Witten for sure
Romo I say maybe. Really not sure what Romo has done for this franchise but get PAIDDDDDDD. Yes he put up great stats but no big playoff victories. To me Romo is Danny White 2.0
Like others has mentioned, I value wins over stats and as the starting QB of America team with the resources we have, Romo should have a ring or a bunch of playoff wins.
I won't argue on Romo's behave here, as I'd like to see him with a ring too.
But when did Dallas ever have a team that SHOULD have won the Super Bowl?
That 2007 year is the closest, imo.
That was his 1st full year as a starter, the Pats went 17-0 in the regular season and were overwhelming SB favorites,
Dallas DID win the division, go 13-3, and get a 1st round bye. But they lost in an upset to the eventual SB champs.
But really, that's it. Maybe (and I mean maybe) 2007