Is Dak ready to prove he is elite? (question 4 of 20)

[PAPPYDOG]

https://www.dallascowboys.com/news/4-is-dak-ready-to-prove-he-s-an-elite-qb

Oh boy...
Will we get the typical stuff or can they actually discuss this with level heads.

Consensus from the 3 guys at the Death Star (Frisco Ship) is stats shows he is, but win payoff games to be put in that category from fans and media.

GL with that.........

 

[PackerNation]

Only 3 QBs (Rodgers, Mahomes, and Brady) are elite right now.

Dak doesn't possesses the mental or physical ability to ever be at the elite level of QBs.

Herbert, Allen, and Burrow are the QBs right now that seem to have the best chance to join the "elite" category.

Allen is elite. How dare you place him with Burrow and Herbert. Josh arrived already, he is a made man. Burrow and Herbert are not near his level.

And don't tell me he needs a Super Bowl ring to be elite. All you need to do is watch him play to know he is elite.

So, the list of the elite currently is:
Rodgers
Mahomes
Allen
Brady

Dak will be 29 in a couple days. The ship has sailed on him becoming elite. He is what he is. Better than average QB.

 

[Ranching]

LOL

He can’t “prove” to be what he’s not

I got a kick outta seeing who gave you likes....lol!!

 

[blueblood70]

Is Kyler murray and Watson who make a ton more?? they've done as little or less than Dak.,.and??

did sam Bradford earn his money(rookie then other monies after) and ever became even average? many and i mean Many qbs make far too much money and most like almost ALL are not elite or better then dak in many cases

so lets see that makes DAK about 7th on the money list and hes ranked around 7th in the league maybe 10th

so his money is in line with his ranking and production. What the freaking issues hater trolls??.
100s upon 100s of QBs over decades have got market setting money and WERE NOT elite..

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

There aren't many elite qbs in the league.

 

[raven55]

elite for dak that' a dream, 1 his whole arm now is in question, 2 accuracy forget it hit and miss, 3 if you really get down to it all he's still a fourth round qb sorry, 4 when he needs to lift his offense up againist average or better defenses its not happening. At best he's a good qb and that's all, so face it he's jerry's or steveie's qb because of the contract and that's all so get ready for great high lights againist hurt or deplented defenses. AND LOSSES other wise

 

[phildadon86]

https://www.dallascowboys.com/news/4-is-dak-ready-to-prove-he-s-an-elite-qb

Oh boy...
Will we get the typical stuff or can they actually discuss this with level heads.

Consensus from the 3 guys at the Death Star (Frisco Ship) is stats shows he is, but win payoff games to be put in that category from fans and media.

For Romo everything clicked in his 7th year. So lets see. I have hope.

 

[phildadon86]

Only 3 QBs (Rodgers, Mahomes, and Brady) are elite right now.

Dak doesn't possesses the mental or physical ability to ever be at the elite level of QBs.

Herbert, Allen, and Burrow are the QBs right now that seem to have the best chance to join the "elite" category.

So who was playing QB for the Cowboys weeks 1-6 last season?

If he doesn't possess the mental or physical ability it couldn't have been Dak right?

He does possess the ability. He just needs to be consistent

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

So who was playing QB for the Cowboys weeks 1-6 last season?

If he doesn't possess the mental or physical ability it couldn't have been Dak right?

He does possess the ability. He just needs to be consistent

He will never really be what you already believe him to be.

 

[phildadon86]

He will never really be what you already believe him to be.

Why cant you just answer the question?

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Why cant you just answer the question?

Because it's stupid.

You taking 6 games and presenting it as the "real Dak" while ignoring 6 years is literal elementary level thinking.

 

[Oz-of-Cowboy-Country]

Dak just needs an elite defense year in year out, elite coaching year in year out, and elite play calling year in year out. In other words, he needs everything Tom Brady has had during his whole career.

 

[erod]

This fanbase is so delusional.

Hes going into his 7th season as a starter. He is who he is. An average QB masquerading as a franchise guy

....who's more injury prone than Romo at this point in their careers.

 

[CowboyRoy]

LOL

He can’t “prove” to be what he’s not

The nature of the question must make you feel foolish?

The question wasnt................Can Dak prove this year that he isnt average?

Gotta hurt a big to know lost the Dak argument so badly?

 

[CowboyRoy]

Needs to improve on to take his drop, hit that back foot and cut it loose. He also needs a lot of film work on what to look for pre snap and where he should be trying to go with the football.
His footwork needs a lot of improvement and it would help his accuracy. So no I don't think he is ready yet or if he will ever be.

Maybe if he fixes all these problem his offense can be #1 in the NFL in points and yards?

I guess there is always hope right?

 

[CowboyRoy]

His first 7 games were elite last year.
Can he be consistent is the BIG question???

Winning doesnt make you elite. It can make your team elite.

 

[CowboyRoy]

His first 7 games were elite last year.
Can he be consistent is the BIG question???

Cant be consistently elite with bad Oline play AND a poor run game.

 

[JoeKing]

It's hard to "prove" you are something you are not. Dak can get us as far as we want but that won't make him elite. He's just not!

 

[phildadon86]

Because it's stupid.

You taking 6 games and presenting it as the "real Dak" while ignoring 6 years is literal elementary level thinking.

But you said he isn't physically or mentally capable. Those 6 games prove he is. So who is being elementary here? Its simple logic. If he wasnt capable. Those 6 games dont happen.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

But you said he isn't physically or mentally capable. Those 6 games prove he is. So who is being elementary here? Its simple logic. If he wasnt capable. Those 6 games dont happen.

He's not.

Are you still trying to figure out the first 3 games of 2018 Ryan Fitzpatrick is the real Ryan Fitzpatrick or not?