Is Lamb 88 a 1 WR?

CT Dal Fan

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,668
Reaction score
20,558
Well, was Amari Cooper a number one receiver last year? Can you put him in the same class as DeVante Adams, Cooper Kupp, Justin Jefferson, DeAndre Hopkins, etc.?

Now it's time to see if CeeDee Lamb can be in that class. Dallas needs to find out because you don't spend first round picks on complementary pieces.
 

SteveTheCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,697
Reaction score
13,265
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Well, was Amari Cooper a number one receiver last year? Can you put him in the same class as DeVante Adams, Cooper Kupp, Justin Jefferson, DeAndre Hopkins, etc.?

Now it's time to see if CeeDee Lamb can be in that class. Dallas needs to find out because you don't spend first round picks on complementary pieces.
You have to have a 1 QB to make good use of a 1 WR.

CD is a wiggling speedster. If you make him target the ball for receiving, he isn't going to make great use of YAC.
If we had Brady who could throw him the ball in stride...he'd be not only Cowboys 1 but 1 NFL
 

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,966
Reaction score
13,806
Ben Dinucci has played in 3 games in his career. CeeDee has 27 total yards catching balls from him in those games. What are you on about?

uhh fairly clear bro. ceedee’s rookie year was better than devonta’s w/ those games along with gilbert and dalton (and in 16 games) are you ok?
 

quickccc

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,157
Reaction score
14,050
A true lead no. 1 feature is about
- Mentality,..
- not wearing down..
- coming up big and consistently in the clutch moments ...
- and being able to regularly defeat the opposition top cover coverage CB across from him ...

I'm not sold " yet" on Lamb as a true lead No.1 ...but a lot can be contributed to the OC and QB ...

This year with Gallup still rehabbing, and no Cooper, we'll see teams assigning their lead CB to Lamb, and bracket coverage around Lamb ,.. we'll have to see how it fairs out ..
 

DanA

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,971
Reaction score
5,788
He’s currently a mid-tier no.1 receiver but has potential to be elite and his trajectory is promising.
 

Calvin2Tony2Emmitt2Julius

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,648
Reaction score
1,922
DAN A Don't let a little logic get in the way of a little Neanderthal Drooling OK.

32 teams , then you used "Logically Speaking" ***????

Dissing you own teams players so you can be right is a must. Sheesh the nerve of some people. Logically Speaking!!! You Crack me up
 

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,594
Reaction score
47,449
There are 32 teams so logically speaking 32 no.1 receivers. I would put Lamb about somewhere 18-25 (ie: mid tier) and well within no.1 WR territory.
You are pre anointing.
 

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,966
Reaction score
13,806
Circumstances do not dictate what you claim they do

so ceedee playing with a carousel of bums as a number 2 and producing a better year than devonta in 17 games don’t support my claim? lol sounds good bruh
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,909
Reaction score
11,882
so ceedee playing with a carousel of bums as a number 2 and producing a better year than devonta in 17 games don’t support my claim? lol sounds good bruh

He played in an offense run by Dak Prescott, Andy Dalton, and (briefly) by Ben Dinucci that put up 4161 passing yards in 16 games in 2020. What’s disingenuous of your Ben Dinucci proclamation is CeeDee had 433 of his 900 yards in his rookie year in the first 5 games. Nearly half came from Dak, and he only got about 500 all the rest of the season over the next 12! So no, he didn’t do very well at all with Dinucci and Dalton.

DeVonta did not have a Dak Prescott being down by 3 scores every game to hyper-inflate his numbers over the first third of the season. Last year, DeVonta played in an offense that put up only 3404 passing yards in 17 games. It’s a completely different style of offense that doesn’t promote big receiving yards. We run on first, second, and third down. You don’t put up any stats if the team doesn’t throw the ball.

Extrapolate Devonta Smith’s 916 receiving yards to the difference in passing the two teams had and he pulls out 1119 receiving yards, trumping both CeeDee’s first AND second seasons.

Now, look deeper: CeeDee Lamb’s yards per receptions are 12.6 and 13.9 his first two years while averaging 8.8 yards per target. DeVonta Smith’s is 14.3 in only his rookie year, despite averaging that very same 8.8 ypt. They’re asked to run the same routes, and Devonta is getting more out of them.

Flip the receivers’ situations and Devonta blows CeeDee out of the water. Best part is Devonta has an opportunity to build on his rookie year and blossom into something more. CeeDee is still working on that, leaving something to be desired from year 2.

He’s not the best WR in the East just because he plays for my team, he’s the best WR in the East because he’s earned it. If CeeDee wants it, he needs to earn it.
 
