Gimme's Game 1 observations

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
48,135
Reaction score
46,129
OFFENSE

1) Stephen McGee looked like a bona fide NFL quarterback. He made good decisions, was accurate — even on rollouts, showed you have to respect his running ability, and stood strong in the pocket when he needed to, completing passes under pressure.

2) Lonyae Miller has nice size, but negates his power by running too high. In contrast, Phillip Tanner showed nice power, showed a better burst getting to the hole and had some nice moves. It's easy to blame the blocking for Miller's performance, and that had something to do with it, but if Miller has to be able to run through/bounce off some of those tacklers or find an opening when the initial hole is closed.

3) Chris Gronkowski was very accurate with his blocking assignments, but his ability to do anything with his blocks is hit and miss. At times, he gets movement and at other times he's stuffed in the hole. The fullbacks' blocking was one of the primary culprits in the failed runs.

4) Dwayne Harris reminds me of Patrick Crayton. He isn't very fast, but just has that feel for finding an open spot and runs crisp routes. Some players just know how to play the game and he appears to be one of those who gets it.

5) Raymond Radway is one of those who doesn't get it. He rounds off routes and doesn't always run them right ... but his raw speed gets him open and it doesn't look like his hands are a liability. This could be another UDFA find, but it's probably going to take him a while to get there.

6) I went back after the game and rewatched it just focusing on the offensive linemen, particularly Tyron Smith, David Arkin and Sam Young. I also watched the centers (not quite as closely) and felt like both Phil Costa and Bill Nagy were solid. They didn't have to do a lot of solo blocks in pass protection, but when they did, they held their ground, and their run blocking was solid.

Smith is really good at sustaining blocks, but he was beaten a couple of times on the first team's only block. A quick inside move by a DE left him basically grasping at air, but Tony Romo got off a quick pass to Gronkowski. Then later in the drive, he got beat around the corner, and even though the DE fell down, it forced Romo to step up and hurry an incompletion.

Arkin was very solid in pass protection, getting bulled back into Jon Kitna once, but his run blocking, especially with the second-team line, showed his lack of power. Several times he got no movement or was knocked back on runs to his side.

Young doesn't appear able to sustain blocks. His technique is solid, although he was beaten around the outside once, but he just can't stay with quicker DEs if they have time to adjust their moves. He allowed a DE to shake him to force McGee to scramble and he allowed a sack when a DE used an up-and-under move. I actually thought Jeremy Parnell, who surprised me, did a better job at left tackle than Young did at RT, but I wasn't watching Parnell as closely.

DEFENSE

1) Dallas' run defense was gashed on the opening drive primarily because Igor Olshansky was getting blown off the ball. It appeared to me that Olshansky took several snaps lined up in the nose tackle position, and that's when Denver would take advantage to push him back into the linebackers.

2) Jason Hatcher was active and in on several plays, and probably played the best among the ends. Marcus Spears also got into the backfield a couple of times with opportunities to make stops, but he and Sean Lee blew a good one, letting Willis McGahee escape.

3) Sean Lissemore played the best at nose tackle. He had a couple of nice run stops at the line of scrimmage.

4) Lee's game would have looked better if he had stopped McGahee when Lee shot into the hole. I thought Lee was solid, but wanted more.

5) The inside linebacker who stood out the most to me was Kenwin Cummings. He was in on several good stops and also had a big special teams tackle.

6) Victor Butler was all over the place. He pressured the quarterback, chased down running backs, held his own on running plays coming his way, etc. When he was in the game, it appeared like he was in on every tackle.

7) Josh Thomas looks like he's going to be a solid player. He gave up a catch of the middle, but had good coverage, and he made a nice play in the end zone.

SPECIAL TEAMS

1) If Dan Bailey can kick off like that in the regular season, then Dallas won't have to keep David Buehler for kickoffs ... if Bailey wins the field goal job. Buehler made the only FG attempt by Dallas, but it was typical of Buehler's field goals ... almost pulling too far to the left instead of going down the middle.

2) Dwayne Harris looks like he's got good movement skills on kickoff returns, although he's going to have to watch trying to do too much and losing yards, like he did on the punt returns. Raymond Radway showed off his speed on his return, but he's a lot like Akwasi Owusu-Ansah in that both are going to take it as far as the blocking lets them. I still think Bryan McCann is the best option here because he has speed and moves, but Dallas didn't use him.

COACHING

1) Loved Jason Garrett's playfulness with his players. He was serious when needed to be, but showed his fun side. Also loved his decision to go for two in a preseason game. The fact that Dallas made it is just going to reinforce the Cowboys' confidence in him. It was an educated gamble: plenty to gain, not much to lose.

Also, loved the players' interactions. Romo was talking his receivers' ears off. Dez Bryant was congratulating everyone for good plays and cheering them on. The veteran offensive line were discussing things with the young ones. Communication is so important in a team sport, and there was plenty of it.
 
