How many playoffs game did Dalton win?

[Dak_Attack_09]

I thought hopes and dreams were to be in the post-season and win the SB.

The price ain’t going down Jerry.

 

[Jarv]

Dalton is the only quarterback to lead the Bengals to five consecutive playoff berths, and one of five quarterbacks to lead his team to the playoffs in each of his first five seasons.

 

[EMMITTnROY]

Dak has won 1 more playoff game than Dalton, and with a much much better OL, RB and WRs.

Dak is better than Dalton, no doubt. But I don't think Dak's 1 more playoff win over him is worth an extra $30 million.

 

[Aviano90]

I thought hopes and dreams were to be in the post-season and win the SB.

The price ain’t going down Jerry.

It’s comical watching the excitement over Dalton.

 

[Dak_Attack_09]

It’s comical watching the excitement over Dalton.

I like him as a backup to help implement McCarthy’s offense, but if they think he is gonna come in and out perform Dak they are crazy.

 

[Asklesko]

I like to think the fault was all marvin lewis not andy d

 

[Dak_Attack_09]

I like to think the fault was all marvin lewis not andy d

I could say the same for the Greenbay loss in Dak’s rookie year and would have went to the SB.

 

[xwalker]

Dak has won 1 more playoff game than Dalton, and with a much much better OL, RB and WRs.

Dak is better than Dalton, no doubt. But I don't think Dak's 1 more playoff win over him is worth an extra $30 million.

Playoff Games
Dak: 3 in 4 years (75%)
Dalton: 4 in 9 years (44%)

 

[Aviano90]

I like to think the fault was all marvin lewis not andy d

But the team got worse when Marvin left, much worse.

 

[LittleD]

"Dak can Pack" cause he can take it or leave it now. Andy is a proven QB who can take this loaded offense to the playoffs. Dak, not so much.
Jerry is applying the hammer and Dak is the nail. Now, next year, the Cowboys can apply the non-exclusive tag and get some draft choices for
a 4th round QB who can't hit a peach basket from 10 yrds.

 

[leeblair]

Playoff Games
Dak: 3 in 4 years (75%)
Dalton: 4 in 9 years (44%)

Dak has had the best offensive line in football with the best running back in football, playing in the worst division in the NFL.
YET HE couldn't muster enough talent to win the East at 8-8 against an Eagles team that was basically on injured reserve.
Don't tell me he's great.
He isn't.

 

[xwalker]

Dak has had the best offensive line in football with the best running back in football, playing in the worst division in the NFL.
YET HE couldn't muster enough talent to win the East at 8-8 against an Eagles team that was basically on injured reserve.
Don't tell me he's great.
He isn't.

In 2019 Dak was 2 yards away from breaking the Cowboys all-time record for passing yards in season.

 

[sean10mm]

Dalton went to the playoffs with teams full of Pro Bowlers. The idea that his bus driving took a corpse to the playoffs like young John Elway is comical. The 2015 Bengals had the #2 scoring defense in the NFL and he went nowhere with it.

AJ Green was better than any receiver the Cowboys have had since 2012-2014 Dez Bryant. Jermaine Gresham and Tyler Eifert were Pro Bowl TEs. He had multiple 1,000+ yard rushers behind him. The 2015 team had 5 Pro Bowlers on defense.

Marvin Lewis wasn't a great coach but it's hard to seriously argue he was worse than the clapper. He at least could put togeather multiple good defenses. Hell, he was DC of the 2000 Ravens and had 6 top 10 scoring defenses on the Bengals.

 

[Asklesko]

I could say the same for the Greenbay loss in Dak’s rookie year and would have went to the SB.

Nah, dak is a different story. He clearly just sucks.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Dak is better than Dalton, no doubt. But I don't think Dak's 1 more playoff win over him is worth an extra $30 million.

That's a terrible way of trying to establish Dak's value to the Cowboys. Wins and losses are a team stat.

 

[visionary]

Dalton went to the playoffs with teams full of Pro Bowlers. The idea that his bus driving took a corpse to the playoffs like young John Elway is comical. The 2015 Bengals had the #2 scoring defense in the NFL and he went nowhere with it.

AJ Green was better than any receiver the Cowboys have had since 2012-2014 Dez Bryant. Jermaine Gresham and Tyler Eifert were Pro Bowl TEs. He had multiple 1,000+ yard rushers behind him. The 2015 team had 5 Pro Bowlers on defense.

Marvin Lewis wasn't a great coach but it's hard to seriously argue he was worse than the clapper. He at least could put togeather multiple good defenses. Hell, he was DC of the 2000 Ravens and had 6 top 10 scoring defenses on the Bengals.

He has been to the playoffs in a division with Pitt and Baltimore. Dak can’t beat an 8-8 Eagles team with WRs literally off the street to get yo the playoffs

I like Dak but he’s not worth 35 mill/year

I’m ok if we have to start the season with Dalton

 

[Dak_Attack_09]

He has been to the playoffs in a division with Pitt and Baltimore. Dak can’t beat an 8-8 Eagles team with WRs literally off the street to get yo the playoffs

I like Dak but he’s not worth 35 mill/year

I’m ok if we have to start the season with Dalton

What are you talking about, Dak beat the Eagles.


The same Eagle team that Won a SB recently vs Pittsburgh and Ravens who are chokers and overrated always losing to the Patriots to the playoffs.

 

[EMMITTnROY]

That's a terrible way of trying to establish Dak's value to the Cowboys. Wins and losses are a team stat.

But that's what this entire thread subject is about. So if the OP is saying Dalton isn't good cause he hasn't won a playoff game...

 

[GenoT]

I thought hopes and dreams were to be in the post-season and win the SB.

The price ain’t going down Jerry.

Dalton played for a perennial bottom-feeder in Cincy

How many playoff games do you think Dak woulda “won” (as if it’s all on the QB ) if he’d have spent his career with the recent Bengals?

Meanwhile...Dalton was brought here as a veteran backup — nothing more.

 

[Dak_Attack_09]

Dalton played for a perennial bottom-feeder in Cincy

How many playoff games do you think Dak woulda “won” (as if it’s all on the QB ) if he’d have spent his career with the recent Bengals?

Meanwhile...Dalton was brought here as a veteran backup — nothing more.

Dak accomplished everything Romo has done in a shorter time span, he would have won minimum 2 playoff games with Cincy.