Last edited:

DanA

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,971
Reaction score
5,788
You are pre anointing.

I don't think so.

In 2021 he was:
  • 16th for receiving yards
  • 24th for targets
  • 22nd for receptions
  • 25th for TD's

And that includes TE's....He's squarely in the mid-range no.1 receiver category. Not a star that can carry an offense but good enough to be a no.1.
 

DanA

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,971
Reaction score
5,788
He played in an offense run by Dak Prescott, Andy Dalton, and (briefly) by Ben Dinucci that put up 4161 passing yards in 16 games in 2020. What’s disingenuous of your Ben Dinucci proclamation is CeeDee had 433 of his 900 yards in his rookie year in the first 5 games. Nearly half came from Dak, and he only got about 500 all the rest of the season over the next 12! So no, he didn’t do very well at all with Dinucci and Dalton.

DeVonta did not have a Dak Prescott being down by 3 scores every game to hyper-inflate his numbers over the first third of the season. Last year, DeVonta played in an offense that put up only 3404 passing yards in 17 games. It’s a completely different style of offense that doesn’t promote big receiving yards. We run on first, second, and third down. You don’t put up any stats if the team doesn’t throw the ball.

Extrapolate Devonta Smith’s 916 receiving yards to the difference in passing the two teams had and he pulls out 1119 receiving yards, trumping both CeeDee’s first AND second seasons.

Now, look deeper: CeeDee Lamb’s yards per receptions are 12.6 and 13.9 his first two years while averaging 8.8 yards per target. DeVonta Smith’s is 14.3 in only his rookie year, despite averaging that very same 8.8 ypt. They’re asked to run the same routes, and Devonta is getting more out of them.

Flip the receivers’ situations and Devonta blows CeeDee out of the water. Best part is Devonta has an opportunity to build on his rookie year and blossom into something more. CeeDee is still working on that, leaving something to be desired from year 2.

He’s not the best WR in the East just because he plays for my team, he’s the best WR in the East because he’s earned it. If CeeDee wants it, he needs to earn it.


That's a lot of hot air trying to suggest that, what is basically a marginal call, is definitive. Devonta was force feed in his 17th game to get Philly’s rookie reviving record and it was still short of what Lamb did in 16 games. He was certainly no better than Lamb in his rookie season, and I see no reason he will be better than him year 2.
 
Last edited:

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,966
Reaction score
13,806
DeVonta did not have a Dak Prescott being down by 3 scores every game to hyper-inflate his numbers over the first third of the season. Last year, DeVonta played in an offense that put up only 3404 passing yards in 17 games. It’s a completely different style of offense that doesn’t promote big receiving yards. We run on first, second, and third down. You don’t put up any stats if the team doesn’t throw the ball.

Extrapolate Devonta Smith’s 916 receiving yards to the difference in passing the two teams had and he pulls out 1119 receiving yards, trumping both CeeDee’s first AND second seasons.

Now, look deeper: CeeDee Lamb’s yards per receptions are 12.6 and 13.9 his first two years while averaging 8.8 yards per target. DeVonta Smith’s is 14.3 in only his rookie year, despite averaging that very same 8.8 ypt. They’re asked to run the same routes, and Devonta is getting more out of them.

Flip the receivers’ situations and Devonta blows CeeDee out of the water. Best part is Devonta has an opportunity to build on his rookie year and blossom into something more. CeeDee is still working on that, leaving something to be desired from year 2.

He’s not the best WR in the East just because he plays for my team, he’s the best WR in the East because he’s earned it. If CeeDee wants it, he needs to earn it.[/QUOTE]


cool story bruh. wake me up when it doesn’t require extrapolation and numbers aren’t deflated by 11 games of bums. you could have stopped at “he’s not the best receiver in the east” because it sounds to me like you’re saying the 14.9 ypc ceedee avgd (as the number 2) with Dak his rookie season easily trumps Devontas. Along with his total numbers (yds, tds, receptions etc) in less games with said bums the remainder. yeesh almost too easy to make a very clear declaration lol. but hey. let’s just put this to bed until projections aren’t necessary. for now we’ll just go with irrefutable facts if that’s cool
 
Last edited:

Redsfan_83

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,569
Reaction score
3,853
No clue if this is mentioned already though, but in all honesty what use is a WR1 on our team? We have RB1 (for our purposes) and once taken out of the game we're done. The only way Dak can succeed is if he has multiple options (even though he also struggles at finding these), with a WR1 Dak is a dead giveaway, and this player will become null and void right now
 
Top