Give Me 3 but Substantiate Your Claim

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Give Me 3 Positions
That Put Us Over The Top

1)

2)

3)

We are competitive right now but if you looked at our roster including potential sleepers like Gardner ala Crawford circa 2014, what positions make an impact or have that hidden ability to surprise?

We saw O-Line continue to be the reason we kept elevating, something many have wanted since 2009..

We saw a rushing attack being forged not just behind this wall but when there was nothing and things got dirty..

We saw WR's come up big, time after time, and Witten with a sprinkle of the Gavster..

We've seen Romo make plays..

LB's for days...

Still missing that DT and secondary play but have somewhat good enough if all the other pieces come up big or just as good.

Truth is it appears one way but might just unfold another..

Not many expected 13-5, Boys it looks like we "sitting" in High Cotton...
BPA

I'm not certain I understand the question. Hardy is the guy that will put the Cowboy over the top if anybody does.

If this is a draft question, then I don't think there are players that will definitely put the Cowboys over the top in 2015.

Staying healthy would be the biggest factor that could make the difference in having a great season vs mediocre season.

If the question is what is the weakest position at this minute, then it's probably CB. You need 3 top shelf CBs and the Cowboys have 1 top shelf but undersized CB on the roster.

The 1tech DT position was a big problem last season but they have many options there for improvement. An in shape Josh Brent with a full off-season with the team could be a huge improvement. Physically Ken Bishop has a ton of upside but had a lot to learn as a small college rookie. He now has NFL experience including a playoff game. T. McClain played through injury last season but flashed good ability as a pass rushing 1tech.

Backup OT went from having a guy that was better than the starter to a big unknown.

They don't really have a backup Safety unless your a fan of Jeff Heath.
 

CF74

Vet Min Plus
Messages
26,167
Reaction score
14,623
I'm not certain I understand the question. Hardy is the guy that will put the Cowboy over the top if anybody does.

If this is a draft question, then I don't think there are players that will definitely put the Cowboys over the top in 2015.

Staying healthy would be the biggest factor that could make the difference in having a great season vs mediocre season.

If the question is what is the weakest position at this minute, then it's probably CB. You need 3 top shelf CBs and the Cowboys have 1 top shelf but undersized CB on the roster.

The 1tech DT position was a big problem last season but they have many options there for improvement. An in shape Josh Brent with a full off-season with the team could be a huge improvement. Physically Ken Bishop has a ton of upside but had a lot to learn as a small college rookie. He now has NFL experience including a playoff game. T. McClain played through injury last season but flashed good ability as a pass rushing 1tech.

Backup OT went from having a guy that was better than the starter to a big unknown.

They don't really have a backup Safety unless your a fan of Jeff Heath.

Basically my question is asking what 3 positions could we upgrade, improve, or build upon that can really make an impact for 2015 and moving FWD... And who are your sleepers, ie Ben Gardner.. The Kracken is kinda obvious...

Some of your other responses have been stated before so I commend u for holding your position. I just see the team slowly making improvements and wanted to get some Validations from the fans ideas and views..

Many just stated positions without explanations why which is fine, glad to see a general consensus to some degree...
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,835
Reaction score
20,691
Hardy
DLaw
Crawford
Draft a DT

Exactly. I'm not so sure we'll be drafting a DE in this draft, or at least early. If D-Law makes a jump and Hardy proves himself, there is no room on the roster as a starter for an early DE. Next year we can worry about that.

Focus on RB, DT, CB, and RT early.
 

ShiningStar

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,517
Reaction score
7,746
RB- Our offense relies heavily on the running game and we have nothing proven there. While the offensive line is the best in the NFL, a good runningback is needed to make the running game truly dangerous. We need one that not only can run well, but also pass protect well so Romo doesn't get killed. Randle may get more opportunities this year, so he'll have a chance to show if he can be effective in a more expansive role. Ryan Williams looks good running, but his pass protection needs to improve. I haven't watched McFadden in the pros, so I'll refrain from commenting on him. It's possible one of the runningbacks on the roster will break out, or that we will draft someone to take over, but until then it's a huge question mark for me. A lot of people think Murray was solely a product of the oline, and they definitely helped, but he put up good numbers before last season. His biggest issues were injuries.

DE- Greg Hardy was a huge addition, but he's on a one year deal. Like most people I feel that the trenches are extremely important. Hardy is the only proven pass rusher on the team. Crawford showed a lot of promise last year, and I expect him to continue that progress he's shown. Lawrence made some plays in the playoffs, but I'm still iffy on him. Yes, I'm aware he missed a lot of time to injury and that limited valuable practice time that most rookies need, but until/if he shows something I consider that to be a huge question mark. Mincey is a good rotation player and a solid starter. We don't have much of a pass rush from the 1-tech spot, but as long as they can command a double team I consider that passable.

Even assuming Greg Hardy plays like he has in the past and stays out of trouble, and Lawrence plays up to his potential, defensive end would still be a tremendous help. Even moreso than DT IMO. A large percentage of snaps are in the Nickel formation. Hardy can slide inside next to Crawford. Then Lawrence and another DE could rush from the outside. If Lawrence can be what the front office thought they were getting on draft day this could provide a formidable pass rush. This would help out the secondary more than just adding a corner IMO.

FS- A top-flight ball hawk free safety could put this team over the edge. Having a rangy center fielder would open up a lot scheme-wise. I'm of the belief this may very well be the hardest type of player to find in football. Having this type of FS would free up Church or Wilcox to play closer to the line. It would also not only help in run support, but with the SS covering a short to intermediate space, it would make it harder for opposing receivers to get open in a short amount of time. This would make the opposing quarterback hold onto the ball longer giving the pass rush more time to get pressure or the sack. Having a rangy safety back there would also help to mitigate our corners that aren't Scandrick's cover abilities.

