Is Dak Prescott Elite? Dak vs Elite Quarterbacks!

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

No, you haters are. Y'all are the not only negative but nasty and disrespectful ones around here. This is a Fan Zone. Y'all attack anyone who tries to say anything positive about their team's franchise QB. That is not only toxic but mental.

If dak wasn't a Cowboy....and our starting QB was, say, Colt McCoy or Johnny Manziel....or someone universally considered as "bad"... would cowboy fans in here be "haters" if they were openly not supportive of him as the starting QB, and vocally insisted that he may be a good human being, but he isn't a skilled enough QB to lead this team to anything more than the occasional wild card game or three?
Or would that be "hating"?

Are we just supposed to be positive about each and every player, even if we think he's holding us back?

Or is it just the manner of disapproval you take issue with. Like...would you be OK if people just didn't comment on Pro-Dak threads, but rather created their own threads about their displeasure with Dak, so that the Pro-Dakkers could have their own "space" free of dak-negativity? Or would the pro-Dak guys still come on those threads and yell at everyone for voicing their non-support of dak (as a starting QB for dallas...not as a person)?

Serious question

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Did you watch the video?

doesn't matter. somebody will make a video showing the exact opposite.

I am not a Bash Dak over Dallas Cult, but I don't think he is elite. there are only a couple of Elite QBs right now. some on the edge of being elite. so not considering him to be elite is not a knock. its a reality. he is good. sometimes great. he just has to find a way to get over the hump. that's all.

 

[America's Cowboy]

If dak wasn't a Cowboy....and our starting QB was, say, Colt McCoy or Johnny Manziel....or someone universally considered as "bad"... would cowboy fans in here be "haters" if they were openly not supportive of him as the starting QB, and vocally insisted that he may be a good human being, but he isn't a skilled enough QB to lead this team to anything more than the occasional wild card game or three?
Or would that be "hating"?

Are we just supposed to be positive about each and every player, even if we think he's holding us back?

Or is it just the manner of disapproval you take issue with. Like...would you be OK if people just didn't comment on Pro-Dak threads, but rather created their own threads about their displeasure with Dak, so that the Pro-Dakkers could have their own "space" free of dak-negativity? Or would the pro-Dak guys still come on those threads and yell at everyone for voicing their non-support of dak (as a starting QB for dallas...not as a person)?

Serious question

I'm on other sites where the majority of Cowboys fans still believe in Dak and this team. It's you guys in here who have constantly bashed him year after year while making some of the most ridiculous and misinformed statements. Nothing wrong if you don't like the player, but y'all don't stop. This has been going on for years now.

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

I'm on other sites where the majority of Cowboys fans still believe in Dak and this team. It's you guys in here who has constantly bashed him year after year while making some of the most ridiculous and misinformed statements. Nothing wrong if you don't like the player, but y'all don't stop. This has been going on for years now.

But my question was....if the people in here who DON'T want Dak as the starting QB left the Pro-Dak threads alone, and didnt comment on the "Dak is Elite...Dak is Top5 opinions"...but rather just created their own threads to interact with like minded fans who want a different QB.....would the pro-Dakkers just let them have their own space to talk amongst themselves....or would you just jump in and call them all haters...and try and silence them?

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Yes he has…he certainly has played with rosters that were good enough

I just don’t know how realistic you are about winning with Allen Hurns as your number 1 or going into last with Lamb and no one else. I think they have been good enough to win in the first round but they were not good enough roster wise to beat Philly or 49ers….

 

[Vtwin]

Gentlemen....gentlemen!

I feel like this is devolving into a I'm Rubber You're Glue thingy

That was my entire point.

Trying to show this toxic lover how toxic and childish he is by playing his own game against him.

I'll stop now. Maybe I'll go out in the rain and pick up dog crap. At least something will get accomplished.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

But my question was....if the people in here who DON'T want Dak as the starting QB left the Pro-Dak threads alone, and didnt comment on the "Dak is Elite...Dak is Top5 opinions"...but rather just created their own threads to interact with like minded fans who want a different QB.....would the pro-Dakkers just let them have their own space to talk amongst themselves....or would you just jump in and call them all haters...and try and silence them?

I would. Some of the Anti Dak guys are some of the worst posters in this site. A lot it people have them on ignore.

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

That was my entire point.

Trying to show this toxic lover how toxic and childish he is by playing his own game against him.

I'll stop now. Maybe I'll go out in the rain and pick up dog crap. At least something will get accomplished.

I didn't say Stop!

I was doing a play-by-play.

