Dallas is very good. Roster wise, you are top 3 in the NFC. Anyone saying your talent is overblown is wrongly attributing scheme, culture, and execution struggles to the talent on the field.
Dallas’ unique issue is they are wildly inconsistent. If you played SF on Sunday, you may only lose by a little bit this time. Then if you play them the Sunday after that, you may win by a last second FG. Then the Sunday after that, you lose by 40 again.
The team that destroyed the Jets and the team that looked lost for 4 quarters against the Cardinals were not the same team. The team that showed up against New England, the team that was good and bad against LAC, and the team that played SF were 3 completely different identities, 3 completely different performances, 3 completely different teams.
Philly hasn’t been great every game. But we’ve had similar successes and similar faults in each of them. They all look like they’re packaged together. Same with SF, even though they’re in a 2 game losing streak, the identity of each game is similar: Brock looks least like Mr. Irrelevant when nursing a lead, and SF needs to run the ball to be effective. Every game has followed that to a T. But Dallas doesn’t have that defining identity. Sometimes your run D is unconscionable in a good way. Sometimes it’s unconscionable in a bad way. Sometimes Dak is ultra- efficient, destroying complex defenses. Sometimes everyone is wondering how Dak missed both his first and second read running wide open down the field.
It’s perplexing, but Dallas isn’t a bad team. They’re a classic Nintendo where the cartridge only works about 80% of the time. And then sometimes you blow on it repeatedly, and just accept you can’t play that game today for no definable reason.
So no, SF wasn’t any different than Week 1 last year, or week 18 last year, or the Broncos game in 2021. It happens periodically, and everyone wishes they knew why.