Is it good for Kitna to be up top during games

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Parcells4Life, Jun 13, 2019.

  1. Parcells4Life

    Parcells4Life Well-Known Member

    2,607 Messages
    3,922 Likes Received
    With Moore on the sidelines during games, they’re going to have Kitna up top to read defenses. I would think you’d want the opposite because as the QB coach doesn’t he need to be as close as possible to see Daks mechanics?

    If his stride is off by half a step, I’d think it’d be easier to communicate that in person rather than over the phone.
     
    DuncanIso and Ranching like this.
  2. Ekspozed

    Ekspozed Well-Known Member

    250 Messages
    301 Likes Received
    I read it's Moore's preference to be on the sideline, as close and personal with dak as he can.

    While I think kitna will be and already has been good for dak, if it's truly Moore's offense you have to let him do it his way. Kitna has a lot of years experience, it may prove useful having him up top seeing everything.
     
    Proof, OmerV, ShortRound131 and 2 others like this.
  3. visionary

    visionary Well-Known Member

    16,860 Messages
    14,826 Likes Received
    Moore needs to be on the sideline in Daks ear
     
    ShortRound131 and SoupcanSam like this.
  4. SoupcanSam

    SoupcanSam Well-Known Member

    4,326 Messages
    6,034 Likes Received
    I like it the way it is. Dak can benefit more from Moore down bottom than kitna, especially since this is a new offense.

    Something as simple as correcting mechanics isnt as important as getting this offense correct in game.

    Imo no amount of mechanic info from kitna will help Dak once the real shells start flying out on the battle field.

    Teach Dak now and hope he can maintain it on the field. If Dak screws up then he needs to find a way to adjust without needing a babysitter.

    He is too many years in to even still be having these little problems.
     
  5. GMO415

    GMO415 Well-Known Member

    6,522 Messages
    11,946 Likes Received
    Does a QB coach even need to be present on game day? The water boy is more valuable
     
    links18 likes this.
  6. jrumann59

    jrumann59 Well-Known Member

    11,608 Messages
    5,705 Likes Received
    It depends on how involved in the offense the QB coach is. In the NFL most OCs were QB coaches first.
     
    CouchCoach likes this.
  7. CouchCoach

    CouchCoach Well-Known Member

    16,558 Messages
    27,635 Likes Received
    Seems to be the personal preference of the coaches and one doesn't seem to be better. If I were the play caller, I would prefer to be up top because that is the angle I am used to watching games. But, Kitna and Moore will be in constant communication with what they are seeing.

    That time that Sean Payton had to be up top because of the leg injury, they weren't near as sharp.
     
    conner01 and dogberry like this.
  8. CouchCoach

    CouchCoach Well-Known Member

    16,558 Messages
    27,635 Likes Received
    The relationship between Kitna and Dak is different than some and he is critical to the operation. Dak will have a second set of QB's eyes to assist him.
     
  9. Ranching

    Ranching Well-Known Member

    21,699 Messages
    56,089 Likes Received
    I had my OC on the field my first 6 years. I had a very experienced coach up top. The next 4 years my OC went up. We were throwing much more those years and I felt he could see the field better. Brought the OC back down my last two years. I had just hired him and I felt he needed to be close to my QB. We had success both ways. Kitna had more experience than Moore so I think it the right move.
     
  10. links18

    links18 Well-Known Member

    18,281 Messages
    11,895 Likes Received
    I think people overstate the importance of the QB coach on game day. But whatever, a set of eyes up top cant hurt, I guess.
     
  11. Techsass

    Techsass Well-Known Member

    1,736 Messages
    2,123 Likes Received
    I'm not sure what a QB coach actually does, but I would think he's probably more involved with practice than he is during the game.
     
    jazzcat22 likes this.
  12. jazzcat22

    jazzcat22 Well-Known Member

    37,281 Messages
    36,260 Likes Received
    Yes I believe this is correct.
    The QB coach should have all the mechanics and such worked out in TC and the off season. They probably have limited time during the season as that time is spent on the game plan. However in film reviews, they can bring up any inconsistencies to adjust. As opposed to do it during the game. Then he is thinking of that issue and not just executing the plays.
    So with Kitna up top maybe he can see how it develops better, and the can communicate by headsets if he sees something during the game. He can mention it, or make a note to correct in the next practice.

    Some coaches prefer to communicate one one one or with groups, as opposed relaying messages to the sideline. What they feel comfortable with is fine. Just make it work.
     
    Techsass likes this.
  13. CowboysFaninHouston

    CowboysFaninHouston CowboysFaninDC

    9,385 Messages
    3,690 Likes Received
    as a former coach....you don't fix the mechanics during the game....that's when you play and focus on playing...you don't see bad mechancis during a game when all heck is breaking loose....you watch tape together with the player, and then take what you learned to the practice field......you fix the mechanics during practices, off season, etc....I think the arrangement is fine that way....
     
    Cover 2, dogberry, GenoT and 2 others like this.
  14. cern

    cern Well-Known Member

    7,585 Messages
    10,027 Likes Received
    the idea is for kitna to relay to moore what he sees {or saw} from above, especially right after a play. this way moore can send in the next play even before the wr's have returned to the huddle. keeps the defense from changing players. much the way it's done by sean mcvay in los angeles. should be very successful. I like the idea.
     
    CowboyRoy and Techsass like this.
  15. Jake

    Jake Curmudgeon

    14,925 Messages
    26,396 Likes Received
    You work on mechanics in practice. You don't monkey around with them during games.

    Besides, if someone needs to yell at Dak on the sidelines to appease some fans Kris Richard can do it.
     
    Cover 2 and Techsass like this.
  16. Corso

    Corso Offseason mode... sleepy time

    20,140 Messages
    34,261 Likes Received
    For his allergies? Definitely.
     
  17. Oz-of-Cowboy-Country

    Oz-of-Cowboy-Country Well-Known Member

    1,588 Messages
    1,862 Likes Received
    Moore is going to call plays. The play caller should always be on the sideline. IMO. So the QB can communicate with him about what's happening after the snap and go over photos together.
     
    Cover 2 and CowboyRoy like this.
  18. Swanny

    Swanny Well-Known Member

    1,831 Messages
    2,443 Likes Received
    You can see mechanics better from up top.
     
  19. The Quest for Six

    The Quest for Six Well-Known Member

    13,914 Messages
    8,737 Likes Received
    that's why they invented headsets......I'd prefer Moore up in the booth to see the whole field and the defensive alignments.....
     
  20. DuncanIso

    DuncanIso Well-Known Member

    1,184 Messages
    924 Likes Received
    Yes. He’s probably helping read the defense for Dak, something Dak was not good at.
     

Share This Page