I have him ahead 4 rounds to 3. You better come out swinging

 

[McKDaddy]

I'm on other sites where the majority of Cowboys fans still believe in Dak and this team. It's you guys in here who has constantly bashed him year after year while making some of the most ridiculous and misinformed statements. Nothing wrong if you don't like the player, but y'all don't stop. This has been going on for years now.

It's all been discussed a thousand times. Every argument for & every argument against. Why do you keep posting arguments "for" and then complain if anyone declines to agree?

Lots of other players, coaches, schemes, opponents, etc., to have meaningful conversations about.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

doesn't matter. somebody will make a video showing the exact opposite.

I am not a Bash Dak over Dallas Cult, but I don't think he is elite. there are only a couple of Elite QBs right now. some on the edge of being elite. so not considering him to be elite is not a knock. its a reality. he is good. sometimes great. he just has to find a way to get over the hump. that's all.

I don’t think the point of it was whether ir not he’s elite. Just where he compares to the “elite”. To me this so called elite group doesn’t exist. It’s Mahomes then everyone else. Josh Allen is not Mahomes. Maybe he will be someday. But Josh Allen is close to Derek Carr than he is Mahomes IMO.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Dak is not Elite. OMG, how many more Dak threads do we need. lets regurgegate all the same argument again.
training camp doesn't come soon enough.

I advise you to stop entering them.

 

[Vtwin]

I didn't say Stop!

I was doing a play-by-play.

I have him ahead 4 rounds to 3. You better come out swinging

He can have the win.

Our exchange exemplifies the old saying. 'Never get in the pen and wrestle a pig. You just get dirty and the pig likes it.'

 

[starfan1]

Dak is not Elite. OMG, how many more Dak threads do we need. lets regurgegate all the same argument again.
training camp doesn't come soon enough.

Keyshawn Johnson ,Kellerman and Jay williams ya thats really gonna change some minds. This one will be different. . I get it it he just post this nonsense in response to the other nonsense. By days end well have another nonsense thread or this one will be.. Its old cant wait till training camp starts so we can start with some more nonsense.

 

[starfan1]

I would. Some of the Anti Dak guys are some of the worst posters in this site. A lot it people have them on ignore.

as are some of the pro dak posters and im pro dak

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

I would. Some of the Anti Dak guys are some of the worst posters in this site. A lot it people have them on ignore.

Hmmmm....perhaps those of us who want something better at QB should just stay on this side down here...and you Pro-Dakkers should just stay up there and have ur own union....and we'll draw a line between us... the Maybe-DakSucks Line. Don't cross it.

All we want is our freedom to do things they way we think should be done.

Don't come down here and try to oppress us....just cause you think we're rebellious.

We don't take kindly to that....

 

[mcmvp]

Did you watch the video?

Anyone can put some NFL video clips together...voice them over and post it to YouTube. It doesn't mean they are worth listening to. This guy is only considering things at their most basic...it's surface level drivel with no substance behind it. I hope you didn't think this video supported anything....it doesn't

 

[CCBoy]

You do realize that for every one of these you post the idiot haters will find another one stating the opposite

This board has gotten toxic as hell and you’re not helping it

And no Dak isn’t elite but he’s good enough I ain’t even looked at the video

C'mon, who does that fool? One just doesn't hide behind partial truths. One points that out unless mischief is one's real motive. Hidden behind the excuse of grandeur.

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

He can have the win.

Our exchange exemplifies the old saying. 'Never get in the pen and wrestle a pig. You just get dirty and the pig likes it.'

That's the spirit. So what if he called you a childish idiot...and said you should revoke ur cowboy fandom? It's just words. And even though those words included "immature...stupid.....ignorant...." it's best to just tell him he's right.

You don't think he's rigjt though...do you? He seemed like he just wanted to silence you

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

as are some of the pro dak posters and im pro dak

I don’t see it. Maybe I have the pro guys on ignore.

But at the same time it’s a Cowboys site. I expect people to be pro their players even if at times it can be annoying. But that’s a huge difference between saying stuff like Cooper Rush is better than Dak. And it’s the same group of guys. The fact there’s even a anti/pro group is stupid in itself.

 

[starfan1]

I don’t see it. Maybe I have the pro guys on ignore.

But at the same time it’s a Cowboys site. I expect people to be pro their players even if at times it can be annoying. But that’s a huge difference between saying stuff like Cooper Rush is better than Dak. And it’s the same group of guys. The fact there’s even a anti/pro group is stupid in itself.

while i agree with you the pro dak guys are doing it to antagonize the anti daks and visa versa