Giants fans ripping Roy's tackle on Watson

J-DOG

Active Member
Messages
2,135
Reaction score
0
I think the horse collar rule is hilarious.
How many years did they manage to play football without that rule?
Football is a rough game. Players get hurt.
That tackle on Watson was very LEGAL!
We have a couple of players like Roy and TO who are getting called for penalties off of thier reputation as much as anything else. TO getting called for spiking the ball when I see Welker doing the same thing in Sunday's game and no call.
Also what constitutes a push out against DB's. I have seen 3 instinces int the last two weeks that have not been called correctly. In one of them...in the Buffalo game there were 2 refs(1 behind the play on the sideline and another in front close to the sideline) that called TO out of bounds when he clearly gets one foot down before being pushed out by the db. How can they both screw up that call?
They are terrible.
I saw a thread in this forum Saturday night that showed Mike Carey's crew was calling this game. I thought it was funny how most people who were pleased and thought he would be good...his crew is one of the worst. There is always some sort of controversy with his crew in one way or another and he usually gets more airtime then the announcers.
 

jimmy40

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,866
Reaction score
1,888
J-DOG;1712564 said:
I think the horse collar rule is hilarious.
How many years did they manage to play football without that rule?
Football is a rough game. Players get hurt.
That tackle on Watson was very LEGAL!
We have a couple of players like Roy and TO who are getting called for penalties off of thier reputation as much as anything else. TO getting called for spiking the ball when I see Welker doing the same thing in Sunday's game and no call.
Also what constitutes a push out against DB's. I have seen 3 instinces int the last two weeks that have not been called correctly. In one of them...in the Buffalo game there were 2 refs(1 behind the play on the sideline and another in front close to the sideline) that called TO out of bounds when he clearly gets one foot down before being pushed out by the db. How can they both screw up that call?
They are terrible.
I saw a thread in this forum Saturday night that showed Mike Carey's crew was calling this game. I thought it was funny how most people who were pleased and thought he would be good...his crew is one of the worst. There is always some sort of controversy with his crew in one way or another and he usually gets more airtime then the announcers.

How many years did they manage to play football without the force out rule?
 

J-DOG

Active Member
Messages
2,135
Reaction score
0
jimmy40;1712575 said:
How many years did they manage to play football without the force out rule?
If it's a rule they should call it then.
Also this league is turning into touch football with the league taking out the aggressive play.
If you are happy with 45 to 42 outcomes then I could see why you would love these type of rule changes.
I just happen to think that defense is a part of football.:p:
 
Messages
754
Reaction score
7
Too bad Roy doesn't hurt himself.

Addition by subtraction.

He has just devolved into a total liability in pass defense.
 

CrazyCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,287
Reaction score
440
Roy is a Cowboy and we must pull for him to start playing like we all believe he can.
 

CNY Cowboy

Benched
Messages
386
Reaction score
0
ManicDepressiveMan;1712623 said:
Too bad Roy doesn't hurt himself.

Addition by subtraction.

He has just devolved into a total liability in pass defense.

Stop it!!!! You can't be serious.:mad:
 

smarta5150

Mr. Wright
Messages
7,163
Reaction score
0
If they wanna complain about that tackle then they should talk about Pierce and his sack that happened moments ago.

Clearly the same situation.
 

zrinkill

Cowboy Fan
Messages
49,040
Reaction score
32,541
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
ManicDepressiveMan;1712623 said:
Too bad Roy doesn't hurt himself.

Addition by subtraction.

He has just devolved into a total liability in pass defense.

idiotic statement ..... as usual for you.
 

dozin_theknick

New Member
Messages
593
Reaction score
0
smarta5150;1712716 said:
If they wanna complain about that tackle then they should talk about Pierce and his sack that happened moments ago.

Clearly the same situation.

you beat me to it
 

jimmy40

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,866
Reaction score
1,888
J-DOG;1712607 said:
If it's a rule they should call it then.
Also this league is turning into touch football with the league taking out the aggressive play.
If you are happy with 45 to 42 outcomes then I could see why you would love these type of rule changes.
I just happen to think that defense is a part of football.:p:
So they should call the horse collar? It is a rule.

So you think the receiver should get credit for a catch when the defense forces them out?

Doesn't sound like you like defense too much to me.:p:
 

smarta5150

Mr. Wright
Messages
7,163
Reaction score
0
smarta5150;1712716 said:
If they wanna complain about that tackle then they should talk about Pierce and his sack that happened moments ago.

Clearly the same situation.

cowboyz;1712717 said:
pierce just did the same tackle to sack harrington

dozin@theknick;1712725 said:
you beat me to it

and cowboyz

;)

Seriously though... that tackle is gonna happen, just like a horse collar.

This is a physical game that inflicts pain and injuries. Deal with it.
 
Top