Giants should have drafted Lock?

[AmericanCowboy]

the real question is how does jones compare as a prospect to rosen? i think i'd have rather gone allen, lawrence and then traded for rosen if i were the giants.

the crazy thing is that they got rid of snacks harrison, and then essentially traded OBJ to draft a younger snacks harrison with upside. gettlemen is screwing that franchise and i love it.



actually they traded their 2nd round pick. they don't pick again until late round 3.

They also traded a CB with discipline issues and an inflated ego to the Saints and then drafted a corner with an inflated sense of ego and discipline issues.

 

[Proof]

Remember when the Seahawks got a "F" grade for drafting Bruce Irvin, Bobby Wagner, and Russell Wilson with their first 3 picks in 2012? All they did was go to two straight Super Bowls, and Wilson and Wagner are routine Pro Bowl picks.

Remember when the Cowboys were universally panned for trading down and picking Travis Frederick with the 31st pick in 2013?

Remember when nearly everyone was bagging on the Browns a year ago for picking Baker Mayfield over Sam Darnold? Darnold's team picked 3rd this year, while Cleveland went on a winning streak under Mayfield.

Let's hold off on dunking on the Giants for a couple of years to see how things turn out.

No. Only remember the cowboys ish. Seahawks with an F? Nah


Edit- Just looked it up. That’s hilarious.

 

[ChronicCowboy]

I like the Giants draft. Skins did better but Giants draft is underrated.

 

[dckid]

Big mistake

I agree & I love that the Giants keep screwing themselves up.
Last year they draft an RB, when they should have drafted a QB. This year they get Jones.. this guy was the 100th rated prospect on some draft guides. They trade the most explosive WR in the league, for a box safety and Cleveland's first round pick who they turned into a DT who is a run stuffer.
Gettelman is an amazing GM

 

[reddyuta]

a QB with 54 % completion rate is not a 1st Rder,you cannot coach accuracy as we have found out with Dak.

 

[Hennessy_King]

a QB with 54 % completion rate is not a 1st Rder,you cannot coach accuracy as we have found out with Dak.

Did you see Dak's stats as a senior?

 

[Rayman70]

answer to the OP.....yes. Why is it even a question? lmao...this kid Lock is light years ahead of Jones and his ceiling his higher. The tape don't lie.

 

[reddyuta]

Did you see Dak's stats as a senior?

I would take Dak over Haskins and Daniel jones,i am not a fan of both those guys at all.to me Murray was the only 1st RD QB in this draft.

 

[Rayman70]

Did you see Dak's stats as a senior?

Dak gets beat up about accuracy...but fans don't seem to remember he was widely known for his accuracy in his rookie year and as you mentioned, in college he was no slouch. He carried those gawd awful teams on his back as a 5th year senior and leader.

 

[Rayman70]

Dak was actually the most accurate passer other than Aaron Rodgers in 2016. FACT. So lets just get the facts straight boys.

 

[Hennessy_King]

I would take Dak over Haskins and Daniel jones,i am not a fan of both those guys at all.to me Murray was the only 1st RD QB in this draft.

Haskins is a baller. I think his attitude is a little meh. But he's not a runner and looks to throw first. And he's dropping dimes. 70% comp. 4,800 yards 50tds and only 8 ints. IDC if my daughter has those stats i'm drafting her lol. How many top playmakers are coming out in the draft from ohio state that made him look better?

 

[Rayman70]

Haskins is a baller. I think his attitude is a little meh. But he's not a runner and looks to throw first. And he's dropping dimes. 70% comp. 4,800 yards 50tds and only 8 ints. IDC if my daughter has those stats i'm drafting her lol. How many top playmakers are coming out in the draft from ohio state that made him look better?

Unfortunately for Haskins, the team is owned by Dan Snyder, thus he will have little chance to shine.

 

[blueblood70]

Big mistake

or Jones at 17 , just taking any of them besides Murray before 10 was a mistake.. Washington was smart let Haskins drop to them..they all thought Miami was going QB and Panicked

 

[reddyuta]

Dak was actually the most accurate passer other than Aaron Rodgers in 2016. FACT. So lets just get the facts straight boys.

yeah but most of his passes we short in college like they are here.

 

[Rayman70]

yeah but most of his passes we short in college like they are here.

so what. Eli Mannings passes are mostly short too and he cant hit the broad side of a barn...yet he gets a free pass. What a joke. Lets just give Dak some credit for being better than good...as hard as that may be for some. All he does is win since hes been in the league.

 

[Hennessy_King]

yeah but most of his passes we short in college like they are here.

brady made history on dinking and dunking. They created the short passing game to replace a non existent run game.

 

[darthseinfeld]

Haskins is a baller. I think his attitude is a little meh. But he's not a runner and looks to throw first. And he's dropping dimes. 70% comp. 4,800 yards 50tds and only 8 ints. IDC if my daughter has those stats i'm drafting her lol. How many top playmakers are coming out in the draft from ohio state that made him look better?

He is garbage now though

 

[reddyuta]

so what. Eli Mannings passes are mostly short too and he cant hit the broad side of a barn...yet he gets a free pass. What a joke. Lets just give Dak some credit for being better than good...as hard as that may be for some. All he does is win since hes been in the league.

I want us to resign Dak but i feel he has limitations which he will not overcome.we just have to build a great team around him.

 

[CowboyChris]

Giants are a clown show, they will soon be the Jets of the NFCE

 

[Jake]

Giants have drafted the Senior Bowl MVP (each a QB) the last 3 seasons.