batman had a good run lately with "the dark knight", but the ones before that were pretty bad. mr freeze? it was like bad tv all over again. even the latest man of steel was pretty bad, to me. however, globally it did pull in around $650 mil. i just couldn't stand seeing the entire city demolished worse than even pacific rim. didn't care for the acting and the rocket launches he did when taking off.
but when you look at Thor, Avengers, Thor 2, Iron Man 1-3, X-Men, Wolverine (you could argue his solo films didn't do as well) Spiderman (any run will do but i am enjoying this last run even if electro was pretty badly done) and so forth.
of course they keep trying to do Hulk movies and they should ban any future attempt to try again. daredevil wasn't too terrible but they never should have made the electra movie. so yea, a few poo-bombs in their cellar. the last spiderman movie from the previous series however contained the worst scene ever put into a movie with peter parker dancing like a giggalo down the sidewalk.
as a comic collector i just grew up on marvel OR indie characters for the most part. firestorm was my favorite DC character and i had to giggle like a little school girl to find out you have to scream SHAZAM to get your powers. outside that, we have:
the dark knight, series won 2 oscars.
man of steel - marginal to me but i'll concede to its success.
then we have:
green lantern. i smelled poo bomb the instant they announced the movie cause the comic book always had goofy looking characters. squids in a bubble trying to look like a hero and so forth.
jonah hex
catwoman
various earlier superman movies (richard pryor stealing money?)
and in general, my overall feeling is the justice league will make some money simply cause comic book movies are pretty popular today but as of today (just read wiki) no script, no director, and it even being done now will depend on the success of batman / superman.
it's all preference, to be sure. marvel for some reason (cough stan lee cough) just had the better base of heros to work with.
I think the feel of the pre-
Batman Begins movies can be contributed to the Christopher Nolan effect. The prior movies followed Tim Burton's interpretation of the character and were entirely cartoony. Nolan brought a serious tone which matched a serious character. I believe that's why most people loved his films over the ones which came before.
I also think Nolan would have had a similar effect on
Man of Steel for audiences. Overall, moviegoers didn't love Zach Snyder's creation, but most people liked it. Perhaps the C grade given by paid movie critics will inspire Snyder to work harder on making the sequel more appealing for moviegoers who found his original to be a bad movie.
(Note: Before someone says my opinion of overall audience reaction to
Man of Steel isn't correct, please check general nonpaid movie critic ratings on
Rotten Tomatoes.com, Metacritic.com or even
iMDB.com . )
I hope Marvel doesn't give up on Hulk, Daredevil or even Electra. In my opinion, the Ed Norton
Hulk could've been better minus the love story subplot. There was only moderate serious effort put into crafting
Daredevil. Even Ben Affleck seemed disinterested at times. Whoever conceived
Electra should be gutted. There was practically zero serious effort to make a functional movie (e.g. script, special effects, etc.). At least Jennifer Garner made an honest effort to make the character believable.
The script and casting of
Green Lantern sucked. All of the real actors, minus Michael Clarke Duncan, Angela Bassett, and the guy who played Sinestro, could have been replaced and still got the same movie or a slightly better one. Ryan Reynolds is perfect casting for Deadpool. For Lantern the old saying of, "Look like Tarzan and act like Jane" totally applies. He cannot do serious roles.
I pretty much agree with everything else. I think
Justice League is being rushed to the big screen. Marvel Studies has a proven formula: a) highlight each main character in their own films or embed them in other main character films, b) get a director who can mesh the different personalities together into one movie, c) BE SERIOUS/no cartoony interpretation and d) have a great script. It worked for
The Avengers. DC does even want to re-establish Wonder Woman first for today's audiences. I just have a bad feeling for the movie's chances.