That's a good read, man. Very fair review.

McGee seems like a sandlot QB. When he's contained in the pocket he struggles. When the Cowboys get him moving or a play breaks down, he starts making plays. To his credit, he does seem to have a knack for making a play at the end of the game. I just question his pocket presence and ability to read defenses. His accuracy too.

I still want to find another QB to develop.

I thought the story of the game was how well our rookies played. Of course they have a long way to go, but all they could do right now is play well in that first game and they did so. I'm very encouraged on where they go from here. And this is without our 2nd and 3rd round picks playing. We should all feel good about this. You're allowed to. It won't hurt you.
 
Risen Star;4048012 said:
That's a good read, man. Very fair review.

McGee seems like a sandlot QB. When he's contained in the pocket he struggles. When the Cowboys get him moving or a play breaks down, he starts making plays. To his credit, he does seem to have a knack for making a play at the end of the game. I just question his pocket presence and ability to read defenses. His accuracy too.

I still want to find another QB to develop.

I thought the story of the game was how well our rookies played. Of course they have a long way to go, but all they could do right now is play well in that first game and they did so. I'm very encouraged on where they go from here. And this is without our 2nd and 3rd round picks playing. We should all feel good about this. You're allowed to. It won't hurt you.

I thought McGee was pretty good in the pocket. He leaves it early sometimes, but he stood in there quite a bit and took hits while completing passes. He didn't feel the safety blitz coming, but other than that, his pocket presence was fine.

I also thought he was very accurate. The interception he threw was caused by the receivers cutting each other off. It also appeared to me that he did a nice job reading the defense and finding the open receiver. There were several instances where his receivers didn't complete the pattern or run the right pattern that might have made him look inaccurate, but he was on target and made several very good throws.

Best game I've seen from him, and he definitely showed progress from last preseason.
 
Nice job gimmie - thank you.
 
McGee didn't look legit to me. He looked like he's still a year or two from being close to being considered legit.

Otherwise, great write up. Agreed pretty much all around.
 
theogt;4048026 said:
McGee didn't look legit to me. He looked like he's still a year or two from being close to being considered legit.

Otherwise, great write up. Agreed pretty much all around.

He looks confused and late on his reads. He seems much more confortable on the run or improvising than he does working out of the pocket.
 
theogt;4048026 said:
McGee didn't look legit to me. He looked like he's still a year or two from being close to being considered legit.

Otherwise, great write up. Agreed pretty much all around.

I thought he started out a little shaky and then settled into a nice groove.

I'm really not sure what more can be expected of him, other than maybe a little more patience in the pocket.
 
gimmesix;4048039 said:
I thought he started out a little shaky and then settled into a nice groove.

I'm really not sure what more can be expected of him, other than maybe a little more patience in the pocket.
Agree that he settled in and looked better. But even then he didn't look totally legit. He's certainly not given much chance to look good with that putrid line.
 
Risen Star;4048034 said:
He looks confused and late on his reads. He seems much more confortable on the run or improvising than he does working out of the pocket.

Maybe I missed something. I'll have to go back and look. But the only time I saw hesitation with McGee was when someone ran a wrong route. It happened with Harris twice and with Radway a couple of times.
 
theogt;4048026 said:
McGee didn't look legit to me. He looked like he's still a year or two from being close to being considered legit.

Otherwise, great write up. Agreed pretty much all around.


McGee is getting there fast, last year Kitna said he was the most improved player on the roster, this year maybe two consecutive.

While not a big McGee fan since seeing him bomb Camp in his rookie year, he looked like a Jr.High QB that season. A dedication to hard work, now he's very close to being a decent back-up Pro QB.
 
I'm not gonna give Garrett credit for going for 2. IMO, any coach who doesn't go for 2 in the last minute of a preseason game when they're down by one deserves to get fined by the league.
 
ChldsPlay;4048073 said:
I'm not gonna give Garrett credit for going for 2. IMO, any coach who doesn't go for 2 in the last minute of a preseason game when they're down by one deserves to get fined by the league.
Yeah, I think pretty much everyone goes for 2 in that situation, if only for the chance to practice.
 
McGee doesnt read defenses very well to me. He has to do a better job of recognizing the blitz is coming and going to his hot reads. He seemed to check things down when he wasnt getting any pressure and should be taking a shot down field and holding it too long when they were bringing the heat instead of looking for his hot read.

I think he might be over thinking things, at the end when he knew he had to make something happen he seemed more relaxed and just went for it. When he trusted his read and made a confident throw he was on the money.

Hopefully another season behind Romo and Kitna will serve him well. He clearly has the physical tools to at least be a good back up. Plus you never know what teams will give up for a QB that shows potential in the preseason.
 
