Is Dak Prescott's contract actually that bad

Chasing6

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,463
Reaction score
6,416
In terms of overall QB play this season the top 15 list would arguably look something along the lines of:

Lamar Jackson
Josh Allen
Jared Goff
Jayden Daniels
Joe Burrow
Jalen Hurts
Patrick Mahomes
Justin Herbert
C J Stroud
Kyler Murray
Sam Darnold
Baker Mayfield
Kirk Cousins
Jordan Love
Matthew Stafford

A few quarterbacks can be moved around here and there plus there's a case for the likes of Purdy and Williams to be in the top 15 but in general, it's not an outlandish list.

The point being Dak Prescott is no where to be seen within the top 15 quarterbacks in the league this season and for good reason.

Realistically going forwards with the likes of Caleb Williams and Bo Nix likely to improve a whole lot more and even accounting for say Darnold, Mayfield and Cousins struggling to back up their form into next season and the potential of Stafford and/or Rodgers retiring, do people really see Prescott getting himself into the top 10 ranked quarterbacks next season?

In terms of big name quarterback contracts on the horizon how many are there? Purdy at the end of this season, C J Stroud likely in 2026 and perhaps Josh Allen at some point during that period to restructure his contract given he's only in the low 40s at this time and to spread the cap hit of his next contract with the Bills.

Other than that there are not too many more before Prescott's contract will be up for renewal again - perhaps his will be a year after a bunch of the top 10 guys. The point being that when we look back at the highest earning quarterbacks over the 9 years prior to Prescott's current contract expiring, he will have likely been either the highest earner or at least a top 3 earning QB over those 9 years! Astounding really given the horrific ROI in terms of relevant performance to the team winning important games against good teams. It also completely blows out the water the ridiculous notion/assertion that, "his contract will be around the 15th highest paid quarterback in a year or two" - no it will not!

I am very interested to find out how much Purdy is offered by the 49ers. I do not think it will be $60+ million a year. I think he will take a commercial view and be pleased to take a bit less to stay and play for a good team rather than earning more on a bad team. In those circumstances, I wouldn't be surprised if he accepted around $50 million a year. But who knows, the 49ers might be the next team to massively overpay for a solid NFL starting quarterback. Again, it is noticeable that his overall use and performance is increased when he scrambles and moves to acquire first downs or extend plays which leads me to my next point...

My final observation is that of the above top 10 ranked NFL quarterbacks in the league this season, only Goff lacks mobility. The other 9 can all move at will to extend plays and rush for a much needed first down. Same rules apply to the young quarterbacks coming through like Love, Nix and Williams. If you are planning to pay top dollar to a quarterback then surely they require some mobility in the modern NFL? If not then pay them around the $45-$50 million range to compensate for that to facilitate the payment of two stud running backs like Montgomery and Gibbs or draft a stud RB in the first round like Robinson...

Whichever way people try to dress it up, the latest Dak Prescott contract looks to have been an awful progress stopping decision and one that will kneecap the team for several years to come.

Fair play to him though as he will have brought in $400+ million over 9 years - Jerry must be in a whole world of pain right now!
It was not bad last time either, but Jerry restructured it and kicked the can down the road making it an albatross. He is sooner or later going to have a large dead cap hit because of it. The uneducated will blame Dak for it.
 

McKDaddy

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,552
Reaction score
10,209
@Swagger - If you'd like to conduct a real world simulation, I will sell you this brand new #2 pencil on an installment plan where you pay me $15,000 this year, $35,000 the following, $35,000 the following & $15,000 in year 4. At the end of that, you can report on the value you received for your investment and how it correlates to Dak's contract.

Please message me directly to set up your first ACH transfer to me.

I do these things because I care about education. For the brotherhood of learning!
 

zrinkill

Cowboy Fan
Messages
49,001
Reaction score
32,469
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
eb245708-e88e-4944-b4f1-9ffc18a62c59_text.gif
 

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,821
Reaction score
14,406
I remember the Stans telling me Goff and Stafford stink and Dak is way better …. meanwhile Stanford loses all his weapons but still finds ways to win on the road ….most them have disappeared though which is nice.


but yes the answer to this thread is yes
which games did stafford win without his weapons? only one i'm seeing is against the raiders where he threw for 150 yds and a pick
 

Chasing6

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,463
Reaction score
6,416
I remember the Stans telling me Goff and Stafford stink and Dak is way better …. meanwhile Stanford loses all his weapons but still finds ways to win on the road ….most them have disappeared though which is nice.


but yes the answer to this thread is yes
Just because a team wins, does not mean the QB found a way to do it. Sometimes teams win despite their QB.

Give me a break already.
 

Xelda

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,332
Reaction score
18,150
It's that bad. Please note his sudden down turn. That would not be the case if he were trying to get a new contract. He wouldn't have blown the playoffs if... never mind. Him telling fans they can jump ship if they want to would not have been said last year. I'm a Cowboys fan, can't change my stars.
 

thunderpimp91

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,925
Reaction score
19,095
The Dak contract is horrible for a few reasons that dont even involve Dak including that Jerry/Stephen horribly mismanaged the previous contract leaving a total of $335M ($67M per year avg) in cap hits on the books through 2028.

The best thing the Cowboys could have done was let Dak go, eat the bulk of the remaining cap hit this year and next, and then truly commit to a rebuild. Reality is this team is not good enough to actually compete for a championship and Jerry seems to have zero interest in actually having an all in type of year the Cowboys would need to stack the roster for a serious run.
 

Chasing6

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,463
Reaction score
6,416
Do we have 1 dominant position group on this team?

Do we have an above average position group on this team?

Do we have an average position group on this team?

Seeing the problem yet?
 

Cmac

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,119
Reaction score
8,734
How come almost every other post you make you mention Romo?
Not quite......you're actually making my point.....High Sensitivity surfaces when I'm simply comparing our QB plights/history/similarities......Romo/Dak. Are there differences, beyond subjective feelings?
 

Cmac

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,119
Reaction score
8,734
Romo has been gone for years, leave it be, who cares. Dak is the one under scrutiny.
We all have choices 5Stars....I typically don't start threads....I chime in like you.
Oops.....I bring Romo up sometimes, because there's a few that get somewhat sensitive. Similarly with Witten, similar, but not so much with Sean Lee, and similar with LVE, just not to the degree Romo talk becomes. The Romo love is greater than the 3-ring Troy Aikman love, by far. Hmmm.

Maybe, many on here didn't see the full career, maybe just too young. Romo is a "Made for TV Movie" sequence.......unheralded & undrafted QB finally getting a chance, giving us good in games, giving us bad in some, giving us bad in big moments, trying to help a team, and giving us frustration like our current QB. Romo is Folklore on this board. And believe it or not.....I liked, hoped, and cheered for Romo too, just like I'm trying the same for Dak.....2 QBs of ours that are part of the drought. They are connected in this infamy.




OIP.R1m9fCzDsWPLab8ptsVGCgHaFc
 

Redsfan_83

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,133
Reaction score
5,109
Well in 2-3 years' time it won't look all that if Dak can even stay healthy enough to fail at the forward pass. Honestly, I don't think it's the contract we all hate, it's the quality of play from our QB t
 
Top