I'm of the belief we already have enough talent to win the Super Bowl. We came close last year. I realize close doesn't count as a Super Bowl win, but it bodes well for future chances. But with these three position upgrades, the Cowboys would have an even better chance to get #6. I don't expect us to be able to get all three, but two of these would go a long way to hopefully outdoing last year's success.


Feeling better i didnt have to write this.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Basically my question is asking what 3 positions could we upgrade, improve, or build upon that can really make an impact for 2015 and moving FWD... And who are your sleepers, ie Ben Gardner.. The Kracken is kinda obvious...

Some of your other responses have been stated before so I commend u for holding your position. I just see the team slowly making improvements and wanted to get some Validations from the fans ideas and views..

Many just stated positions without explanations why which is fine, glad to see a general consensus to some degree...
Sleeper: Whaley
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,969
1. S -- Need someone who limits offensive gameplans and makes plays without getting gashed for TDs.
2. CB -- Need a guy that can cover like Mo but win physical battles.
3. WR -- Need someone to consistently take advantage of the coverage Dez/Witten draw.

These things can occur organically with players simply playing much better at those positions: See TWill, Wilcox and Claiborne.
But those 3 positions were soft last year.
And they would provide synergy with what we have now. --The DL is talented and a nice mix of youth and veterans. The running game will be fine with that OL and teams having to double or shade cover Dez.

I didn't put RB because we had the league's leading rusher last year and it didn't put us over the top.
We obviously need more than that.
 

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,705
Reaction score
60,327
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
A nose tackle like Vince Wilfork. Big trash can full of dirt that you can't move.

A ball-hawking safety. Church and Wilcox are both strong safeties.

A cornerback that isn't a bust.
 

Sandyf

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,248
Reaction score
1,379
For Me, it starts with a trade, actually 2 trades on draft day.
1. Trade #27 to Oakland for #35, #68 - to much, not if the OL guy they want falls to #27
2. Second round DE and LB (Owa and Kendricks)
3. Third round CB and FS (Rollins and Randall)
4. Trade next year's 2nd with Ryan Williams to Minnesota for AP - just don't believe AP will be a Viking by end of draft

But to answer the way you have it
LB
DE
CB
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
34,289
Reaction score
19,697
Give Me 3 Positions
That Put Us Over The Top

1)

2)

3)

We are competitive right now but if you looked at our roster including potential sleepers like Gardner ala Crawford circa 2014, what positions make an impact or have that hidden ability to surprise?

We saw O-Line continue to be the reason we kept elevating, something many have wanted since 2009..

We saw a rushing attack being forged not just behind this wall but when there was nothing and things got dirty..

We saw WR's come up big, time after time, and Witten with a sprinkle of the Gavster..

We've seen Romo make plays..

LB's for days...

Still missing that DT and secondary play but have somewhat good enough if all the other pieces come up big or just as good.

Truth is it appears one way but might just unfold another..

Not many expected 13-5, Boys it looks like we "sitting" in High Cotton...
BPA
1) DT - having a DT that can collapse the pocket and demand double teams, will only bolster Crawford, Lawrence and Hardy's ability to rush the passer. A better pass rush equates to more turnovers, less % of 3rd down conversions and more offensive opportunities.

2) CB - going along with DT, another CB that can cover, would provide the same thing. a better defense that would thrive on scaks and turnovers. a better CB, would allow the DL to get to the QB even more. an extra 1/2 second the QB has to hold the ball, leads directly to more sacks.

3) FS - a rangy free safety that can man the middle of the DB field. side to side, allowing church to play closer to the line and help run game.

additing those three will take this defense to a viable top 5 defense. and ready for a championship run
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,310
Reaction score
32,716
1. DE - not being able to tackle a quarterback basically on one leg tells you all you need to know. You put pressure on the quarterback, you're playing in the NFC Championship with a right to go to the Super Bowl.
2. RB - I'm okay with the running back rotation because I believe we'll either trade for AP or pick up Murray's replacement in the draft. Besides, running back-by-committee doesn't bother me. We've got to keep the pressure off Romo. If we get AP or Gurley, no defense is going to be able to hang with us. We'll be like the Cowboys of the 90s. Pick your poison, babyyy!!!
3. WR. Yes, you read me right. I doubt the two top playmakers will be available, but if you get another top receiver to pair with Dez to take double coverage off him, this offense will be as good, if not better, than the Vikings team that went 15-1 with Moss, Carter, Reed and Robert Smith at tailback. Beasley and TWilliams are good, but they don't scare anyone, and TWilliams disappears for stretches.

I would have said CB, but if we get the necessary pass rush, the corners will be okay. And DT is pretty thin at where we'll be picking, and we have Crawford, Brent, Hayden and a few others to "man" the middle.
 

Joe Realist

No Kool-Aid here!
Messages
12,675
Reaction score
5,707
Assuming there are no major injuries..

1.) DE
2.) DT

both of the above help the secondary
3.) RB - move the chains type
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,835
Reaction score
20,691
For Me, it starts with a trade, actually 2 trades on draft day.
1. Trade #27 to Oakland for #35, #68 - to much, not if the OL guy they want falls to #27
2. Second round DE and LB (Owa and Kendricks)
3. Third round CB and FS (Rollins and Randall)
4. Trade next year's 2nd with Ryan Williams to Minnesota for AP - just don't believe AP will be a Viking by end of draft

But to answer the way you have it
LB
DE
CB

Haha, well we have the Madden draft for this thread. I like it!
 

dallasdave

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,326
Reaction score
88,063
1. RB- Gordon or Gurley
2. CB- good pure cover guy
3. KR- a kick returner who is outstanding
 
Top