I cant figure McGee out. Or maybe I have. He looks slow and confused in the beginning, but if you need a win and clutch throws at the end, he will get it done and look like a seasoned NFLer in the process.
 
ChldsPlay;4048073 said:
I'm not gonna give Garrett credit for going for 2. IMO, any coach who doesn't go for 2 in the last minute of a preseason game when they're down by one deserves to get fined by the league.

Tell that to Bill Parcells. Some coaches probably would rather play extra to get more time to look at players like Radway. And I have no problem with that, because most of the players who would be involved in OT are not ones you are counting on.
 
Nice review...Agree with ya except for McGee. I just don't see why we continue to invest time here. To me he is like Drew Henson. Good athlete, good arm, pretty darn accurate but he cannot get the ball out on time. Works in college ball....Throw it when the receiver is open, but will never happen in the NFL. I liked Brady Quinn. I would be happy if he was our 3rd trying to move to backup.

Anyway...Good post!
 
BTB's assessment of McGee:

McGee had a rough start to the game, no question about it. A series of incomplete passes and an interception had Cowboys fans collectively shaking their heads and sighing loudly in exasperation. And McGee was quick to acknowledge that:

"I was probably in the first series or two rusty, getting back on the flow."

Yet that exasperation, and the tired old clichés of the indecisive passer, may have led many fans to overlook what a stellar performance McGee had on his final drives behind an O-line with a combined starting NFL experience of exactly one game and a rag-tag bunch of receivers.

McGee's stat line looks good overall: he threw for 208 yards on 14-of-24 passing, three TDs and one interception for a 109.0 passer rating. But the more interesting stuff is in the details. And as McGee said, he did indeed look rusty in the first two series:

McGee came in on the last drive of the second quarter, completed a pass to John Phillips, had a pass tipped at the line of scrimmage and was then intercepted on a pass intended for Jesse Holley. The first drive of the 3rd quarter was equally unspectacular. Two completed passes to Ogletree and four incompletions ended that drive on a punt. For those nine pass plays on his first two drives, McGee accrued an abysmal 3.7 passer rating.
Stephen McGee, first 2 drives vs. Broncos
CMP ATT YDS CMP% YPA TD INT Rating
3 9 29 33.3% 3.2 0 1 3.7

The good news is that it got a lot better after that, as McGee got more comfortable with the game situation.

"Once we got the momentum going, being able to move the ball I felt very comfortable. I love the last-minute situation like that. I feel like that’s a situation I excel in and compete my butt off when we’re behind. I love that. Hopefully we’re not behind in the future, but it’s fun to come back in a two-minute situation. That’s what a quarterback loves. I feel like I’ve made huge leaps already this year and hopefully I’ll be able to build on them."

And for the next four drives, McGee went on a tear, completing 11 of 15 passes for 179 yards, three TDs and a 152.5 passer rating.
Stephen McGee, last 4 drives vs. Broncos
CMP ATT YDS CMP% YPA TD INT Rating
11 15 179 73.3% 11.9 3 0 152.5

Obviously, it's a pre-season game. But numbers like that should have Cowboys fans perking their ears. Of course, the five-yard hook pass that turned into a 76-yard TD reception by Dwayne Harris drives those numbers up, but even without that TD pass, McGee would have a 131.8 passer rating over the last four drives.

As KD said in his write-up immediately after the game, "McGee is clutch, don't question it, just go with it." Perhaps the Cowboys will find a way this preseason to give McGee some playing time behind the first team O-line, and just as importantly, against a first team defense, to understand just what exactly they can expect from McGee down the line.

It may be time to put those old clichés about McGee to rest. After all, Jason Garrett thinks McGee is pretty darn good:

"Stephen did a nice job," Dallas coach Jason Garrett said. "Obviously, at the end of the game, to string some positive plays together, making some good throws, making some good decisions, then allowing us to score that last touchdown...Pretty darn good by him."

This is about what I saw. I think too many of you are looking at those first couple of possessions and getting down on McGee.

I thought he had a good game. Came out tentative (although the INT wasn't his fault) and progressed from there. Yes, he was late on a pass to Ogletree, but he appeared pretty decisive on his other throws (loved the final TD pass under heavy duress and the conversion on a rollout), showed nice touch and accuracy and just made plays.
 
Went back and read my original post, and I apologize for some mistakes I failed to edit. I was trying to complete it in a hurry because I needed to get to work.
 
Actually, getting Harris is finally making me get over our decision to get rid of Crayton. Since he has been gone, that move the chains/ find the soft spot guy has been sorely missing from our offense.
 
dmq;4048255 said:
Actually, getting Harris is finally making me get over our decision to get rid of Crayton. Since he has been gone, that move the chains/ find the soft spot guy has been sorely missing from our offense.

Yeah, I think it's important to have a slot guy who can work the middle of the field well.

We'll see how Ogletree does in that role, but he's more of an outside-in receiver to me.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,684
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top