Great Debate: Does Dallas need a Free or Strong Safety?

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,528
Reaction score
12,551
The idea that every safety needs to support against the run and cover guys is obvious...so do the lb's in today's game. However, there is still a huge difference between a FS and a SS and teams do NOT play them equally or interchangeably which is a stupid idea we've failed at before.

Once or twice a generation you find a true SS (tough, sure tackler with the size for TE's and aggressive) who can also get the job done regularly at FS in the deep patrol (think Lott or Woodson).

All one has to do is look around the league today...you aren't going to see Reid of Baltimore playing SS and his counterpart in the deep patrol except as a blitz changeup for a particular offensive formation.

The FS does not have to be as big and you want him to be very intelligent, a sure tackler, a very good coverage guy against WRs, and hopefully an instinctive ball hawk. The SS is NOT as valueable and should not be paid as much...the SS is a bigger guy who can take on RBs at the line, drive TE's backwards, but is not expected to play the ball that well 40 yards downfield.

Hamlin is a decent but not great FS. Roy Williams is an above average SS that we let get caught running downfield too often and should not have been covering man to man in the red zone.

I think we'll see Hamlin at FS with Watkins as his backup. I believe we'll see Roy starting at SS and replaced in certain passing situations by someone else....we'll try to draft a SS type this year, but he's likely to be a project type....still, you never know when you're going to find a guy like the Skins did in round 4 who comes in and makes huge plays for you.
 

TellerMorrow34

BraveHeartFan
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
5,076
Since Hamlin is here, and will be for a long while, we need a SS. Hamlin, I believe, will suck at SS.
 

dbair1967

Arch Defender
Messages
30,782
Reaction score
1
glorydaysrback;2641447 said:
hey guys, it is evident that there Terrell Owens has created a division on this board on whether or not our hole at the safety position is of the free or strong safety variety. Some people on this board believe Hamlin can hack it at SS and would like for Dallas to acquire a ballhawking centerfielder. Others believe Hamlin is not a SS and IS our free safety and that Dallas should acquire a strong safety this offseason. The purpose of this post is to see what the general consensus is - I happen to think that this defense is missing a ballhawking free safety to take this defense to the next level. What do you think?

Based on what we saw after Hamlin got paid last year, we need both.Hamlin was putrid last year.
 
Top