobility? He did! And he showed improvements, then all that thing about drugs and we all know what happened. Jerry Jones wanted that guy, and I guess he is the only reason that Carter stayed, but still, I had my moments of doubt.

My questions for you guys are the following?

1. Shall Tomo Romo remain the starting QB for the remaining of the season, despiste he might have good and some bad games?

2. Shall the Cowboys just wait for the season to be over and draft a promising star and build a team around him?

3. Shall the Cowboys open up the wallet and try to bring somone who is young and proven to work, like lets say... Drew Breeze, Palmer etc?

 

[Deep_Freeze]

Sidenote: Someone please teach Romo how to slide..... ray2:

Those head first dives puts the gray matter at risk.

 

[kartr]

I think this may be the case even more than I would like to believe. I'm sure I'll get stoned for this, but I honestly believe Parcells felt like Quincy was his answer. I think he actually believed Quincy would be a solid starter in this league. I think you're right in that the drug issue killed his career not so much his game. Now having said that I was not a Carter fan. I don't believe and this is just my uneducated opinion Romo is in the Troy Aikman mold we grew acustom to around here. He is more of a Pennington/Delhhome type QB. But here's to hoping he's the next Brady

You're absolutely right, Parcells did believe that Carter was the answer. Jerry just pretended to be behind Carter. Jerry could have nixed the idea of bringing in Henson. He was the one who brought in Hutch. He was the one who kept trying to bring in a Aikman-like franschise qb instead of just giving
Carter his 2-3 years the way that Holmgren gave Hassellbeck. I like Romo, but he is not in the same league as guys like Carter and Brees. There's a reason he went to Eastern Illinois and they went to Georgia and Purdue.

 

[MissionCoach]

I never thought anything about any of those guys. They were Chumps at best.

Henson was a joke since day one..Hutchinson played horrible and never showed much potential.

Romo HAs been here basically 4 years and BIll PArcells LIkes him....

We're not talking about chumps like Campo and others that dont know a thing about Football.


Not to mention Sean PAyton was all over him aswell.

I concur...Romo has been watching and studying for the past 4 years...unlike QC, Hutch, and Henson to a lesser degree, that were basically thrown to the wolves.

Although it was only Romo's first start...he passed with flying colors. He made some veteren throws...spread the ball around, limited his mistakes, and even used his legs to buy some time and get out of trouble. The quick release was an unexpected and very pleasant surprise!

To use one of BP's favorite lines...let's not put him in Canton just yet...but as a long time Cowboy fan, Romo's debut was definitely something to get excited about!!! :starspin :starspin :starspin

 

[5Stars]

I like Romo, but he is not in the same league as guys like Carter and Brees.

What "league" is Carter in?

Strike that question...he's not...!