THUMPER
Papa
- Messages
- 9,522
- Reaction score
- 61
DWhite Fan;2716519 said:Meredith's record in "big games" was significantly better
With all due respect to Don, I will never understand hy he gets a pass win it comes to having never won when it counted the most, while Danny (and Craig to a lesser extent) gets hammered:starspin
I think Meredith gets some slack because of the games he played in. He faced the Packers twice and had a good game in the first one against one of the best pass defense teams the league has ever known. In the 2nd one (The Ice Bowl) the conditions were horrible for passing so he gets a pass on that one. Plus we would have won that game if not for that last crazy gamble by Starr. If he would have failed on that sneak they would have had no time to kick a tying FG and they would have lost.
In the first playoff game against the Browns, we crushed them 52-14 and Don had the highest passer rating possible, 158.3.
It is really his final game that kills him. In that 1968 playoff game vs the Browns, he was completely wretched going 3 of 9 with 3 INTs and 0 TDs. he left the game with a 9.7 QB rating and retired shortly after they got home. Landry blamed him for the loss and Don never got over it. He was only 31 years old and could have played at least another 4-5 years at a high level, just in time for Staubach to step in.
So even though he was 1-3 in playoff games, he was really only bad in one of them. Morton, on the other hand, was terrible in all 6 playoff games he played in as a Cowboy. Even in the games we won he was pretty bad.
Danny White gets a raw deal IMO as he had his share of big wins and played well in a number of playoff games but because he didn't win it all he is a bum. I don't buy that and always liked him.