Is Michael Gallup the best WR from his draft class?

[CATCH17]

I know we’re Cowboys fans so we will probably have a bias but if you’re picking between Gallup, Ridley, and DJ Moore I think you have to go Gallup, right?







Gallup also had 1100 yards receiving while missing some time as well.

Could he get by as a #1 WR in an offense at this point? Probably.. Maybe not for Dallas because we need so many weapons around the QB but for most teams he could probably do it.

 

[G2]

He's done a really good job IMO.

 

[Kaiser]

Great point, fans always get caught up with their pet cats like Ridley but Gallup may very well be better than anyone in that class - plus he was a value pick that dropped to them in the 3rd round.

 

[KJJ]

Statistically DJ Moore has more catches and yards his first two seasons. Between Ridley and Gallup, Moore has had the worst QB situation.

 

[Hennessy_King]

I know we’re Cowboys fans so we will probably have a bias but if you’re picking between Gallup, Ridley, and DJ Moore I think you have to go Gallup, right?







Gallup also had 1100 yards receiving while missing some time as well.

Could he get by as a #1 WR in an offense at this point? Probably.. Maybe not for Dallas because we need so many weapons around the QB but for most teams he could probably do it.

I wanted dj moore or rashaan evans over LVE.

 

[ClappingCarrot]

DJ will be just fine in Carolina, and Calvin has had a nice ability finding the end zone himself. One guy battled some injuries last season, the other had 2nd and 3rd string QB's throwing to him, and still finished with over 1,000 yards. DJ does have a serious fumbling problem though.

Gallup, for where he was selected, was a steal. I'm looking for him to breakout and set the field on fire in 2020.

 

[DFWJC]

LVE aside, It was a deep WR class and the Cowboys were smart not to reach for one in the 1st round like some where screaming for.

All three of those guys are really good. Plus several others as well.
Cortland Sutton
DJ Chark
Etc

 

[John813]

IMO I think Moore is the best among the three, but there's no big drop in talent in that group.

Value wise, Gallup in the 3rd was great

 

[Stash]

I know we’re Cowboys fans so we will probably have a bias but if you’re picking between Gallup, Ridley, and DJ Moore I think you have to go Gallup, right?







Gallup also had 1100 yards receiving while missing some time as well.

Could he get by as a #1 WR in an offense at this point? Probably.. Maybe not for Dallas because we need so many weapons around the QB but for most teams he could probably do it.

Courtland Sutton has been slightly better to this point.

 

[SackMaster]

Maybe?

But as long as he is productive in Dallas (which might be one of the few things that the majority of this forum's members agree on) what does it matter if he is the "Best" or not?

 

[darthseinfeld]

Moore, Sutton and Gallup are neck and neck. Ridley is good, but he didnt make the jump like the other 3 did

 

[armadillooutlaw]

The fact that Gallup's in the discussion at all is really awesome considering where he was drafted.
Almost makes you want to think hard about the Cooper decision.
Hmm... torn.

 

[darthseinfeld]

Courtland Sutton has been slightly better to this point.

I think Sutton is better suited to be an alpha dog #1. Gallup is 1A or 1B type IMO

 

[beware_d-ware]

Gallup's good, but Moore is way better. He just put up more yardage than Gallup with Kyle Allen as his quarterback.

 

[darthseinfeld]

The fact that Gallup's in the discussion at all is really awesome considering where he was drafted.
Almost makes you want to think hard about the Cooper decision.
Hmm... torn.

1000 yard recieving season in year 2 from a 3rd round pick is a huge score

 

[CATCH17]

Maybe?

But as long as he is productive in Dallas (which might be one of the few things that the majority of this forum's members agree on) what does it matter if he is the "Best" or not?

Because it’s fun to look back on players we debated about for months before the draft...

 

[CATCH17]

Moore, Sutton and Gallup are neck and neck. Ridley is good, but he didnt make the jump like the other 3 did

I didn’t like Ridley or Moore..

Ridley just didn’t look athletic enough and he was older.. He’s a few months younger then Amari I believe.

Moore.. I just didn’t like his style..

I did like Sutton a lot.

I couldn’t figure out Gallup.. There was basically no holes in his game. He did have a nice game against Alabama.. I’ve just never known what this guys true upside is but he looks like the most pure WR out of all 4 of those guys.. Like Pierre Garçonish.

 

[Typhus]

LVE aside, It was a deep WR class and the Cowboys were smart not to reach for one in the 1st round like some where screaming for.

All three of those guys are really good. Plus several others as well.
Cortland Sutton
DJ Chark
Etc

Im glad we drafted Gallup, but Sutton and Chark are very solid as well.
Getting Gallup in the 3rd was the steal of our draft.

 

[SackMaster]

Because it’s fun to look back on players we debated about for months before the draft...

I can respect that.

I apologize for being a bit quick on the trigger, but more times than not on this board, it seems that if a player is not the "best at his position" then most members tend to treat that player as one of the worst in the league.

I'll shut up on this topic now unless someone says something I find suspect.

 

[CATCH17]

Gallup's good, but Moore is way better. He just put up more yardage than Gallup with Kyle Allen as his quarterback.

Nothing about DJ Moore screams way better then Gallup.